AntarcticPilot
Well-known member
I'd agree. A day boat is much more fun. However you won't find many very secondhand caravans on sites for the OP's budget. The lake isn't about passage-making though. Some days with a steady Westerly you can fly down the lake and back on a reach in a few hours. Other times it can take you half a day to get a mile. I have sailed at less than a knot quite often (some may call it "drift").
If your aim is to spend a day sailing, and maybe a night. You can enjoy the lake for what it is. No planning for tides. Turn up and sail.
Entirely agree - I'm not in any way denigrating sailing on a lake! But a 30' boat, which is what the OP proposes, seems the wrong kind of boat. It's too big to poke into small bays or narrow passages, and less manoeverable in a tight spot - especially for a novice. It's ideal for my kind of sailing, where I hope to sleep in a different place each night I'm on holiday, and where sea-keeping ability is important. But it's not better or worse, or right and wrong - it's just different choices and styles.
Not much need to plan for tides on the Clyde either! It only gets important if you're heading round the Mull of Kintyre and up the West Coast.