Pitting on an iron keel

vyv_cox

Well-known member
Joined
16 May 2001
Messages
25,463
Location
France, sailing Aegean Sea.
coxeng.co.uk
Just out of interest Vyv, would hot-dipping in Zinc when the keel is still hot from casting be a long (enough) term answer to justify the cost?

In theory yes, provided the temperature was high enough. Based on my regalvanised chain it might last 10 years. The practicalities might make this a difficult process, assuming most keels are sand-cast.
 

Ruffles

Active member
Joined
26 Feb 2004
Messages
3,044
Location
Boat: Portsmouth, Us: Stewkley
www.soulbury.demon.co.uk
In theory yes, provided the temperature was high enough. Based on my regalvanised chain it might last 10 years. The practicalities might make this a difficult process, assuming most keels are sand-cast.

ISTR galvanisers charge by the weight!!!

BTW, do cost up the work you are about to do on your keel. The last time I did mine it was a filthy and tedious job and cost me several hundred quid in epoxy primer.
 

Birdseye

Well-known member
Joined
9 Mar 2003
Messages
28,146
Location
s e wales
Visit site
Just out of interest Vyv, would hot-dipping in Zinc when the keel is still hot from casting be a long (enough) term answer to justify the cost?

Had a hot dip galv plant in my factory. You wouldnt need the keel hot from casting - in fact it would need to be stripped back to bare metal which it isnt "as cast". In use the duration would depend on abrasion but you would still have to antifoul and I dont know enough about antifoul paint so say how well that would get on with galv. If its anything like my lead keel, then coppercoat wouldnt work well.

But the main issue by a long way would be the cost of galvanising a keel. I'm pretty much out of touch with current prices but a quick google suggest around £1 per kg.
 

Kukri

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2008
Messages
15,568
Location
East coast UK. Mostly. Sometimes the Philippines
Visit site
Had a hot dip galv plant in my factory. You wouldnt need the keel hot from casting - in fact it would need to be stripped back to bare metal which it isnt "as cast". In use the duration would depend on abrasion but you would still have to antifoul and I dont know enough about antifoul paint so say how well that would get on with galv. If its anything like my lead keel, then coppercoat wouldnt work well.

But the main issue by a long way would be the cost of galvanising a keel. I'm pretty much out of touch with current prices but a quick google suggest around £1 per kg.

I do, though. We once bought a ship that had been built - very slowly, very carefully - in Peru, a country not known for shipbuilding, under the excellent supervision of a firm of Norwegian naval architects who had thoughtfully specified the most expensive of everything. It would be cynical of me to suggest that they might have been on commision. She had 3,700 miles on the clock when she was arrested by the High Court, on her maiden voyage, in darkest Liverpool, and we bought her from the Admiralty Marshal.

Her builders had thought that it would be a good idea to zinc spray the whole external hull. It wasn’t. Paint doesn’t stick to galvanising under water; it exfoliates. Chain goes from wet to dry, and isn't painted; a hull or a keel stays wet and is painted.

We had to blast the lot off back to SA 2.5 and epoxy everything. Good ship once we had her sorted.

800px-Sph495gTauranga_Chief_%28RP1%29.JPG
 
Last edited:

GTom

Well-known member
Joined
12 Jun 2017
Messages
959
Visit site
Had a hot dip galv plant in my factory. You wouldnt need the keel hot from casting - in fact it would need to be stripped back to bare metal which it isnt "as cast". In use the duration would depend on abrasion but you would still have to antifoul and I dont know enough about antifoul paint so say how well that would get on with galv. If its anything like my lead keel, then coppercoat wouldnt work well.

But the main issue by a long way would be the cost of galvanising a keel. I'm pretty much out of touch with current prices but a quick google suggest around £1 per kg.

Thought about galvanising, is it £1 per kg keel weight? Sounds like a dealbreaker to me. :(
 

anoccasionalyachtsman

Well-known member
Joined
15 Jun 2015
Messages
4,173
Visit site
Surely the £ per unit mass thing is just a guide? The amount of zinc used will depend on the surface area of the object. Mental arithmetic says that a 1,000kg keel would have the same area as about 60m of 6mm chain, the mass of which is about 50kg. If I were foolish enough to ignore Minn's experience I'd be negotiating.
 
Top