Greenheart
Well-known member
My take on this is motor sailers are aimed at the older sailor who perhaps doesn't want to be bashed about in the elements anymore...
Even before my teens, I never understood why yachts with no weather protection are assumed to be what any generation wants.
It's very irritating. By next spring, I should have enough to buy a Centaur - not a tragically neglected Centaur, but a nice one. And it'll be tempting, because they're definitely good boats for not a lot of money...
...but they're also as limited in terms of poor-weather appeal, as the dinghy I already own. If I wanted to put on layers of purpose-designed gear in order to sit outdoors in comfortless low-season British conditions, I already have a boat to do that in. Why would I buy a much bigger one if it doesn't provide even as much weather protection as the cheapest, oldest car?
There are sometimes 1970s Fisher 25s on the market at a shade under £20,000. That's almost encouragingly cheap, but it's still the same money as two really clean, re-engined Centaurs.
Rather surprisingly, I realised a few years ago that the only yacht I've ever seen whose accommodation I would happily move into without planning to modify, is Westerly's mid-eighties Konsort Duo. I would kill for one. It's perfect!
Not even a moment of the designer's time has been spent trying to beautify her - she looks like a slabby, overheight, mid-seventies pre-flybridge river-cruiser, with mast and sails added as an afterthought. But the fact that the Konsort hull was proven before Westerly ever thought of adding an inside helm, or of setting up the accommodation just for the comfort of a cruising couple, means it works as a sailboat in spite of being primarily a comfort boat.
The state of motorsailer construction and purchase is very sad. British yachtsmen seem as self-deluding as ever, determinedly buying open-cockpit boats that will be comfortless to sail here for five months out of twelve. The fact that old motorsailers command solid prices while same-size same-age no-protection designs lose value, shows that people want comfort. Unfortunately the people driving new-yacht sales are persuaded by marketing that the exposure is worth it. What can that be, except wilful daftness?