Round Britain day 52

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
6,152
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
Another rough beat with a critical breakage.

The tides meant a lunchtime start at the earliest to leave Kinlockbervie. Got slightly delayed as chatting with the owners of an Oceanus 473. Then I decided the wind had dropped enough so I fly the drone round the harbour. Finally slipped at 13.55. Slowly motored out and the wind seemed a lot stronger so decided on a double reef for the main. The direction was SW, so another beat in stronger winds. Most of the time it was a force 6, but 7 at times. To be able to clear Stoer Head meant sailing on port tack on about 260 for 3½ hours. The tide was being helpful and pushing me southward. When I reached a tacking angle of about 110 degrees to Stoer Head, I tacked on to starboard. This was more comfortable as I was slicing the waves rather than punching in to them.

After about a mile a critical part broke, the pin on the tiller arm to hold the ram. Am I pushing the boat too hard? Are some parts breaking due to prolonged useage? It seems I am becoming a long term test bed for parts to see when they will break. I am beginning to feel slightly jinxed. I will check in the morning if I have a spare one onboard, if not then I will have to reshape a bolt using the multitool and Dremel to have a rounded end. So, I may not be sailing tomorrow as planned.

It was back to hand steering again. The helm is relatively light most of the time, so not really a problem. The new rope on the tiller clutch worked fine when I needed it. There was certainly a lot of heavy spray at times and I am pleased to say the rubber flaps I fitted round the halyard slots in the spray rail seemed to be doing the trick. No water appears to have run across the headlining in the main cabin. Yippee.

The tack was just about right when I reached Stoer Head as I was about ¾ mile to windward and just needed to continue on the same course. Well the wind started to be kind and instead of just laying the course, it veered about 30 degrees and when the windward distance increased to about a mile I decided I could crack the sheets slightly. Silly move as the wind decided to back again by 30 degrees, so had to sheet in again. Slowly the wind then decided to drop, so I unrolled the genoa to a single reef. Later it increased a bit and veered as well. I was on a close reach and it felt great. Then as I approached Lochinver I turned on to a reach and then a broad reach as I entered. After running off for a bit I then turned in to wind to drop the main and continued on under genoa. After pulling out the fenders, I furled the genoa and just coasted under sprayhood while I prepared for berthing.

I decided to fully rig to berth starboard to, but there was only one spare finger for berthing which was port side. Quickly I rigged some more lines and went in as 2 people had come to assist me. It was an easy berth and really did not need assistance, but they wanted to chat about where I had come from and whatb the conditions were like. It was now 21.15. I quickly tidied the boat up on deck including relay all the warps, removing some fenders, coiling the unused warp and finally connection to the mains electricity after several days on batteries alone. Not surprisingly I no longer felt hungry, so just did not bother to cook the chicken curry I had planned.

Its too late to load and resize the photos, I will try and do those in the morning. Last night I did a lot of editting on the next video and it just needs some short phrases added to indetify places and will be ready to load. So, that may be Sunday or Monday.
 

Attachments

  • RB map 17.jpg
    RB map 17.jpg
    231 KB · Views: 47

jamie N

Well-known member
Joined
20 Dec 2012
Messages
6,274
Location
Fortrose
Visit site
Lochinver has The Pie shop. These are the best pies, certainly in Scotland, that can be had.
It's Sunday today, so the Chandlery won't be open, but could help you should you need 'bits', and can wait until tomorrow?.
 

Sandy

Well-known member
Joined
31 Aug 2011
Messages
21,908
Location
On the Celtic Fringe
duckduckgo.com
Am I pushing the boat too hard? Are some parts breaking due to prolonged useage? It seems I am becoming a long term test bed for parts to see when they will break. I am beginning to feel slightly jinxed. I will check in the morning if I have a spare one onboard, if not then I will have to reshape a bolt using the multitool and Dremel to have a rounded end. So, I may not be sailing tomorrow as planned.
Another interesting day on the water.

Sound like 'an everyday story of sailing folk.'

The boat is doing what it was made for, things break on long passages one reason people 'overspec' things is to mitigate those things especially at higher latitudes. I best not go into a rant about @Sybarite and the cost of an RNLI boat against the cost of a SNSM one, but hope you understand the metaphor.
 

srm

Well-known member
Joined
16 May 2004
Messages
3,248
Location
Azores, Terceira.
Visit site
Am I pushing the boat too hard? Are some parts breaking due to prolonged useage? It seems I am becoming a long term test bed for parts to see when they will break.

Yes you are. It sounds as if you have a relatively modern yacht designed for the odd weekend and a week or two of holiday use a year. You did mention earlier that your main only has two reefs as you did not intend to sail in more than F7. You have been doing that to windward fairly frequently on this trip. So far you have put quite a few years of average use into the boat.

While I was in Stromness we had a visitor whohad set off intending to sail none stop single handed around Britain and Ireland. That was his third stop to repair, replace Raymarine tiller pilots. According to the sales blurbs his boat was well within the size and weight of the machines spec. After many complaints someone at Raymarine admitted to him that they were not intended for continuous use.

With reference to @Sandy though. If a boat is correctly specified things rarely break. Unfortunately, most modern boats are built down to a price for obvious reasons and so breakages have become accepted as a norm. The bottom line is that it is the owner's/skipper's responsibility to run a safe vessel.
 

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
6,152
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
Generally all the equipment I have fitted to Concerto is over specified. When Concerto was built, the accountants had not started to wave their pencils on cost savings, so I have no worries about her. What has broken are minor fittings, but which have a critical effect. I feel sure I can fashion a bolt to replace the broken pin for the autopilot ram, if I do not have a spare on board.

Yes, I have been sailing in higher than planned winds, but yesterday was nothing exceptional and other than the pin breaking, it was a day when the wind direction and strength proved to be the problem. This year has had excessive high winds up north and stayed cool, whilst the south has been baking. If I waited until everything was perfect, I doubt I would complete the trip in the expected timescale and see as many places.

The wind outside at the moment is supposed to be less than yesterday, but at the moment it does not sound like it. It should hit a warm 19C today with rain showers all day, which is a lot warmer than yesterday. I never thought this trip would have meant I would only be sailing in cold weather clothes and full oil skins everyday. Maybe the weather will change in the next few days with lighter winds as predicted, so I can enjoy being in the Western Isles.
 

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
6,152
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
Lochinver has The Pie shop. These are the best pies, certainly in Scotland, that can be had.
It's Sunday today, so the Chandlery won't be open, but could help you should you need 'bits', and can wait until tomorrow?.
The Pie Shop is open today, so thank you for the recommendation. The venison and cranberry sound delightful, so I will buy one for lunch. The range is quite extensive and I thought you could all get your taste buds salivating.
Our Pies
 

AngusMcDoon

Well-known member
Joined
20 Oct 2004
Messages
8,832
Location
Up some Hebridean loch
Visit site
It should hit a warm 19C today with rain showers all day, which is a lot warmer than yesterday. I never thought this trip would have meant I would only be sailing in cold weather clothes and full oil skins everyday. Maybe the weather will change in the next few days with lighter winds as predicted, so I can enjoy being in the Western Isles.

The size of the typical weather system in the UK is about the same size as the UK. That means that the weather will often be opposite at either end of the country. It's quite common when it's hot and sweaty darn sarf to be cool and damp oop north. As you may have heard, it's a trifle tropical in the busy part of the realm at the moment, so the other end gets cool and miserable. It's often the same situation with wind. Last year while the Scilly Isles were getting repeatedly battered by storms wrecking boats on beaches it was gentle zephyrs and balmy days all the way in Stornoway.
 

Supertramp

Well-known member
Joined
18 Jul 2020
Messages
1,046
Location
Halifax
Visit site
Generally all the equipment I have fitted to Concerto is over specified. When Concerto was built, the accountants had not started to wave their pencils on cost savings, so I have no worries about her. What has broken are minor fittings, but which have a critical effect. I feel sure I can fashion a bolt to replace the broken pin for the autopilot ram, if I do not have a spare on board.

Yes, I have been sailing in higher than planned winds, but yesterday was nothing exceptional and other than the pin breaking, it was a day when the wind direction and strength proved to be the problem. This year has had excessive high winds up north and stayed cool, whilst the south has been baking. If I waited until everything was perfect, I doubt I would complete the trip in the expected timescale and see as many places.

The wind outside at the moment is supposed to be less than yesterday, but at the moment it does not sound like it. It should hit a warm 19C today with rain showers all day, which is a lot warmer than yesterday. I never thought this trip would have meant I would only be sailing in cold weather clothes and full oil skins everyday. Maybe the weather will change in the next few days with lighter winds as predicted, so I can enjoy being in the Western Isles.
Your comment about what has failed is exactly right. You are beyond the limit of some of your equipment and fittings but I'm sure nowhere near the limits of a Fulmar, especially yours. Not many people really test their gear like you are. You can overspecify but there will always be a weakest link and you are finding them. An autopilot gets far more and harder use than when there is a crew. You are also probably choosing to sail in conditions when many wouldn't. Stoer Point in a SW 6 is not a trifling matter and one I would avoid. A long tack out was a good strategy. You are in one of the most beautiful places in the world - enjoy it, and it gets more sheltered.
 

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
6,152
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
Checking through my stock of parts, I cannot find a spare autopilot pin. Also the balance of th pin is stainless steel and frozen into the alloy arm. Will have to try and find somewhere nearby to fix it for me. Need to speak to the chandlers, boatyard or harbour master tomorrow.

Here are some photos as promised. Just going off to fly the drone now as the sun has come out.

IMG_5150 1000pix.jpg
Leaving Kinlockbervie.

IMG_5151 1000pix.jpg
The view further round.

IMG_5157 1000pix.jpg
That is how far 3½ hours gets you to make Stoer Head.

IMG_5158 1000pix.jpg
Lochinver, the marina is in the distance on the left.

IMG_5160 1000pix.jpg
The famous pie shop.

IMG_5159 1000pix.jpg
The view behind the pie shop.

IMG_5161 1000pix.jpg
A small rivers flowing down from Loch Culag into the Lochinver.
 

Minchsailor

Well-known member
Joined
2 Dec 2014
Messages
1,276
Location
N of Ardnamurchan, winter South of Oban
Visit site
Checking through my stock of parts, I cannot find a spare autopilot pin. Also the balance of th pin is stainless steel and frozen into the alloy arm. Will have to try and find somewhere nearby to fix it for me. Need to speak to the chandlers, boatyard or harbour master.
There is a mechanical engineer around who did some work on my anchor windlass (siezed SS studs in the aluminium casting - usual problem). He's more used to working on fishing boats, and is a bit of a 'character'.

Lyndia in the HM office will give you his mobile number.
 

wully1

Well-known member
Joined
27 Aug 2002
Messages
2,840
Location
west coast of Scotland
Visit site
Lochinver has The Pie shop. These are the best pies, certainly in Scotland, that can be had.
It's Sunday today, so the Chandlery won't be open, but could help you should you need 'bits', and can wait until tomorrow?.
Best variety certainly but the best pies?

THE best ‘Jock Pie’ ever is to be had in Conel Post Office - made on the premise.....
 

dunedin

Well-known member
Joined
3 Feb 2004
Messages
14,067
Location
Boat (over winters in) the Clyde
Visit site
Another great report about another successful leg.

Yes you are. It sounds as if you have a relatively modern yacht designed for the odd weekend and a week or two of holiday use a year. You did mention earlier that your main only has two reefs as you did not intend to sail in more than F7. You have been doing that to windward fairly frequently on this trip. So far you have put quite a few years of average use into the boat.
Concerto’s Fulmar is a very seaworthy type of boat. Loads of them have sailed these Northern waters successfully for decades, including some years back the Cumbrae sail training Fulmar. Yes it, and our Fulmar, certainly had three reefs and regularly used the third one, but that is easily added.

Each has their own style of cruising, but it does sound like Concerto likes longer slogs than I prefer - all the way from Stromness to Kinlochbervie without a stop, and an upwind bash to Lochinver, bypassing lots of intermediate stopoff anchorages (such as Loch Laxford). Which is great, as we all prefer different ways of doing things.
However, perhaps might benefit from swapping the cruising mindset from the linear coastlines of the East coast, to the myriad of possibilities amongst the islands of the Scottish west coast? Perhaps rather than bash a Southerly going upwind, that might have been a day to head across to Stornoway. Then with the forecast of winds heading NW a couple of days later use these winds to take southing towards Ullapool - or just change the plan and go south down the Outer Hebrides instead. Maybe then head north a bit again if southerlies return. Going with the wind flow, rather than a fixed schedule/itinerary , gives a more gentle ride for boat, gear and crew In these waters.:)
 

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
6,152
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
Today has been an unwind and relax day. Once I get a fix for the autopilot pin, I plan to take it easier. Over the past few weeks the wind has been like an enemy to disrupt the trip. Hopefully the next few weeks will be more enjoyable in both the weather and the places I am going to visit in this spectacular cruising region. There is no fixed itinerary, just a few places I want to visit, so I can be very flexible and try and use the wind. Talking with a lot of sailors who have sailed the Scottish waters for years, they all admit they have never visited every harbour or anchorage. I know I can only try some of the huge number of places, but will try as many as I can before I have to head further south.
 

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
6,152
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
i would be sorely tempted to spend about 2months exploring the next section south to the clyde, if the height of the wee midgie season wasn't closing in fast
Do not worry, I expect to be coming back in a few years time and spending a lot more time here. In 3 to 4 years I expect to move from Kent to Cheshire and Concerto will follow. I shall berth her may be N Wales or SW Scotland. Either will make the Western Isles very easy to reach.
 

srm

Well-known member
Joined
16 May 2004
Messages
3,248
Location
Azores, Terceira.
Visit site
Do not worry, I expect to be coming back in a few years time and spending a lot more time here. In 3 to 4 years I expect to move from Kent to Cheshire and Concerto will follow. I shall berth her may be N Wales or SW Scotland. Either will make the Western Isles very easy to reach.

In which case may I suggest that you add visiting and sailing around the St Kilda group to your possible cruising destinations.
 
Top