Portofino
Well-known member
Ok so this paper here which I posted earlier and was a accused of “ searching to stuff to back fit my argument “ or. words to that effect uses lift .As said ..I'm sitting on the fence...
I can understand what Porto is trying to say, I also understand the disagreement by others.
To my mind the argument here
Is the definition or interpretation of the word "lift" ... imho it's a bit like saying a wire is "live" and others saying it's wrong because the wire is not alive. Porto says if it doesn't "sink" it must "lift".....well there is the problem as I see it, because there is a lot of information out there that use terminology to "support" Porto's theory, and as yet I have not found anything that says it doesn't produce "lift", but then we enter the world of "your wrong, but I can't prove it"
I will précis this .
https://www.researchgate.net/public...ith-spray-rails.pdf?origin=publication_detail
A plane hull tested in a tank with bits added to compare any differences .
This time they recorded the Cog movement, up = lift or down .
See the strakes shape , size , position ….running all the way back .
No deep deadrise this time , in fact a round bottom soft chime hull .
Results below .
Listen up carefully.The bare hull shows max trim in other words is bow is running the highest - top graph .
Now look at the rise of the CoG the LIFT , the bare hulls is the least .
So the ones with strakes have generally the largest lift , the CoG rise and lowest trim . So this means the sterns lifted too otherwise how can they maintain the low trim .If the stern underwater sections did not contribute lift then the trim would be higher not lower than the control , the bare hull .
This just shows the straked boats getting the largest rise of CoG - top graph .
Lower shows the relationship between drag ( resistance) and adding strakes .
Every paper on strikes + lift says the same .But there real usefulness is as I always said in particular circumstances.
I used Chris d s in my post above to dodge the “ you been looking for it …..” He posted it albeit they talked in terms of sinkage .
The reason why is to do with adding measuring equipment to the modal the weight.
More here from MapishM s country folk . There’s a shit hot school of NA in Naples btw ….unsurprisingly.
Pardo , Fraucher to name a few funky designs of late .
Big thanks to those on here who have supported me battling on with this .You know who you are .
Porto .
Apologies to the op for hijacking his post .In consolation I have answered his Q and he has started other threads about his prospect.So i don’t feel net too bad .
Last edited: