Suez blocked.

Biggles Wader

Well-known member
Joined
3 Mar 2013
Messages
10,927
Location
London
Visit site
Im guessing it all happened too quickly for thrusters to be of much use. She appears to have been going quite fast hence the distance the bow has gone into the bank but the anchors are still in the pipes so no attempt was made to slow or stop. I wonder if this could be another example of how little we really know about the handling of these fairly new mega ships. What with corkscrewing and throwing the cargo over wall in the Pacific, several minor accidents while maneovering in port and now this possible "ground effect" debacle perhaps we need a bit of research. My theory? The ratio of ship speed to available water was wrong and the pressure waves worked to crash the ship rather than keep it in the channel.
 

Kukri

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2008
Messages
15,568
Location
East coast UK. Mostly. Sometimes the Philippines
Visit site
She has two bow thrusters but Evergreen seem to have lost interest in stern thrusters recently; I suppose they don’t have enough installed reefer points to justify the generators on the monsters.

Thrusters don’t work at speed. She was going much too fast (12-13 knots) for the thrusters to be effective.
 
Last edited:

newtothis

Well-known member
Joined
28 May 2012
Messages
1,480
Visit site
So...I am not a betting man but when does the clever money start going round the Cape?
That ship has, quite literally, sailed. Seen several on front and backhaul heading south, and both Maersk and MSC have announced re-routings round the cape.
This is turning into quite the charlie foxtrot for those waiting on cargo.
 

Kukri

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2008
Messages
15,568
Location
East coast UK. Mostly. Sometimes the Philippines
Visit site
That ship has, quite literally, sailed. Seen several on front and backhaul heading south, and both Maersk and MSC have announced re-routings round the cape.
This is turning into quite the charlie foxtrot for those waiting on cargo.

Maersk and MSC operate jointly so no surprise there. ? See my post 225 for OOCL and Evergreen.

If the ships heading south open the taps the effect is rather small. Good for people like me of course. I put a link to a well known on line voyage estimator in post 154 or 156 if people want to play with the numbers.

“My” old bangers were good for 25.5 knots when they were young, but have been poodling round at half that since 2011. Their engineers are rather keen on “giving it a go” thereby doubling our capacity (and trebling our fuel bill and doing something horrible to our spares bill and something wonderful to their overtime) at a stroke!?
 
Last edited:

newtothis

Well-known member
Joined
28 May 2012
Messages
1,480
Visit site
Maersk and MSC operate jointly so no surprise there.See my post 225 for OOCL and Evergreen.

If the ships heading south open the taps the effect is rather small. Good for people like me of course.
Sorry, missed your earlier reply. The ones I've seen have all be going pretty much full clip, presumably to try and make up a bit of schedule.
 

JumbleDuck

Well-known member
Joined
8 Aug 2013
Messages
24,167
Location
SW Scotland
Visit site
Yes. It’s free warehouse space. for buffer stock. We did once try to persuade them out of it. No chance.
Danke schön. How strictly to timetable do ships like this run? In other words, if I had a container on an Evergreen ship, would its arrival normally be case of "Sometime in the second week of April, guv", "Twenty past nine in the morning on Tuesday 13th", or somewhere in between?
 

newtothis

Well-known member
Joined
28 May 2012
Messages
1,480
Visit site
Danke schön. How strictly to timetable do ships like this run? In other words, if I had a container on an Evergreen ship, would its arrival normally be case of "Sometime in the second week of April, guv", "Twenty past nine in the morning on Tuesday 13th", or somewhere in between?
Bookings give a scheduled arrival date, but it is a moveable feast. Schedule reliability on Asia-Europe is running at about 25% at the moment. Arguably, cargo owners are used to delays, but to reliable delays. The extra week or so to go the long way around is one they weren't expecting.
 

Kukri

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2008
Messages
15,568
Location
East coast UK. Mostly. Sometimes the Philippines
Visit site
Bookings give a scheduled arrival date, but it is a moveable feast. Schedule reliability on Asia-Europe is running at about 25% at the moment. Arguably, cargo owners are used to delays, but to reliable delays. The extra week or so to go the long way around is one they weren't expecting.

Just so. We could achieve much higher levels of schedule reliability, thereby allowing our customers to go closer to optimal JIT, but we would have to charge them more, and they don’t want to pay for it.
 

Rappey

Well-known member
Joined
13 Dec 2019
Messages
4,511
Visit site
Going round might need armed escorts passing the gulf of guinea due to piracy if some reports are to be believed.
 

Frank Holden

Well-known member
Joined
23 Nov 2009
Messages
1,066
Location
Cruising in the Golfo Corcovado
Visit site
I don't read newspapers, let alone French newspapers, but a reliable source has just told me that Le Figaro has a different slant on this. Egypt and France have recently had a falling out about the Suez pilots, who were predominantly French. The French pilots left, en masses, and the Russians jumped in, training mostly Egyptians as pilots, Le Figaro says one of these new pilots was in charge at the time of the grounding!
Allan
That sounds more like 1956......
Last time I went through the canal was 1965... we had a greek pilot.... I recall him saying they - the greeks - were all packing up and going back to greek ships because of Greek pension law changes that would see them losing state pensions or some such...
Prior to that ...1963/64 7 transits, all Egyptian pilots.
 

Kukri

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2008
Messages
15,568
Location
East coast UK. Mostly. Sometimes the Philippines
Visit site
Going round might need armed escorts passing the gulf of guinea due to piracy if some reports are to be believed.

There are some very silly things being written. Ships call at West African ports and yes they sometimes get attacked by local pirates. Why the pirate gangs want to set off hundreds of miles into the broad Atlantic to try to board container ships making 18 knots and more I cannot begin to imagine. The Somalis - who are really good seamen - left fast boxboats well alone.

I suppose they could try for bulkers and tankers but bulkers and tankers making for West African ports stay 200 miles out until they are called in and they don’t get bothered.
 

penfold

Well-known member
Joined
25 Aug 2003
Messages
7,729
Location
On the Clyde
Visit site
Maersk and MSC operate jointly so no surprise there. ? See my post 225 for OOCL and Evergreen.

If the ships heading south open the taps the effect is rather small. Good for people like me of course. I put a link to a well known on line voyage estimator in post 154 or 156 if people want to play with the numbers.

“My” old bangers were good for 25.5 knots when they were young, but have been poodling round at half that since 2011. Their engineers are rather keen on “giving it a go” thereby doubling our capacity (and trebling our fuel bill and doing something horrible to our spares bill and something wonderful to their overtime) at a stroke!?
It's a while since I was anywhere near a slow speed engine but most were(prior to 2008-09) optimised for 22-24kts and my understanding was that the subsequent slow steaming fad put up maintenance costs rather than lowering them.

Apropos not much I was rather hoping the newest fad for mis-selling corrosive and nonflammable soup as HFO would bring about a renaissance in steamers due to the low NOx emissions and relative immunity to crappy fuel.
 

westhinder

Well-known member
Joined
15 Feb 2003
Messages
2,517
Location
Belgium
Visit site
Update. Boskalis say she is only one metre out of her draft. I had been assuming that she was down to her marks when she struck, and was working on two metres.

That means that my calculations for the weight of cargo to be removed are too conservative, particularly when we consider that at high tide on Monday the tide will be 42 centimetres higher than when she stranded.

Sticking with my figure of 200 tons per centimetre immersion that means that the weight of cargo to be removed is much less. I had guesstimated 2,000 forty foot containers at the trade average weight of 22 tons plus 3.75 tons tare. I think the number might be nearer six hundred, and if the SCA and the salvors can clear enough sand away over tte weekend she really might come off with no cargo removed.
That is more or less exactly what the Boskalis CEO told Dutch television tonight: the ship is firmly wedged into the bank with its bow, but not the stern. They are bringing in two extremely powerful tugs over the weekend and keep dredging around the bow and hope to be able to pull her off using the spring tides of the first half of the week. If that fails, he reckons they will have to remove about 600 containers from the front stacks using a big crane on the bank. He would not be drawn on how long that would take. My guess would be the next springs in two weeks.
 

Kukri

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2008
Messages
15,568
Location
East coast UK. Mostly. Sometimes the Philippines
Visit site
It's a while since I was anywhere near a slow speed engine but most were(prior to 2008-09) optimised for 22-24kts and my understanding was that the subsequent slow steaming fad put up maintenance costs rather than lowering them.

Apropos not much I was rather hoping the newest fad for mis-selling corrosive and nonflammable soup as HFO would bring about a renaissance in steamers due to the low NOx emissions and relative immunity to crappy fuel.

The deep, deep peace and cleanliness of the Temple of Steam, after the noise and filth of the diesel engine room...?

The 10L90MC is a good engine but we got one of B&W’s off moments with the generator prime movers. A good thing we have four per ship, because we have been down to one on several occasions - we might as well have specified SKLs!
 
Top