bbg
Well-Known Member
Sleeping whilst going the the English Channel, Irish Sea etc. are obviously suicidal and no-one in their right mind would do so. Would they?
FWIW I know someone who was hit mid-ocean by an oil tanker, while he was asleep. Boat was dismasted and taking on water, and the ship (whose name he saw on the stern, at very close range) did not respond to hails on hand-held VHF. He was picked up a couple of hours later by another boat. He reported everything to the authorities when he arrived in Brazil, and they didn't arrest him or prosecute him.
So - is it negligent? Possibly, in some circumstances. Maybe not in others.
Is it "illegal"? That depends on what you mean by illegal. It means very different things to be
- negligent or partly responsible in a civil claim between two private parties; and
- in contravention of a statute for which one of the potential penalties is imprisonment.