pretzel_logic
Member
Hi Rob44
My tuppence worth on two things.
Firstly, courses. My father, brother and wife, are or were pilots like you (for a large 'British' Airline - prob similar to you). So I have a very vague idea of the training involved to get there. In their case it was fighters for the RAF, but you can do (I think) 'zero to hero' courses. And eventually they had to do qualifications which eventually lead to an ATPL (which I'm guessing is where you are at). At the end of all that you then become a very junior pilot with an airline and you then build up experience over the years.
Contrast that with the yachting world where you do a zero to hero course in three months, and then you're a qualified skipper and able to do that commercially. No experience, no necessity for any leadership potential, no need for any 'right hand seat time', you're in charge straight away. In some ways it's like learning the piano, you get so fixated on the pieces of paper (Grades) that you get to Grade 8 without actually 'learning' the piano - you've just learnt the bits necessary to pass the exams. There is very little experience gained.
The actual individual courses (DS and CS is what I did) themselves are ok. Personally I think that some of the focus is wrong. They spent large amounts of time practising how to fish someone out of the water, but very little time focussing on how to prevent that from occurring in the first place. By teaching people how to move around the deck and do tasks effectively whilst holding on. One hand for yourself, one hand for the ship type of thing.
The other point is that they are quite good at teaching marina/parking/mooring procedures, but when I did my DS it was a Jeanneau and the CS was a Halberg Rassey. Both of which will go astern willingly and much of the manoeuvring was based around that. In the real world a lot of boats will not go astern very well and so different methods need to be adapted and (on my courses) they weren't recognised. However I get that they can't cater for everything but it needs to be borne in mind.
The point being that courses are not the be all and end all - and in fact don't seem to be particularly valued outside of the charter/sailing club world and aren't necessary to sail your own boat. I only did them as I wanted to charter a boat, otherwise I probably wouldn't have bothered.
The second point refers to money. In your OP you referred to giving it all up and living on £1400 a month. Being a pilot I'm guessing you'll be on a comfortable salary and no matter what anyone says about how thrifty they are and how little they can live on, the truth is that taking a large drop in income is a struggle.
Personally, what I would do is to carry on working, do a CC course then buy something small that you can learn the ... er... ropes on. You'll so much more about actually sailing in a multitude of different conditions and looking after a boat (neither of which are addressed to any great extent in the courses) and you can carry on working.
Don't forget that every year you work then not only is that another year to save/top up your pension but also another year that you don't have to fund from your savings. So effectively two years from every year you work.
My tuppence worth on two things.
Firstly, courses. My father, brother and wife, are or were pilots like you (for a large 'British' Airline - prob similar to you). So I have a very vague idea of the training involved to get there. In their case it was fighters for the RAF, but you can do (I think) 'zero to hero' courses. And eventually they had to do qualifications which eventually lead to an ATPL (which I'm guessing is where you are at). At the end of all that you then become a very junior pilot with an airline and you then build up experience over the years.
Contrast that with the yachting world where you do a zero to hero course in three months, and then you're a qualified skipper and able to do that commercially. No experience, no necessity for any leadership potential, no need for any 'right hand seat time', you're in charge straight away. In some ways it's like learning the piano, you get so fixated on the pieces of paper (Grades) that you get to Grade 8 without actually 'learning' the piano - you've just learnt the bits necessary to pass the exams. There is very little experience gained.
The actual individual courses (DS and CS is what I did) themselves are ok. Personally I think that some of the focus is wrong. They spent large amounts of time practising how to fish someone out of the water, but very little time focussing on how to prevent that from occurring in the first place. By teaching people how to move around the deck and do tasks effectively whilst holding on. One hand for yourself, one hand for the ship type of thing.
The other point is that they are quite good at teaching marina/parking/mooring procedures, but when I did my DS it was a Jeanneau and the CS was a Halberg Rassey. Both of which will go astern willingly and much of the manoeuvring was based around that. In the real world a lot of boats will not go astern very well and so different methods need to be adapted and (on my courses) they weren't recognised. However I get that they can't cater for everything but it needs to be borne in mind.
The point being that courses are not the be all and end all - and in fact don't seem to be particularly valued outside of the charter/sailing club world and aren't necessary to sail your own boat. I only did them as I wanted to charter a boat, otherwise I probably wouldn't have bothered.
The second point refers to money. In your OP you referred to giving it all up and living on £1400 a month. Being a pilot I'm guessing you'll be on a comfortable salary and no matter what anyone says about how thrifty they are and how little they can live on, the truth is that taking a large drop in income is a struggle.
Personally, what I would do is to carry on working, do a CC course then buy something small that you can learn the ... er... ropes on. You'll so much more about actually sailing in a multitude of different conditions and looking after a boat (neither of which are addressed to any great extent in the courses) and you can carry on working.
Don't forget that every year you work then not only is that another year to save/top up your pension but also another year that you don't have to fund from your savings. So effectively two years from every year you work.