Has somebody broken the Met Office weather model?

Ammonite

Well-known member
Joined
7 Feb 2007
Messages
1,076
Visit site
If only PredictWind had more consumer friendly business practices! I’ll never go back and I warn people away.
They bill your credit card unless you cancel, and if you cancel they cut the service immediately without refund. Bunch of crooks.
I can't comment on your experience but given they provide a free platform which offers pretty much everything I need, my experience couldn't be further from yours :)
 

Ammonite

Well-known member
Joined
7 Feb 2007
Messages
1,076
Visit site
You’re not a customer then 😂 the free platform has less in it than Windy
You said consumer not customer 😎
...also I don't think Windy has a tabular format that allows the forecast models to be compared side by side which is my favourite feature, although I stand to be corrected on this
 
Last edited:

ylop

Well-known member
Joined
10 Oct 2016
Messages
2,324
Visit site
...also I don't think Windy has a tabular format that allows the forecast models to be compared side by side which is my favourite feature, although I stand to be corrected on this
it does. Get the forecast for the location - tap the bottom of screen like you are going to change the model and bottom left is a compare… may be a paid feature.
 

Ammonite

Well-known member
Joined
7 Feb 2007
Messages
1,076
Visit site
it does. Get the forecast for the location - tap the bottom of screen like you are going to change the model and bottom left is a compare… may be a paid feature.
I've just checked and it's available as part of the premium (paid) option, not the free one. Thanks
 

Boathook

Well-known member
Joined
5 Oct 2001
Messages
8,573
Location
Surrey & boat in Dorset.
Visit site
A report in today's i about weather app accuracy. Met Office came out OK/ best for planning ahead and the rest no better, even struggling for the next day.

I do think that these weather apps need a human forecaster to keep any eye on what is being produced by persumably AI.
 

Beneteau381

Well-known member
Joined
19 Nov 2019
Messages
2,053
Visit site
All models have been predicting many days with the difference between wind and gust over 10kts, sometimes 20kts. I have found this to be accurate on the W Coast of Scotland this year. It is therefore essential to look at the gust forecast and not the steady wind forecast when passage planning. These are not occasional gusts, the wind has been blowing at or near the indicated gust speed for maybe 50% of the time.

So reef early and reef deep !


- W
Meteo, xcweather and windy have been doing way out forecasts for the last few weeks here in Portugal
 

franksingleton

Well-known member
Joined
27 Oct 2002
Messages
3,590
Location
UK when not sailing
weather.mailasail.com
We were in Brittany, as far south as La Turballe for much of July, August, early September. For long periods all the forecast models were erratic. They differed markedly from each other and were inconsistent from one day to the next. There were spells, around the second week of August and the second week in September when forecasts seemed to be more consistent with each other and with themselves from day to day. I have no explanation for this.

There were some slightly confusing comments about grid lengths and predictability in earlier posts. Global models use grid lengths of between about 9 and 13 km. (PredictWind “proprietary”, aka CSIRO CCAM, uses 50km.)
All models contain smoothing of about 5 grid lengths so that effective resolution is between 50 and 80km.
Detailed models, eg ICON-EU, UKV, AROME, HRRR, are nested in global models and can produce nothing greatly different.
The area covered by, say, UKV is small. Weather systems move. Therefore such models are really only useful to us for short periods. I might look at them for the next 12 hours. Beyond that, and maybe for even shorter periods, they are indicative only.-
 
Last edited:

Puffin10032

Active member
Joined
5 Jul 2016
Messages
120
Visit site
A report in today's i about weather app accuracy. Met Office came out OK/ best for planning ahead and the rest no better, even struggling for the next day.

I do think that these weather apps need a human forecaster to keep any eye on what is being produced by persumably AI.

My understanding is that the weather apps simply take a feed from each model's main run. When the Met Office produce a forecast they do a whole series of runs (termed an ensemble) not only from their own but also the European model. The degree to which all these runs agree allows them to put a confidence value on the forecast which is missing from the apps although you can get a hint of it by comparing the Met Office and ECMWF models on Windy.
 

franksingleton

Well-known member
Joined
27 Oct 2002
Messages
3,590
Location
UK when not sailing
weather.mailasail.com
A report in today's i about weather app accuracy. Met Office came out OK/ best for planning ahead and the rest no better, even struggling for the next day.

I do think that these weather apps need a human forecaster to keep any eye on what is being produced by persumably AI.
National weather services and ECMWF run their models. The various apps that we see are beyond their control except, of course, for those appearing on their own sites. AI might be being used to generate apps but I am not aware of that being the case. I suspect that they are using some form of model output statistics.
 
Last edited:

lustyd

Well-known member
Joined
27 Jul 2010
Messages
12,269
Visit site
Some apps are starting to use AI to refine local weather. Where local measurements are available it's easy enough to compare expected and observed and see patterns. It's also possible to take a Navionics approach and collect weather data through the app and use this for machine learning.
Whether it's an effective approach time will tell.
 

franksingleton

Well-known member
Joined
27 Oct 2002
Messages
3,590
Location
UK when not sailing
weather.mailasail.com
My understanding is that the weather apps simply take a feed from each model's main run.
I believe that is so.
When the Met Office produce a forecast they do a whole series of runs (termed an ensemble) not only from their own but also the European model.
As far as I know, ensembles are produced by each service using only their own model output.
The degree to which all these runs agree allows them to put a confidence value on the forecast which is missing from the apps although you can get a hint of it by comparing the Met Office and ECMWF models on Windy.
The danger in using Windy or Ventusky to compare ECMWF, UK UM. ICON, CMC GEM, US Navy NAVGEM, Meteo France Arpege is that this is too small an ensemble.
 

AntarcticPilot

Well-known member
Joined
4 May 2007
Messages
10,444
Location
Cambridge, UK
www.cooperandyau.co.uk
National weather services and ECMWF tun their models. The various apps that we see are beyond their control except, of course, for those appearing on their own sites. AI might be being used to generate apps but I am not aware of that being the case. I suspect that they are using some form of model output statistics.
I have read recently that the Met Office has incorporated AI in their models. However, this is NOT AI such as LLMs like ChatGPT - it's physics based AI modelling used to speed up processing, a technique that is increasingly widely used where speed of processing of problems with high dimensionality is required. Such techniques incorporate mechanisms to ensure that the results are explainable in physical terms.
 

franksingleton

Well-known member
Joined
27 Oct 2002
Messages
3,590
Location
UK when not sailing
weather.mailasail.com
Change is occurring in weather prediction at an alarming pace. It is all too easy for expectation to exceed practicality.
As lustyd says, AI is just statistics. The atmosphere is a turbulent system. Whatever prediction system is used, operational weather prediction will be limited by the lifetime of weather features of all sizes from showers to monsoons. Predictability will still be limited by the physical reality of the atmosphere.
 

Stemar

Well-known member
Joined
12 Sep 2001
Messages
23,505
Location
Home - Southampton, Boat - Gosport
Visit site
The YouTube Met office channel is worth a look. You get what's happening and why, including the degree of certainty. It won't tell you that it's going to rain in Gosport, but not in Southampton but, if you understand what's happening, it helps to know hoe much you can trust your preferred weather app when it does tell you.
 

lustyd

Well-known member
Joined
27 Jul 2010
Messages
12,269
Visit site
Simonjk used to do weekly forecasts on this forum and with videos to explain which were extremely valuable. Not seen them for a while and his channel seems to be aviation now so I guess he moved on
 

franksingleton

Well-known member
Joined
27 Oct 2002
Messages
3,590
Location
UK when not sailing
weather.mailasail.com
The YouTube Met office channel is worth a look. You get what's happening and why, including the degree of certainty. It won't tell you that it's going to rain in Gosport, but not in Southampton but, if you understand what's happening, it helps to know hoe much you can trust your preferred weather app when it does tell you.
The Met Office app can resolve detail to about7km - at least for the next few hours. It will resolve small detail further ahead, but less accurately. The website version, UK rainfall radar map - Met Office .
gives the last 1-2 days actual radar imagery. That should be at less than 5 km res.
 

FairweatherDave

Well-known member
Joined
28 Sep 2009
Messages
2,021
Location
Solent
Visit site
Simonjk used to do weekly forecasts on this forum and with videos to explain which were extremely valuable. Not seen them for a while and his channel seems to be aviation now so I guess he moved on
I get a weekly weekend sailing forecast e mail from Simon, from something I must have clicked on on his site. It's an e mail not a video but useful all the same.
 
Top