Civilised racing anyone?

Fox Morgan

Well-Known Member
Joined
22 Oct 2009
Messages
248
Location
Ponta Delgada & Southampton
Visit site
moved from the lounge forum due to being "too boaty"

After weeks of shaking my head watching friends go out and batter themselves in stripped out racing yachts in the name of "having fun", I have an idea that should make things entirely more civilised.

I wrote a blog post about it
http://www.boogie-nights.org/2015/04/ive-been-stuck-inside-working-on.html

if anyone thinks I've missed something from my list of civilised demands, please feel free to add your own...

------- for those who don't like following links, I've done my best to copy the words and pics below ------------
I've been stuck inside working on a project, which means I have been viewing the world through a small vertical window.
I play games, like spot the mast and guess the motorboat by the sights through my skyward facing hatch and the sounds that permeate through the water and reverberate inside Boogie Nights.
thus: I have become a dab hand at recognising boats by their masts, spreaders and the tone of their engine.


One set of spreaders looks like this:

sunfast-3600-code-2-5-25-backstay-10-12kts-tws.jpg

pic courtesy, Paul Brant of http://ninjod.org/


This, for the uninitiated (and the majority of society who give zero chuffs) is a Sunfast 3600. The size and aft sweep of the spreaders, the pre-bend in the mast. It's a performance racing yacht, even without seeing the boat and with the sails tucked away in port. Simply by looking at the big stick pointing skywards it's unmistakable.


It is one of many in the Solent area and all over the south coast that are being pressed into racing use this season. If one person accidentally got on the wrong boat, he or she might not notice for some time. They are clone boats.


Now this is where I start to question the obsession of my dearest sailing friends.


two things:

1a - expensive sails
1b - high tech electro gizmodry
2 - lack of an oven and other basic civilised elements


I realise that's three things.

But the first two are in the same bracket of "I've got a lot of money, what can I spend it on?"


The latter is, "I've got to feel as uncomfortable as possible in order to feel like a winner"


This is intended as a non-too-serious rib poking at quite a few people I know who fit this bill.


so, about those sails...


1a -

sails come in all types of cloth and non-cloth. Some are made from densely woven canvas, or a Dacron material. Others are laminated or plastic sails reinforced with carbon or kevlar strands. Then there's exotic moulded thingymejigs that cost a frikkin arm-and-a-leg.


"The more fancy the sails look, the better they are."


Laminated carbon sails are really lightweight, which reduces the weight of the boat. The lighter the boat, the faster it goes. (sort of) Reducing the weight of sails up the mast means more leverage from the keel. Which means the boat doesn't lean over quite so much. Which means you can keep bigger sails up for longer, which means you'll go faster and be able to sail closer to the wind (maybe)

Of course, the downside is that laminate sails will cost you at least an arm, if not a leg as well. This is going to make winching rather more tricky than if you have a full complement of appendages. You're gonna need more crew.

Oh and those fancy laminate sails, they're gonna need replacing every couple of years or so. You're going to be so busy working to earn the money to pay for this, you wont be going sailing much anyway. Unless you work for a trading bank. In which case, does the tax man know about your luxury fancy yacht you dirty robbing ratbag?


"just the mere mention of 'carbon sails' is enough to render some sailing buddies doubled over in climactic embrassament."


I chose a heavy weight offshore sail cloth for Boogie Nights new main sail last season. There'll be no unintentional orgasming around here thank you. That should last well in excess of five years, possibly a lot longer if I take care of it. It cost £5000, which, if I can make the sail last 10 years is £500 per year. If I take the boat out every week of the year, thats about £10 a week.

I'm not counting the cost of lost battens at this point. In fact, I'm not even going to talk about that. What? Sorry? Where was I?

RPM_0714small.jpg

sail cutting by laser - Lonton & Gray http://www.lontonandgray.com/

I bored my Sherman-tank-wielding-brown-sauce-replacing friend almost to the point of permanent stupefication just a few days ago when I tried explaining the intricacies of the jib or genoa selection and purpose and the complexities of choosing the right size for the boat. I won't go on, but, I'm going to get the front sail (genoa - no never met her) reduced at which point it will become a jib.

"I'm hoping I like the cut of my jib when it's done."

I hope you understand that I'm not obsessed at all. But it wont look like one of those fancy black sails out in the Solent, flown by fannies with all the fekkin gear and no idea. Overpaid, overfed, fancy labelled performance clothing wearing and in need of something to throw their disposable income at. I'm not bitter. Not at all. Does anyone actually know what jobs these people do anyway? I'd like to know. Because I'm not obsessed at all. Nope.


screenshot11%2Bcopy.jpg

When I look at a regatta in action and see all of the black and orange tinted see through sails, all I can think is, how does anyone afford that?image courtesy of : http://www.performanceyachtcharter.com/sailing-event/royal-southern-summer-regattas/


1b -

The next thing these wealthy-elite sailing racing types with fancy black sails do is buy gadgets. Gadgets for safety (good). Gadgets for calculating weather patterns. Gadgets for calculating the best route to take from A to D via points B (starboard hand buoy) and C (port hand buoy) Gadgets for communicating to their shore based support team. Gadgets for assisting with every technical aspect of the sailing endeavour.


These will make you a winner. Not only can you render your fellow combatant green with envy when they see your electronic appendages attached to the chart table, but you have the upper hand in terms of onboard thinking technology.
And quite possibly save weight while you're at it. Those big old pilot books, almanacs and paper charts are damned heavy you know. The joy they bring will have to be sacrificed. In favour of Gadgets
tide tables, paper charts and dividers are relegated to the cupboard/storage ashore in favour of electronic aids.

20150424_212540.jpg


We all know saving weight makes us go faster right?


"coffee colonic anyone?"


It's amazing how much extra surplus weight we carry around in our lower intestine, so I am told.
So, in the name of weight saving and self induced living rough, I swiftly move on to the second point.


2 -
lack of civilsed amenities.

"For the love of Neptune, where's your chuffing oven?"

Racing boats do not pander to the users/sailors sensitivities. Or so they would have you believe.

IF we were aiming to set a world record then I can understand stripping back to a bare boat. It's a one off. It wont happen all the time.


But for every man and woman who takes part for FUN, for their leisure activity, as a thing they do in their spare time, why, oh why, oh why do they self inflict a kind of purgatory only obsessed people are capable of inflicting upon themselves?


No running water. Check
No oven. Check
Freeze dried food. Check
No fresh food. Check
No personal affects. Check
No cockpit cushions. Check
Absolutely no sprayhoods. Check
Sleeping bags only. Check
Plastic sporks instead of real cutlery. Check
SporkGrn10055237_x.jpg

Spork, anyone?


Now, if you were racing around some marker buoys for a couple of hours locally before packing the boat away and heading back to creature comforts, you wouldn't care about the above points. But the moment you leave land behind and are to spend a few nights at sea, then suddenly, the ability to chuck a pasty in the oven and have a little lay down in comfort makes the world of difference.


tumblr_leil7yiZL01qe0eclo1_r9_500.gif

do you want to sail on a racing boat?



so let's just get this straight,

Having spent a small fortune on shwanky black see through sails that will go out of shape after a couple of seasons, added fancy electronic gadgets to help you sail faster from A to D via B and C, taking into account the current weather, the predicted weather, the currents, tides and other charted features.
You've got the best autopilot and you've had your large intestine rinsed out to reduce weight.
You've got the very same identical boat as every bugger else, despite racing under IRC handicap rules meaning every boat of all types and level of fitout has a fair and equal chance to compete. It has no comforts or civilised amenities and no personal touches to make it appealing as a place to be once safely moored up. And you do this "racing" for fun? Do you even like yourselves? Have you no self respect?


A quick guide to the current, commonly known clubs that frequent the British Southcoast Solent area.


RORC - Royal Ocean racing club
RORC.png


The royal ocean racing club attracts a broad spectrum of yachties. Some are attracted by the name because it sounds a bit like a lion. Others fancy a bit of the royal connection. Others have got a bit too much surplus cash lying around so spunk it away each season on a new set of fancy sails, some new gadgets and self flagellate in stripped out husks of sailing boats. They may have crew onboard to serve as waiting staff when they step ashore. Most likely to be flying a blue ensign when not racing.


SORC - Solo offshore racing club
logo.png



Mostly people who don't have any friends.
Probably because their boats are so inhospitable they've been abandoned in favour of sleeping on a cliff face or climbing Everest without breathing apparatus. Honestly guys, put an oven on board, you'd never be alone again.
In the meantime, you'll find these guys in the nearest bar to their finish line. That's what happens when you don't carry wine glasses.

JOG - junior offshore group
JOG-logo.gif


The junior offshore group is like the poor mans relation to the royal club. Originally this club was set up for boats between 16 and 20 feet long, hence junior. But time has changed things. Now it's open to any boat with an IRC rating.
Boats who are too poor to enter RORC go for a JOG instead.
They don't allow sponsorship logos and any clue that the boat might be run by a tax dodging banker, however, they do allow shmantzy pants laminate sails and stripped out racing boats. But due to running IRC handicapping, that stripped out racing boat could be beaten by a comfortable cruiser that has been sailed well. JOG racing is sociable too but formed of cliques between the out and out racers and the racer cruisers. One lot reclines in the cockpits with drinks and social times, mingling from boat to boat. The others head for the bar or hope for an invite onto another boat with facilities because frankly, they've got nothing worth staying around on board their own boats for. Unless you fancy freezedried food out of a dog bowl.



I propose a different kind of yacht racing.


all boats should have an oven.
all boats should have running water.
all boats should carry real food, with menus submitted to race control for further adjudication (freeze dried allowed only for emergencies)
all boats should carry at least one out-of-date potnoodle, two tins of baked beans and a tin of custard.
all boats should have standard cutlery (none of that spork nonsense)
all boats should carry wine glasses (plastic is acceptable but glass is preferred)
all boats should carry a cocktail jug of suitable size and capacity to facilitate the making of "dark n stormy" drinks. This will also double as a bailer should ones anchor locker or other awkward space need bailing.
all boats should carry a selection of basic medicinal spirits.
all boats should have the facility onboard to make toast.
all boats should be navigated primarily by paper chart. Hourly plots are mandatory when offshore.
sponsorship logos are allowed if it's for charity.
two scatter cushions minimum per boat.


I'm going to call it Civilised Offshore Racing Club.

our club burgee will be thus:

corc.jpg
 
Last edited:
I think you have only addressed part of the problem, which is "how can I justify exposing my largest investment after my house to the risk of damage by some rich psychopath?"

The most civilise racing I have done was at a fun regatta in Germany. I struggled to understand the race instructions, but managed with the majority until I came to one which included "duches". It was explained to me that it said that in the event of a boat making a protest, the skipper making the protest would be questioned by the race committee while standing in a cold shower.
 
I think you have only addressed part of the problem, which is "how can I justify exposing my largest investment after my house to the risk of damage by some rich psychopath?"

The most civilise racing I have done was at a fun regatta in Germany. I struggled to understand the race instructions, but managed with the majority until I came to one which included "duches". It was explained to me that it said that in the event of a boat making a protest, the skipper making the protest would be questioned by the race committee while standing in a cold shower.

that sounds very civilised indeed.
 
We meet all the requirements except the oven. Meths stove only, I'm afraid.

Classic boat racing is the way to go. Problem is you need to buy an old wreck and do it up.
 
I ask myself after reading your posts/blog if you can get any funnier.....you never fail to succeed lol. Utter brilliance, please never stop. :encouragement::D:triumphant::cool:
 
A truly excellent post. What we need is some form of handicapping system that rewards civilised behaviour. For example every Michelin star awarded to the cuisine on the boat could be worth a 20% reduction in the race time.

The IOR regs could be re-introduced but with the I and J measurements being the length and width and the master stateroom berth - anything less than king-size would not qualify. Internal headroom should also be a key measurement as should the thickness of the cushions and mattresses and the hanging locker space per crew member.

We could have points awarded for the smartness of the crew (at least 50% of whom would not be allowed to be involved in the actual sailing of the boat) and points deducted for ugly/old crew (except owners and their guests of course). There are so many options available - this could revolutionise yacht racing and actually make it enjoyable...
 
Excellently put and totally agree ,used to race a sun odes 40.3 great fun fridge full of beer music playing and fresh bacon butties as we went over the start line, we even won a few, now its a pogo 10.50 quicker yes beer ,hot food no, win any races no (trying hard though ) oh well at least we are sailing and you never know one day we might just win one
 
Carl - you won races in the boat which was a nice place to be, but you haven't won any in the boat built purely to perform???

Doesn't this suggest the fruitlessness of perfectionism?

SugarKane, I like the principles you suggest. It's an odd question, yacht racing...I get heavily criticised hereabouts for scorning the competitive instinct as seen on sailing boats...and indeed it's unfair of me really, since the worst of the breed are plainly in for cardio trouble or hypertension worries...

...but I'd go further than you have...

...because just as expensive sails and doubtfully-beneficial gadgetry are unlikely to return their cost, I've always felt that fin keels and exposed helms define an obsession with performance over comfort, which definitely restricts the pleasure and usability of yachts in the UK climate and depths of water.

Bilge keels spell the ability to dry out in places which most yacht owners can only gaze at wistfully as they pass...but of course, they won't actually buy a bilge keeler because of the performance reduction. (This weird prioritising, in a means of transport which rarely moves faster than a fat lady running)...

...likewise, on the same principle as the compulsory cooker, why doesn't the CORK rulebook insist that all yachts have a hard wheel-shelter or interior steering...on the sound basis that in a whole year's use, by far the most miles sailed will be in hideous headwinds and driving rain.

Unfortunately I suppose every time we criticise anybody's priorities, we further marginalise ourselves. But I'd much rather be slow and comfortable...so much so that I no longer look at stripped-out racers with any more interest than the non-sailor in the street.
 
but how do you warm your pasties, sausage rolls, get bread to rise/bake or make cookies on passage? Sounds like living rough to me.

It doesn't feel like rough. Keeping warm with oil lamps, generous sided bunks, bacon rolls for breakfast, pasta or stew for dinner. With a little thought, there is a lot you can do with a single meths burner.

As for handicap, try this one:

http://www.fky.org/regatta/klr-engl.htm

Using the KLR-formula separates racing from the judgement over items like authenticity, originallity, state of maintanance, degree of original substance and so on. For these (also very important) items we have for example a restoration prize.

Using KLR is very simple, we don´t have measurement-certificates and we don´t want them.
KLR doesn´t need complicated measurements, in some cases we have to ask and to explain to get the „right“ datas (some owners will give the measured sail-area which is less, others are not shure about the yachts displacement).
After 6 years in use without changings we notice a high degree of acceptance.

The KLR-formula has no type-producing character like the well known rules RORC, CCA, IOR, mR ever had. That means that no type will get notable advantages or disadvantages. It is a formula to get ratings for an existing crowd of very different yachts, spread over the various categories of types and spread over about a hundred years.
 
Last edited:
Excellently put and totally agree ,used to race a sun odes 40.3 great fun fridge full of beer music playing and fresh bacon butties as we went over the start line, we even won a few, now its a pogo 10.50 quicker yes beer ,hot food no, win any races no (trying hard though ) oh well at least we are sailing and you never know one day we might just win one

Now then, is that the pogo10.50 up on the crouch?
I have my heart set on a pogo 40 or 1250 (cruising racing version obviously) because I get a massive thrill from going fast, just for fun. However, my eye seems drawn to a lovely luxury looking swan too. completely different kind of boat. But you can be sure, bith would have an oven and scatter cushions. and of course, the ubiquitous figure head who dresses according to the seasons.
 
Carl - you won races in the boat which was a nice place to be, but you haven't won any in the boat built purely to perform???

Doesn't this suggest the fruitlessness of perfectionism?

SugarKane, I like the principles you suggest. It's an odd question, yacht racing...I get heavily criticised hereabouts for scorning the competitive instinct as seen on sailing boats...and indeed it's unfair of me really, since the worst of the breed are plainly in for cardio trouble or hypertension worries...

...but I'd go further than you have...

...because just as expensive sails and doubtfully-beneficial gadgetry are unlikely to return their cost, I've always felt that fin keels and exposed helms define an obsession with performance over comfort, which definitely restricts the pleasure and usability of yachts in the UK climate and depths of water.

Bilge keels spell the ability to dry out in places which most yacht owners can only gaze at wistfully as they pass...but of course, they won't actually buy a bilge keeler because of the performance reduction. (This weird prioritising, in a means of transport which rarely moves faster than a fat lady running)...

...likewise, on the same principle as the compulsory cooker, why doesn't the CORK rulebook insist that all yachts have a hard wheel-shelter or interior steering...on the sound basis that in a whole year's use, by far the most miles sailed will be in hideous headwinds and driving rain.

I was going to suggest that spray hoods and canvas for comfort are all highly encouraged.
You'll certainly find my spray hood firmly in the up position even when racing. The only time I drop it is on a glorious day and the spinnaker is flying.


I'm also working on a blog post of how to look ones dashing best when arriving at a new port, regardless of how many days one has had to do without a proper shower. It's an art form. One that my autopilot is very familiar with as I duck down below to sort out my hair and don my "arrival best."
 
Anyone who reaches for the mainsheet, whenever another boat hails into view, 'just so as to make the old girl show her best', should just be honest with themselves, and go compete at whatever level they wish.

It does not matter how much effort you are prepared to put in, there will always be others who do more, and others who do less. It does not matter whether your chosen goal is winning cowes week class one, or occasionally hanging on the same lap as the leaders, in a Solo, in a puddle, or to get your 4kt caravan around a coastal course in a white sail fleet, each will put a smile on your, and your crews, face, if on the off chance you occasionally perform to your self set targets.

There is nothing in the rules about being uncomfortable, some just swap a bit of comfort for some speed, for others, they feel no need to pay for upholstery, heaters and many loos that they will never use.

You will meet some good friends along the way (and some idiots too), and get the feeling of being part of something bigger.

But, just once, maybe, get a friend who has a boat with 3di sails to invite you out for a race, the feeling of locked in power is amazing....
 
Excellent blog!

And I basically agree with you. It's why I don't do offshore racing.

I'm also definitely going to have to send that pic of the yachts with £ signs on them to a friend of mine, you've put one on his boat....
 
Excellent blog!

And I basically agree with you. It's why I don't do offshore racing.

I'm also definitely going to have to send that pic of the yachts with £ signs on them to a friend of mine, you've put one on his boat....

Is he a banker?

I mean, I'm not jealous at all about people who can afford to replace their sails every other year. Or the unbelievable way a boat handles with carbon sails. NOPE, not jealous at all. not even slightly interested.

don't suppose his cast-offs would fit a dehler 36 would they? hmm?
 
Is he a banker?

I mean, I'm not jealous at all about people who can afford to replace their sails every other year. Or the unbelievable way a boat handles with carbon sails. NOPE, not jealous at all. not even slightly interested.

don't suppose his cast-offs would fit a dehler 36 would they? hmm?


Why hasn't this forum got a 'Like' button because I would press it for your post. Or does the thumbs up cover it?

But you've just lost some credibility because you have Dehler 36 , so hardly an old tub.

All things are relative.
 
The pogo is a fantastic boat to sail, hard on the wind is a struggle, but crack off a bit it is a flyer ,very stable, and comfy, this one is cruising version elect toilet windlas etc all mod cons, only probe is our rating , for round the cans it is no good ,we give time to J122 what we are waiting for is one off the passage races we do when winds suit we regally see 14-16knt boat speed and in complete comfort no problem to put kettle on
 
Top