Rob_Webb
Active member
Before reading the article below and shouting "sour grapes" read my personal comments to both teams (via email today):
To ETNZ
"Congratulations on a fantastic effort, you have flown the NZ flag high and proud for all the world to see and you have exorcised the ghosts of the past. We might have wished for a slightly different result but the margin of loss was tantalisingly small and you have done justice to yourselves and your supporters. You now deserve some breathing space to reflect and regroup yourselves in your own time."
To Alinghi
"Congratulations on defending the Americas Cup. As a ETNZ supporter I cleary hoped for a different result but at the end of the day Alinghi consistently sailed faster and smarter than the kiwis, especially when it mattered, and the best team has won. The whole event was a great spectacle and I look forward to 2009."
Alinghi man gestures with knife at Team NZ member
7:43AM Tuesday July 03, 2007
By Paul Lewis
The Alinghi team member, whose identity is not known, was part of the support crew on the small boats that are used to haul the yachts along the canal that leads to the Cup race course.
The boat had come to meet Alinghi after the race, in which Alinghi went ahead by 4-2, to take it back to its Port America's Cup berth.
On a nearby press boat, Team NZ photographer Chris Cameron was part of a small group of cameramen who had been photographing the race.
Also on board was Rob Griffith, a photographer for Associated Press.
"We were just a bit forward of their [Alinghi's] bow and we were taking pictures looking backwards at them," said Griffith.
"We'd come in quite quickly to get ahead of all the spectator craft. I was standing with Chris when I heard his name being called.
"There was a skinnyish guy standing on the back of the Alinghi towboat.
"He had a knife, with a blade about 4 inches long. It was one of those pocket knives where the blade folds away and with a large circle at the base so you can stick your thumb in and flick it open.
"It was a serrated edge thing and it looked razor sharp - I'd say they use it for cutting through ropes in a hurry or something like that.
"Anyway, he flicked it open and closed a few times after he'd yelled out Chris' name and, after the third time, looking at Chris he raised it to his throat and made the throat-cutting gesture.
"He then pointed at Chris. The intent was clear."
Cameron took some of the pictures on which Team New Zealand based their protest when Alinghi were suspected of sending a man up the mast to lower their mainsail - a potential breach of the rules which could, in theory, have cost Alinghi the race or provoked a re-sail.
The protest angered Alinghi, and their managing director - New Zealander Grant Simmer - was hard put to contain that anger when the hearing ended with the protest being dismissed.
However, it was unusual that it was a majority decision from the race jury, with almost all such decisions normally unanimous.
Team New Zealand would not comment on the incident yesterday.
However, there may be some sort of official action, even if it is just a legal letter.
It is not expected to have any effect on the America's Cup match - other than controversy arising when the match is at its peak.
There is no suggestion the man with the knife in the Alinghi towboat intended to do anything more than make gestures.
However, in many countries, using a weapon in a threatening manner even if there is no intention to actually use it, is a criminal offence.
To ETNZ
"Congratulations on a fantastic effort, you have flown the NZ flag high and proud for all the world to see and you have exorcised the ghosts of the past. We might have wished for a slightly different result but the margin of loss was tantalisingly small and you have done justice to yourselves and your supporters. You now deserve some breathing space to reflect and regroup yourselves in your own time."
To Alinghi
"Congratulations on defending the Americas Cup. As a ETNZ supporter I cleary hoped for a different result but at the end of the day Alinghi consistently sailed faster and smarter than the kiwis, especially when it mattered, and the best team has won. The whole event was a great spectacle and I look forward to 2009."
Alinghi man gestures with knife at Team NZ member
7:43AM Tuesday July 03, 2007
By Paul Lewis
The Alinghi team member, whose identity is not known, was part of the support crew on the small boats that are used to haul the yachts along the canal that leads to the Cup race course.
The boat had come to meet Alinghi after the race, in which Alinghi went ahead by 4-2, to take it back to its Port America's Cup berth.
On a nearby press boat, Team NZ photographer Chris Cameron was part of a small group of cameramen who had been photographing the race.
Also on board was Rob Griffith, a photographer for Associated Press.
"We were just a bit forward of their [Alinghi's] bow and we were taking pictures looking backwards at them," said Griffith.
"We'd come in quite quickly to get ahead of all the spectator craft. I was standing with Chris when I heard his name being called.
"There was a skinnyish guy standing on the back of the Alinghi towboat.
"He had a knife, with a blade about 4 inches long. It was one of those pocket knives where the blade folds away and with a large circle at the base so you can stick your thumb in and flick it open.
"It was a serrated edge thing and it looked razor sharp - I'd say they use it for cutting through ropes in a hurry or something like that.
"Anyway, he flicked it open and closed a few times after he'd yelled out Chris' name and, after the third time, looking at Chris he raised it to his throat and made the throat-cutting gesture.
"He then pointed at Chris. The intent was clear."
Cameron took some of the pictures on which Team New Zealand based their protest when Alinghi were suspected of sending a man up the mast to lower their mainsail - a potential breach of the rules which could, in theory, have cost Alinghi the race or provoked a re-sail.
The protest angered Alinghi, and their managing director - New Zealander Grant Simmer - was hard put to contain that anger when the hearing ended with the protest being dismissed.
However, it was unusual that it was a majority decision from the race jury, with almost all such decisions normally unanimous.
Team New Zealand would not comment on the incident yesterday.
However, there may be some sort of official action, even if it is just a legal letter.
It is not expected to have any effect on the America's Cup match - other than controversy arising when the match is at its peak.
There is no suggestion the man with the knife in the Alinghi towboat intended to do anything more than make gestures.
However, in many countries, using a weapon in a threatening manner even if there is no intention to actually use it, is a criminal offence.
