Unavoidable collision?

Quandary

Well-known member
Joined
20 Mar 2008
Messages
8,210
Location
Argyll
Visit site
The silly season, so here is a silly story but completely true.
Late this year moving our boat from Loch Fyne to its summer berth at Crinan but we did it the Monday after Tarbert race weekend. Myself and the dog aboard, my wife ahead in the car taking lines, opening and closing gates, we were following one of the race boats returning to Oban, closing up to him at the bridges. The dog was in his favoured position when motoring, at the bow with his front paws up on the pulpit step, like a figurehead (I think he may have seen Titanic on TV). We passed the swan's nest to port on the bend before Crinan bridge, Mrs Swan perched on her eggs on top of her mound of reeds. Just round the bend her mate was approaching, returning from a recce. down the canal, he was paddling hard, close to flat out but sticking to his correct side and passed the lead boat comfortably port to port. As we got closer he started to move away from his correct side giving me much less room than the first boat. I steered to starboard but he kept coming over toward our side; close to the bank our keel touched the bottom, stopping the boat abruptly, pitching the dog over the pulpit on top of the swan. Dog was up the bank in two splashes while I got under control and proceeded through the bridge to our berth, the swan turned round and followed me at close to the 4kts. speed limit, the dog running ahead of us along the towpath. As I tied up, starboard too, at our berth, the swan arrived and started hammering on the gelcoat with his beak, just like I expect to have to hammer the dent in the lead keel when I can get at it.

Lessons learned - swans like many other canal users do not always adhere to the collision regs. and may do the unexpected, they are not as placid as they let on.
Swans do not like dogs especially if they are near their nest.
A winter spent waxing the hull to get a reflective shine is not always a good idea.
 
D

Deleted member 36384

Guest
You meet a different class of sailor in a Swan but some can be bloody minded at times.
 

MrB

Well-known member
Joined
12 Sep 2011
Messages
2,519
Visit site
What colour ensign did Mr Swan have? ;):encouragement: Funny Story indeed :encouragement:
 

Quandary

Well-known member
Joined
20 Mar 2008
Messages
8,210
Location
Argyll
Visit site
Crinan canal bottom should be mud on puddling clay, so no dent likely.

Nah, It was the stone pitching or perhaps a boulder, our boat only draws 1.8m and if it had been mud the dog says he would definitely have been able to stay on board. Mind you, he is a big and very angry swan on a direct collision course and going flat out at the time of impact.
A lot of the canal bottom is solid rock, it was down about 5' this afternoon after some low tide lockings and the exposed bank across the front of our house is a solid shelf of virgin rock, not a great slope on it either. I have rescued a few yachts that have reversed their rudders up on to it in the past. I took a boat with only 2.4 m draught (Dufour 44) through last week and it took two days because they could not put enough water into the Crinan reach during the day.
 
Last edited:

Hadenough

Well-known member
Joined
9 Jan 2011
Messages
3,026
Location
No fixed abode
Visit site
Nice story! Our Westie came a cropper this afternoon. Has become over confident, stepping nonchalantly onto the pontoon from the thwart just as the RIB comes alongside, misjudged it today and had an early bath :) good job he wears a life jacket with a handle!
 

Other threads that may be of interest

Top