dgadee
Well-Known Member
I had an insurance survey done by an idiot for €750. I would like an insurance company to allow you to compile one yourself with images and invoices.
I was able to do just that several years ago, provide images set against their requirements. It was only an option when I pushed it about not having a survey due to limited time to arrange for that year, so may be worth asking. Following year moved another insurer / broker where that wasn't a requirement for a few more years and a better policy for me... Porthcawl being one of them.I had an insurance survey done by an idiot for €750. I would like an insurance company to allow you to compile one yourself with images and invoices.
As @Tranona says, third party risks (and recovery of wreck) are much the same for any vessel. My boat may not be worth much, but if it sank in the wrong place it could block the ports of Harwich and Felixstowe until the wreck was removed, with consequential costs that make the £3,000,000 third party cover look small! The ship channel is narrow and only 15m deep. And my low value yacht could cause substantial damage to a much larger or more valuable vessel. Remember too that if a commercial vessel is out of service, even if only for precautionary survey, it is running up costs of 5 or 6 figure sums for each day it isn't operating normally. All these are unlikely events, but the risk is much the same for anything above dinghy size.yes. The %age of value is rather meaningless as the third party element is largely fixed cost. Inevitably the higher the value of the boat, the smaller the %age the premium represents as a total. The idea of %age comes from the world of shipping where that is used as a determinant for indicating level of risk. For example %age rates shot up for both ships and cargoes transiting the black Sea in 2022 and the Red sea in 2024 when the Houthis started attacking ships.
A couple of real yachty examples. When I owned 2 boats, the low value one (£13k) cost around £200 (1.5%) and the £100k one was £550 (0.55%)
Doesn't seem unreasonable, but I'd definitely advise checking carefully to be sure they haven't changed any other conditions/cover.Just had my renewal quote from GJW. Up by 22% to £360 pa on an agreed value of £30K fully comp. I doubt I'll get much of a better deal so I will probably take it.
Give Porthcawl Insurance a call.Just had my renewal quote from GJW. Up by 22% to £360 pa on an agreed value of £30K fully comp. I doubt I'll get much of a better deal so I will probably take it.
My agreed value was changed to assessed value when I renewed. I presume the other agreed conditions remain as before, but I should really confirm with them. E.g. single handing.Doesn't seem unreasonable, but I'd definitely advise checking carefully to be sure they haven't changed any other conditions/cover.
I might give that a punt, especially as I have never claimed.I spoke with someone who renewed last week. They tried to increase his premium by 25 %. He challenged this and apparantly dropped in back significantly. Personally even a 25% increase really is not significant in the grand scheme of things.
Steveeasy
They wouldn't quote without a survey and valuation less than two years old. Mine was done in 2022.Give Porthcawl Insurance a call.
Odd, when we went with them the survey had to be within 5 years.They wouldn't quote without a survey and valuation less than two years old. Mine was done in 2022.![]()
Shouldnt need to contact them to confirm, Nowadays most of the documents are issued on PDF, and it is what these say that really matters. Definitely need to review these each year.My agreed value was changed to assessed value when I renewed. I presume the other agreed conditions remain as before, but I should really confirm with them. E.g. single handing.
My GJW insurance premium went up 4% this year after the Ripe takeover. A few of the conditions have changed, but not much. There's a new web interface requiring a new login and password, and the new one fails to have all the previous details from years past (as the old one does). There will apparently be a 1 year overlap of web portals, even though theold one does nothing now except store old data. My cruising area and extended solo sailing were carried forward.
In preparation for the renewal and thinking of a huge increase, I sought some premium info from a few others. They would all demand a "out of water" survey. When I enquired what they would need to be covered in such a survey, they all (5 of them) refused to say. It left me wondering what really should be covered and who should have that say. They seem to leave it the owner, but I can imagine that if the survey was to lightweight, they'd not accept it?
You will find that most surveyors work to a standard model of insurance survey which is less comprehensive than a pre purchase survey. Essentially the insurer wants to know that the boat is seaworthy and has no major faults plus probably a valuation to support the insured value.In preparation for the renewal and thinking of a huge increase, I sought some premium info from a few others. They would all demand a "out of water" survey. When I enquired what they would need to be covered in such a survey, they all (5 of them) refused to say. It left me wondering what really should be covered and who should have that say. They seem to leave it the owner, but I can imagine that if the survey was to lightweight, they'd not accept it?
GJW seem to have a great following of inland waterways canal boat users who may accept without question things that we may wish to discuss.Never heard of them. Next year I'll look more closely at what's on offer. Perhaps GJW will lose enough business to make them return to their old policies again.