Does using solar degrade my batteries?

Irish Rover said:
I think you're just taking advantages of me now because I said I was a tech numpty 😁.
Anyway, these are what I have
ProMotive AGM
Click to expand...

Honest - no insult or anything implied or intended ...

OK - the batterys you have are designed for truckers where they have diesel heaters / maybe tail lift as well ...

They state a 1200CCA ... so designed to start engines .... so are not a deep cycle battery - but being AGM - you will have slightly more capacity than an equivalent non AGM.

IMHO - good batterys and worth looking after. Far better than the crap I put in my boats !!
 
Irish Rover said:
I'm not sure what it is you're trying to say?
Click to expand...
Generating electricity with a diesel is an extremely wasteful and pollutional process, with relatively low overall conversion efficiencies . Propane would have made more sense for cooking, particularly frying. Just my opinion.

The folks on the forum have done a good job of explaining SOC, what batteries like, and how to treat them. For a cruiser with complex and power-intensive systems, this understanding is as vital as sail trim.
 
thinwater said:
Generating electricity with a diesel is an extremely wasteful and pollutional process, with relatively low overall conversion efficiencies . Propane would have made more sense for cooking, particularly frying. Just my opinion.

The folks on the forum have done a good job of explaining SOC, what batteries like, and how to treat them. For a cruiser with complex and power-intensive systems, this understanding is as vital as sail trim.
Click to expand...

But are you replying in context of the OP's opening post ? Doesn't appear to be.
 
Irish Rover said:
One of us is lost, and I don't think it's me.
Click to expand...
Forums are a watercooler conversations and they resist all efforts of steering. Yes, I wondered, but that does not suggest I am lost.

High resistance loads on a 12V system are, IMO, poor design. The consequences are those you were conserved about in your first post, so we're not far off topic. My thoughts were more of a warning to others that don't see the downside of high electric loads. Propane is still more practical than all-elelctic, IMO, but it's just my opinion. Also, if you do have an electric system failure (inverter?), and many modern power systems are beyond the average owner to debug, your food will be raw. Why not have two possible methods (electric and fuel)? For example, I have a microwave, hot plate, propane stove, and propane grill. If I lose power to the solenoid it can easily be removed (happened once--took 5 minutes).
 
thinwater said:
Forums are a watercooler conversations and they resist all efforts of steering. Yes, I wondered, but that does not suggest I am lost.

High resistance loads on a 12V system are, IMO, poor design. The consequences are those you were conserved about in your first post, so we're not far off topic. My thoughts were more of a warning to others that don't see the downside of high electric loads. Propane is still more practical than all-elelctic, IMO, but it's just my opinion. Also, if you do have an electric system failure (inverter?), and many modern power systems are beyond the average owner to debug, your food will be raw. Why not have two possible methods (electric and fuel)? For example, I have a microwave, hot plate, propane stove, and propane grill. If I lose power to the solenoid it can easily be removed (happened once--took 5 minutes).
Click to expand...
Have you been drinking ?

He said he doesn't want to use the generator. But, if the inverter fails he can use it, no raw food.
 
Just keep this going a bit longer...
I have also been wondering the same thing as the OP.
I know from experience that a lead acid battery in a car, kept fully charged all the time can last 10 years or so.
On my boat I regularly, on a daily basis, as a liveaboard run my batteries down to 50% and then fully charge them again.
By how many years am i shortening the life of my batteries by doing this?

Estimates only please (preferably from experience), no calculations or anything technical and no recommendations that I do anything differently.
Thank you.
 
Thresher said:
Just keep this going a bit longer...
I have also been wondering the same thing as the OP.
I know from experience that a lead acid battery in a car, kept fully charged all the time can last 10 years or so.
On my boat I regularly, on a daily basis, as a liveaboard run my batteries down to 50% and then fully charge them again.
By how many years am i shortening the life of my batteries by doing this?

Estimates only please (preferably from experience), no calculations or anything technical and no recommendations that I do anything differently.
Thank you.
Click to expand...

Charged agressively - I would look to 3 - 5yrs ....

Charged less agressively - 5 - 7yrs ...

But I would be considering over 5yrs a bonus on any LA battery on a boat - given the crap we subject them to ...

Do not forget that most cars do not achieve 100% on a charge ... it falls short of that in the low to mid 90's% ... its why on boats - Sterling and similar company's sold boosters to try extract that last few % etc.
 
Refueler said:
Charged agressively - I would look to 3 - 5yrs ....

Charged less agressively - 5 - 7yrs ...

But I would be considering over 5yrs a bonus on any LA battery on a boat - given the crap we subject them to ...

Do not forget that most cars do not achieve 100% on a charge ... it falls short of that in the low to mid 90's% ... its why on boats - Sterling and similar company's sold boosters to try extract that last few % etc.
Click to expand...
Aggressively, thats interesting and something i hadn't considered.
Would Aggressively be using a 240v battery charger with the 'rapid charge' switch on?
I assume solar charging and charging from the boat engine wouldn't be aggresìve?
 
Thresher said:
Aggressively, thats interesting and something i hadn't considered.
Would Aggressively be using a 240v battery charger with the 'rapid charge' switch on?
I assume solar charging and charging from the boat engine wouldn't be aggresìve?
Click to expand...

Agressive is when you replace the alternator on your engine to a significantly more powerful version ... it also is related to the max charge rate that is noted on the battery label. Pushing it really too aggressive and you can gas up the battery .. even bubbling the electrolyte .. this can be extremely dangerous due to the gas given off.

I have a shore charger that can whack out 70A ... but the manual makes it clear to only use it to get a battery up to a reasonable state - then revert to standard rates.
 
Thresher said:
Aggressively, thats interesting and something i hadn't considered.
Would Aggressively be using a 240v battery charger with the 'rapid charge' switch on?
I assume solar charging and charging from the boat engine wouldn't be aggresìve?
Click to expand...
If you have a "rapid charge" switch, i guess that's an automotive charger ? What make and model ?
 
Last edited:
Thresher said:
Just keep this going a bit longer...
I have also been wondering the same thing as the OP.
I know from experience that a lead acid battery in a car, kept fully charged all the time can last 10 years or so.
On my boat I regularly, on a daily basis, as a liveaboard run my batteries down to 50% and then fully charge them again.
By how many years am i shortening the life of my batteries by doing this?

Estimates only please (preferably from experience), no calculations or anything technical and no recommendations that I do anything differently.
Thank you.
Click to expand...
With such constraints it's hardly worth replying.
 
thinwater said:
Forums are a watercooler conversations and they resist all efforts of steering. Yes, I wondered, but that does not suggest I am lost.

High resistance loads on a 12V system are, IMO, poor design. The consequences are those you were conserved about in your first post, so we're not far off topic. My thoughts were more of a warning to others that don't see the downside of high electric loads. Propane is still more practical than all-elelctic, IMO, but it's just my opinion. Also, if you do have an electric system failure (inverter?), and many modern power systems are beyond the average owner to debug, your food will be raw. Why not have two possible methods (electric and fuel)? For example, I have a microwave, hot plate, propane stove, and propane grill. If I lose power to the solenoid it can easily be removed (happened once--took 5 minutes).
Click to expand...
:sleep:
 
Refueler said:
Charged agressively - I would look to 3 - 5yrs ....

Charged less agressively - 5 - 7yrs ...

But I would be considering over 5yrs a bonus on any LA battery on a boat - given the crap we subject them to ...

Do not forget that most cars do not achieve 100% on a charge ... it falls short of that in the low to mid 90's% ... its why on boats - Sterling and similar company's sold boosters to try extract that last few % etc.
Click to expand...
BTW. Thank you. I feel reassured.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Top