AntarcticPilot
Well-Known Member
You say this with such certainty - but then, it's a better explanation than 'Genesis, Chapter 1'.
Now - about these comets ....
Most of the water on earth came from the planetesimals from which the Earth (and other planets) formed. Comets probably have a similar composition to the primordial planetesimals, but are unlikely to be a major source of water; the Earth isn't gravitationally attractive enough to be struck by large numbers of them. The Earth happens to be large enough and cold enough to retain water; Venus and Mars probably have significant water, but in Venus' case it is combined with other minerals, and not present as liquid; Mars is small and has lost most of it.
The planetesimals that originally coalesced to form the earth probably had a lot more water proportionately than the earth does; Hydrogen and Oxygen are cosmically very abundant. The question is really "Where has the water gone?" not "Where did it come from?"
With another hat on, Genesis tells us a lot about God, but is not a text book on planetology.