Last year we saw Sail Ionian flotilla skippers fitting vertical wind scoops to forecabin hatches. Effective or not? Worth the money? Does anyone have experience / feedback?
Which type of windscoop do you mean? The classical, "standard" type like this:
Or the more elaborate type that works whichever direction you're facing, like this one:
We have two of the "standard" types for our moody 422, and wouldn't be without! They draw a very pleasant breeze through the whole boat, which is delicious when it's 40 degrees C outside like it was last month in the Ionian...!
Absolutely brilliant gets a breeze right through the boat, I have three of them forward and they send air right through a 57' boat, wouldnt be without mine.
Fab bits of kit. We use ours as a spinnaker when racing, a hammock at anchor, a water catcher in the tropics, a backpack, a helipad, a DZ marker, an emergency handkerchief for when you have a bad cold, a shopping bag for Lidl, a sleeping bag, a cool box (not very effective) and a scoop for catching wind and directing it through the boat (very effective).
As I am just about to buy some (or get the SWMBO to make them!) which do you suggest - is the all direction one (second picture) as good, or is it a compromise?
The all round one is good if you are in a marina or at anchor not facing the wind (two anchors) but the directional one is best when the boat swings into the wind at anchor, horses for courses I guess. We use the directional ones and AC in the marinas!!
I purchased one from the American catalogue of 'West Marine' .It required no ties to mast or forestay,instead was self supporting,using flexible fibreglass rods sewed into the side hems,. It also kept all but driving rain out-useful when the boat is unattended...
We carry the inflated dinghy on the foredeck - hauled upright using the spinnaker halyard, it works a treat as a windscoop. Alternatively, Google Plastimo's website, they definitely sell the lightweight fabric ones.
Yup Boatmans world. But then Peter did owe me Euro 80 from the last time I was over there and I was buying a new battery and solar charge controller at the same time /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
I use the standard one and cannot imagine how the more complex one can even be as good, let alone better. Remember it will pull air through the boat if downwinf, as well as push it, and the larger the unobstructed area of hatch for the air to pass through the better. The complex type would seem to only use at best about half the available hatch area, which must severely cut the volume of airflow.
[ QUOTE ]
I purchased one from the American catalogue of 'West Marine' .It required no ties to mast or forestay,instead was self supporting,using flexible fibreglass rods sewed into the side hems.
[/ QUOTE ]
Interesting...
Has it got a name? the US West marine website is vast, and I'm not sure in which category to search, no doubt the Yanks call them by some weird name...!