Valise vs Canister liferaft.........

Twister_Ken

Well-known member
Joined
31 May 2001
Messages
27,584
Location
'ang on a mo, I'll just take some bearings
Visit site
Canister is designed to be stowed on deck, valise in a locker or below. Canister is thus ready to go at a moment's notice, valise might take a few seconds to locate and position before launching. Once you get past four man size, the valise can quite heavy and awkward to shift although - no doubt - adrenaline would be on your side.
 

pvb

Well-known member
Joined
16 May 2001
Messages
45,603
Location
UK East Coast
Visit site
In an emergency, a canister raft stowed on deck or on the pushpit is likely to be easier to deploy. Liferafts are heavy lumps of kit, and I wouldn't want to have to retrieve a valise raft from a locker.
 

karl74

Member
Joined
26 Nov 2011
Messages
80
Location
Weston-Super-Mare
Visit site
Thats prety much what I thought. Is there any reason as to why you couldn't or shouldn't keep a valise stowed on the coach roof at least whilst at sea. Apart from having to lug a 25 - 35kg valise every time you went to sea, or are they not weather proof enough to be kept on deck.
 

skip50

Member
Joined
4 Jan 2011
Messages
593
Location
Troon
Visit site
As I understand it, they are not waterproof enough to stow on deck and also should be kept the 'right' way up. In my case (valise) that is vertically on the long side-if you see what I mean. Certainly not stowed flat as you would a canister.

HTH
 

karl74

Member
Joined
26 Nov 2011
Messages
80
Location
Weston-Super-Mare
Visit site
As I understand it, they are not waterproof enough to stow on deck and also should be kept the 'right' way up. In my case (valise) that is vertically on the long side-if you see what I mean. Certainly not stowed flat as you would a canister.

HTH

Ok thanks. That answers that question then. Canister seems to be the way to go for me as having the kids on board would be one less thing to worry about.
 

Ex-SolentBoy

New member
Joined
25 Nov 2006
Messages
4,294
Visit site
Ok thanks. That answers that question then. Canister seems to be the way to go for me as having the kids on board would be one less thing to worry about.

I have a waterproof valise, so many of the arguments don't apply. I can get to it much quicker than a boat where the canister is on the deck in front of the sprayhood as many do.

On the other hand a pushpit mounted canister is great and quick to deploy unless you have been hit from astern or for whatever reason need to get in the drink from somewhere else on the boat.

There is no perfect solution.
 

prv

Well-known member
Joined
29 Nov 2009
Messages
37,361
Location
Southampton
Visit site
My valise raft is vacuum-packed, so I don't see why it shouldn't be treated as waterproof.

I have a valise raft in a locker below, which is far from the ideal arrangement but the best that can be done on my boat as there's no space on deck for a canister and no suitable deck locker. At least the locker below is next to the companionway, which on a small boat like mine is relatively low. I can certainly lift the raft out of the locker and into the cockpit without any difficulty - I did so last weekend while emptying the boat for the winter.

I reckon the best option is a valise raft in a purpose-designed locker, for example in an aft deck behind the cockpit as I've seen on a couple of boats. Removes any worries about the raft being swept away by a big sea. A canister raft in a decent cradle comes a close second, if your boat isn't well-designed enough to have a locker.

Pete
 

BlueSkyNick

Active member
Joined
29 Apr 2003
Messages
11,766
Location
Near a marina, sailing club and pub
Visit site
The choice partly depends on the type of sailing you do, and how many on board.

If a bunch of hairy arsed racers, you would expect somebody to get a valise out of a locker OK, and a canister might be in the way.

If just a couple, like us, I prefer that the raft can be launched alone by the weakest person aboard, ie SWMBO, by pulling a pin. We work on the basis that if conditions prevent me climbing on to the boat having gone overboard, at least launch the raft so I can buy myself more time.
 

alan_d

Well-known member
Joined
15 Mar 2002
Messages
2,363
Location
Scotland
Visit site
Hi,

Just wandered what the general consensus was or is it just down to personal preference and stowage space on board?

This has been discussed at length previously and a search engine may help you find the relevant thread.

The answer, as to so many other things, is that it all depends. Considerations include (but are not restricted to): Valise rafts are slightly cheaper, lighter and easier to manhandle than the equivalent canister (but anything bigger than a 4-person raft will be difficult for one person to lift). Stowed in a locker they are less susceptible to theft, but also less readily available for deployment. Only canister rafts are suitable for hydrostatic release. A canister raft on the pushpit can be deployed quickly but is potentially more vulnerable to being carried away in extreme conditions; one on the coachroof may obstruct forward vision and prove difficult to reach in extremis.
 

aquaholic

Active member
Joined
17 Jul 2004
Messages
1,151
Location
London
Visit site
We opted for a canister mounted on the stern rail this year, usually just the 2 of us sailing so at least I know we can both deploy it with no problem. Just need remember to remove the padlock before sailing.....:)
 

KellysEye

Active member
Joined
23 Jul 2006
Messages
12,695
Location
Emsworth Hants
www.kellyseye.net
>In an emergency, a canister raft stowed on deck or on the pushpit is likely to be easier to deploy. Liferafts are heavy lumps of kit, and I wouldn't want to have to retrieve a valise raft from a locker.

I agree , ours is on the pushpit with a serrated dive knife tied to the nearest stanchion.
 

jwilson

Well-known member
Joined
22 Jul 2006
Messages
6,107
Visit site
Some older boats have a specific place for a liferaft in a valise. So that's what we have! And if you're going the whole hog it should self deploy with one of those hammar thingies. I think it's required for chartering.

Charter boats can have a valise raft in a locker, but if it's a canister type mounted on deck it must have a Hammar release. Many charter boats used hired valise rafts, freshly certified each year.
 

Burnham Bob

Active member
Joined
18 Jul 2009
Messages
1,803
Location
Burnham on Crouch
Visit site
another vote for cannister being easy to deploy. being a skinflint i was about to buy a valise, but realised that SWMBO probably couldn't lug it up from down below when needed if i was incapacitated. so we paid extra for the cannister version and a cradle to mount on the pushpit. so all she has to do is push it overboard and pull the line.......
 

CFarr

Member
Joined
19 Aug 2010
Messages
406
Location
Me: Well inland. Boat: Bellanoch, Crinan Canal
Visit site
I used to think on deck canisters were the best option, then I read 'heavy weather sailing'
The number of these that were washed clean off the decks before they could be used really made me think.
If you're in a position where you are wanting to deploy one, it's probably going to be a bit rough with all other options out. You'll want it to be there.
 

sailorman

Well-known member
Joined
21 May 2003
Messages
78,878
Location
Here or thertemp ashore
Visit site
I used to think on deck canisters were the best option, then I read 'heavy weather sailing'
The number of these that were washed clean off the decks before they could be used really made me think.
If you're in a position where you are wanting to deploy one, it's probably going to be a bit rough with all other options out. You'll want it to be there.

on our boat the raft is designed to be stowed under the helm seat out of the way with no windage
 
Top