Reflections on our {Scottish} Cruise

Quandary

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 Mar 2008
Messages
8,214
Location
Argyll
Visit site
Just back after three weeks of untypical West of Scotland weather, no wind most days (though we had a cracking close reach from Mallaig to Tob. on the way home) often thick fog which did not burn off until well into the afternoon and flat seas. Some comments on what's new or mildly interesting.
The new harbour building in Loch Aline is the bees knees, plenty of immaculate showers, toilets, laundry and pleasant verandah with outside seating and unlike Tobermory it is accessible 24/7, pity that the silica sand mine works to midnight when a ship is in and that the guy who designed the cramped and short pontoon layout for them has a 16' motor boat, but they say they intend putting that right.
The moorings at Canna are hard to resist when you see the quantities of kelp coming up with anchors in the central area that they have left clear. £10 a night but a look at the sheet with the honesty box in the wee shop suggests that about 50% of users are not paying.
'New' traffic separation around NW Skye is a real pain in thick fog, we felt forced to abort our intended destination, Loch Maddy, and turn right for Stein.
The Shiant Islands merit the description 'awesome' if you are there in a flat sea and clear weather, thousands of every variety of sea bird and a great variety of cetaceans passing through.
Van Morrison was top of the bill at Hebcelt but we were in Stornoway a week early as they were just setting up. Three nights there were about enough with Sunday approaching. Piling for new pontoons going in and serviceable portacabin showers on the quay now.
Hired a car and visited Callinish and the Carloway broch but really impressed by Bernera and the multiple channels and anchorages of Loch Roag though when the fog descended in the afternoon it was eerie. (a future destination which would take many days to explore) Disappointed with the black house village, now operating as a hostel with one cottage as a museum but 20th. century with a fireplace and a proper chimney. People in Lewis have even worse taste in replacement bungalows than the Irish.
Loch Inver has more pontoon berths, a new slipway, state of the art remote controlled travel hoist and plenty of space for boats ashore, shore power on the pontoons is promised for next year. A good place to go for an emergency haul out. The former Seaman's Mission by the harbour has been taken over by the community, revamped, with a very reasonably priced (mains about £8-10) cafe/restaurant open in the evenings (bring your own bottle,) they do carry out from the same menu for about half the sit in price, no showers in there now but you can get those at the leisure centre.
Midges were a problem at times but this year the ticks are worse than I can ever remember, nearly everyone you talk to in the Highlands seemed to know someone with Lymes disease.
Highland Council are still offering great value about £1.75 a metre with the second night free even if it is at a different harbour, even so I listened to the owner of an X42 with a crew of five adults explaining to the harbourmaster at Gairloch who had shifted a boat to accommodate him that the '42' was Scandanavian feet and he was under 12 metres.
Only two alongside berths left on the Flowerdale pontoon, the rest is used by the whale scarers, but rafting is encouraged. We were alongside for several nights but usually had to actively persuade other boats that they were welcome alongside us. Badachro is very crowded now, but the Council also have heavy moorings in Shieldaig. Loch Torridon feels scary in fog.
I suppose it was the poor visibility but all the life boats were kept busy assisting yachts aground, though in one case I heard the Mallaig lifeboat tell a 'casualty' in Loch Moidart that he was quite safe and would refloat in the afternoon, so he was going back to base. Does being aground in a sheltered location with no wind justify a callout? I suspect that if you let the coastguard know of your situation their default response is to call out the lifeboat.
The pontoon at Kyle of Loch Alsh is to be taken over by a local community group who intend to re-open the showers and eventually extend with some sort of wave screen, Kyleakin is staying with Highland Council. They have been given about £80k. to spend on a feasibility study, not sure how many feet of pontoon you could buy for that.
Plenty of room for tidal turbines and passing yachts to sail past in Kyle Rhea even close to mid. spring tide, you need to be alert though as you are rarely going in the direction the boat is pointing.
Inverie has so many ferries running back and forward from Mallaig now, that during the day it feels like Rothesay, or perhaps more like Tobermory, hardly 'Britains remotest pub' anymore, for tranquility try Doune or go on up the loch.
Mallaig pontoons are busy, it now seems to have taken over from Tob. as the turning point for boats that do not anchor, but it is pricey, still with no facilities ashore and charging £3.60 a night for shore power, the diesel from Johnstones is still a bargain though.
Big spring tides on the way home swirling through the Sound of Luing at 5.7 kts. we got 12.8 kts. on the gps. Some of the yachts heading for Croabh seemed to prefer to go south of Luing rather than the excitement of Cuan Sound. As we were doing that at mid tide Stavros Niarchos ghosted in through the Corryvreckan.
Grass that has not been cut for three fairly humid weeks is just about the limit of what a petrol Flymo can cope with.
 
Last edited:
Just finished my first cruise on the west coast, as part of a round Britain. Spent a month and a half there, so had a more mixed bag of weather, but poor visibility seems the main factor.
Apart from your observations, many of which I fully agree with, a few additions:
- great anchorages in settled weather: Gometra Harbour, Wizard Pool, Loch Maddy, Bull Hole
- good shelter from a southerly blow on a mooring in Loch Shieldaig
- poor shelter from a southerly blow on the moorings in Portree
- do not stay on the pontoons in Mallaig in a northerly F8
All in all, the west coast was all I had hoped for, and much more.
Plenty of pictures on www.ossian.be , the text is in Dutch, I'm afraid.
 
Johan
N. force 5 is enough to make Mallaig uncomfortable, I am impressed with your choice of anchorages, all would be on my favourites list, but did you try Acairseid Mhor on Rona, much better than the moorings at Portree though a lot further from the shops.
Tried your link but could not get it to work?
 
Last edited:
Johan
N. force 5 is enough to make Mallaig uncomfortable, I am impressed with your choice of anchorages, all would be on my favourites list, but did you try Acairseid Mhor on Rona, much better than the moorings at Portree though a lot further from the shops.
Tried your link but could not get it to work?
No, unfortunately we did not go into Acairsid Mhor. It was on my list of favourites, just as Loch Scavaig, but unfortunately the circumstances did not seem right at the time. The choices are bewildering anyway, I sometimes wonder if you Scots fully realise what a wonderful cruising ground you have. But that leaves me plenty of reasons to come back ;-)
There seems to be a problem with the site today, I suppose it is the host. Yesterday it was fine, I uploaded new pictures and they were alright then. I hope it will be up and running again soon.
 
N.... I sometimes wonder if you Scots fully realise what a wonderful cruising ground you have. ....

We do. I remained south of Mallaig based on weather forecasts of overcast conditions northwards and missed all the fog, blue sky, all day sun, some winds; tremendous weather the whole of July, the first time in a long time of a month of wall to wall sun. That's news, not the "wonderful cruising grounds".:)
 
The moorings at Canna are hard to resist when you see the quantities of kelp coming up with anchors in the central area that they have left clear. £10 a night but a look at the sheet with the honesty box in the wee shop suggests that about 50% of users are not paying.

Ain't that the truth! And even if they're flying white ensigns it doesn't seem to increase that percentage.
 
I can never understand the reluctance of using an honesty box. If someone has made an effort to make it easier for me and my boat, the least they deserve is a few of my sheckles.

Maybe I just don't like the thought of being dishonest :)
 
Quandary- nice commentary, always good to get other people's impressions of places you know.
We must have been like ships in the night, this year's cruise covered the area Portree-Kylesku-Stornoway. One thing we did differently was that we tried to visit new places each night. The anchorages are so good, and so prolific, that this was not problem at all.
The fog was indeed a bit spooky. We were caught out just south of Priest Island (bang on the Stornoway-Ullapool ferry route) and could just hear the rumble of the ferry's engine, and hte regular blasts from the foghorn. We don't know how close it got as we never saw it yet. At the time we were ghosting along under spinnaker at about 3kt, I was reluctant to put on the engine as I thought it was more important to be able to use my ears...
 
Ain't that the truth! And even if they're flying white ensigns it doesn't seem to increase that percentage.

Encountered them in Loch Aline, they are an arrogant lot, asked why a couple of small local boats could not be moved away to make more room for them, did not impress the lock keepers here on the canal either but you can certainly hear what they are saying. (HRH was a good deal more reticent and allowed hubby to steer while she put away the fenders).
I have nothing against blue ensigns either, but two of the non payers at Canna were sporting the burgee of the nearest yacht club with 'Royal' in its name. The community in Canna might help themselves a bit by not getting a six year old to paint their message on the buoys, on ours the painter used plenty of black paint but ran out of space well before completing the message, we were still able to work out that the night should be paid for though and there were plenty of signs ashore telling you where.
 
. . . . but you can certainly hear what they are saying. . .

Yes they weren't exactly 'low - key' were they! I know it's wrong to perpetuate stereotypes, but . . . One windy day at Canna, the Coastguard had imposed a radio silence on Ch16 whilst everyone strained to hear a possible, weak Mayday call. Even the 10.10 weather forecast was cancelled. But would you believe it, the only break of the radio silence was when the 'cut-glass' accents of the Royal Yacht Squadron boats started a crisis discussion about where they were going to eat that evening as the restaurant on Canna was having problems with their cooker. Obviously, in their ranking of priorities, the social life of the RYS is far more important than someone possible drowning.
 
Top