More Spanish matriculation tax news

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted User YDKXO
  • Start date Start date
D

Deleted User YDKXO

Guest
My boat has now had a 'discrete precincto' placed on it in Palma and within 2 weeks apparently, I will know whether I will have to pay 12% matriculation tax on it. I have been informed that the local customs authorities supported by the Guardia Civile are inspecting every British and German flagged vessel in the Balearics that is currently offered for charter or has ever been offered for charter in the past. Unfortunately, because my boat has a local charter licence, and despite the fact that I have only done a very small number of charter days, it's been identified for inspection
My local charter co has now taken advice from a local lawyor and the letter of the law regarding matriculation tax is this. If a boat is offered for charter in the Balearics, it must have a local charter licence. If it has a local charter licence it is assesseable for matriculation tax. Providing the waterline length (actually it's equivalent to what we know as the plimsoll line length) is less than 15m (my boat just complies), then the boat is not liable for matriculation tax BUT you have to have an exemption certificate to prove it. And here is the key point. Even if your boat has an exemption certificate, then under the law, the owner is NOT allowed to use the boat for private use whatsoever and because of the system of filling out forms whenever a boat visits another port or marina, the authorities can easily find out whether a boat has been cruised for private use. So, to sum up, if a charter boat has an exemption certificate but has been cruised privately, or it doesn't have an exemption certificate when it should have or it has a waterline length more than 15m, it will be assessed for matriculation tax. This affects many boats in the Balearics, probably hundreds if not thousands because there are many owners like me who offer their boats for charter in an attempt to defray some of the exhorbitant costs of keeping a boat there
A word of warning for anyone considering doing a runner. My charter co has had to sign a guarantee that they will not allow owners to remove their boats from their home port whilst they are under investigation and, even if owners do make a break for it, the infamous Guardia Civile and their patrol boats are waiting for them. By the way, during this purge, a couple of large mobos in Portals have had their VAT status as well as their matriculation tax status checked
The feeling on the islands is that this will decimate the Spanish charter industry in particular and affect the Spanish boat industry in general. After all, who wants to moor their boat in Spain when they'll be assessed for matriculation tax if they do even the smallest amount of charter. The fact that a couple of boats have apparently had their VAT status examined is also a worry as many boats in the Med have ownership structures designed to reduce VAT paid which, whilst being legal, might be examined by the authorities so why risk that by mooring in Spain at all
 
Blimey Mike. That's terrible. Reading your "letter of law" paragraph, if what is said there is correct, you are liable for the tax. This really is going to decimate the Spanish boating industry. Folks will flock to France and elsewhere. It's a typically stupid attitude by tax collectors: they think that by assessing tax they collect it, without realising that lots of things (capital, people, boats) are mobile.
 
More good news hot off the press from Majorca. On top of any matriculation tax owed, there will be a fine, in the sum of 50% of the tax owed if you are 'cooperative' with the authorities and heaven knows what % if you decide to fight it. So, make that an 18% tax, not 12%. And, if you do decide to fight it, the discrete precincto will be converted to a full precincto (ie the boat is chained to the dock) until such time as your case comes before a tribunal which will take place at some unspecified date in the future. Furthermore, the authorities have questioned the valuation placed on one boat which already has had it's matriculation tax paid in the past and they have decided that the boat was undervalued at the time
Still, looking on the bright side, there won't be many charter boats available this summer in the Balearics so any boat thats still free to operate will be very busy
 
Oh Dear Mike,

Sorry to hear that. I am sure it will hit your wallet hard! If it has started in the Ballearics it will soon be here on the CDS. Very worrying for those who only charter to defray costs as you have done and as most taxes it does not seem fair or right. Yes they will in the short term get a wodge of backdated taxes and fines but will lose IVA in future years if you all move your boats (or do not replace it).

Can you clarify what you say about past charter licenses. If it has previously been charted say 3 years ago. Changes ownership and is no longer chartered would the new owner be liable for the tax. Also do you know if the boat is taken out of Spanish waters then returns at a later date if it can have the Tax applied.

Paul /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
Hi Mike,

very worrying developments...

just thinking aloud - for anyone who is offering their boat for charter (as we do) and has reclaimed VAT.

If we use the boat ourselves, we have to pay the implied VAT that is chargeable on the charter. In this way, we're in effect chartering the boat from ourselves and this wouldn't be private use. If this had been the case, might it get around the private use law?

However, I suppose you'd have to prove all of this and you don't want your boat chained up until then.....
 
[ QUOTE ]
So do we reciprocate and slap a requirement for every ( Spanish ) chartered boat in Uk waters to have an MCA clearance and charter licence?

[/ QUOTE ] Yes - all three of them! /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
Hmmm, I see your point Woodie. But while that might get you out of the tax under the "private use" trigger, wouldn't you still get clobbered by one of the other things that triggers matric tax? Like merely having a charter licence and being over 15m? Or being under 15m and not having an exemption certificate?

Frankly, seeing what has happened to Mike, you surely must give serious consideration to just moving your boat out of Sp waters, now. The weather and seastate this weekend are perfect for a crossing to France. You can get a berth now, before the ex-Spain rush, in the Cote D'Azur, if you're quick. Otherwise you could get the phonecall that mike has just got and once the precincto is attached there's no escape, and you're looking at a seemingly definite 18% of a T47 presumably backdated to the new price. You'll even get an FX hit with your 2007 boat: they'll compute the euros you should have paid in May 2007 and you'll have to buy them now at sodding 2009 rates

If this matric tax doesn't scare me off (I'm visiting Sp waters for <30days) I'll be on your quay from this sunday night. Chris R has got me a berth. I'm a mate of your near neighbour Mr Baking Bowl
 
you're right - serious consideration needed. We'll have to change the boat name and camouflage her for a quick getaway! Not sure what I can disguise a T47 as though!

Mr Baking Bowl? Is it another T47?

Chris R is a good guy - glad he's sorted you out.
 
Sounds quite frightening, is the tax retrospective, could you not simply arrange a quick sale to a relative to use a private leisure boat? It would then no longer be a charter boat? Tax avoidance, not evasion?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Can you clarify what you say about past charter licenses. If it has previously been charted say 3 years ago. Changes ownership and is no longer chartered would the new owner be liable for the tax. Also do you know if the boat is taken out of Spanish waters then returns at a later date if it can have the Tax applied

[/ QUOTE ]

Can't answer that one. If the boat had a charter licence previously and didn't have an exemption certificate issued at the time, then I suppose mat tax is due retrospectively. But, if a boat doesn't have a current licence then you'd have to be really unlucky to be spotted. I would consult a lawyor
 
[ QUOTE ]
Sounds quite frightening, is the tax retrospective, could you not simply arrange a quick sale to a relative to use a private leisure boat? It would then no longer be a charter boat? Tax avoidance, not evasion?


[/ QUOTE ]

Nice idea but I don't think it would work. The mat tax was theoretically due the first time I used the boat privately after getting the charter licence
 
[ QUOTE ]
The mat tax was theoretically due the first time I used the boat privately after getting the charter licence

[/ QUOTE ]
So say the boat was first used and licenced 3 years ago for chartering would the 12% tax be based on the boat value then??
 
[ QUOTE ]
So say the boat was first used and licenced 3 years ago for chartering would the 12% tax be based on the boat value then??

[/ QUOTE ]

Another good question and I don't know the answer to this one either but it would certainly make a big difference because, as I understand it, the book value on which the tax is based is depreciated by 11% pa to arrive at a current value
 
Mike, as you know we have had all the UK and Spanish papers to charter Seraph in Spanish waters (from Denia) since 2005.

We saw the "writing on the wall" back in February this year and spoke to our Spanish charter legal advisor and told her we were thinking of departing Spain. She said that whilst she couldn't previously tell us of what was transpiring that we were making a wise decision. We took Seraph out of Spain at the end of May and she is now back in the Solent and being re-prepped for charter here.
Didn't see any point of referring to "arising issues" around mat tax/setting up an SL company to continue business in Spain earlier on the forum as it would have been nought but speculation and hearsay (and there has been enough of that)
 
[ QUOTE ]
SO 45 2?

[/ QUOTE ]

I am guessing its a Jeanneau Sun Odessey 45 ( footer )

You know, one of those fab bits of kit with a tall aluminium pole and some white flappy things. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
Top