Lost yachtsman rescued TWICE after using a ROAD ATLAS to navigate.

lenseman

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 Jun 2006
Messages
7,077
Location
South East Coast - United Kingdom
www.dswmarineengineering.com
Furious RNLI chiefs were left with a bill of thousands of pounds after a lifeboat was sent twice in 48 hours to save the same yachtsman – who was using a road atlas to navigate at sea.

In the first drama, Andy Brown had to be saved after he got lost in the middle of the North Sea and wailed to a passing ship, ‘Er, excuse me, which way is it to Hull?’

His 19ft yacht was towed to shore - but two days later he had to be rescued again when he ‘missed’ a harbour channel for boats and ran aground.

The skipper of the yacht Aloysia has received a public dressing down from the RNLI who say the cost of saving him twice over will be thousands of pounds.

They were astonished that Mr Brown appeared to be trying to make a sea voyage using an AA-style road map and without any proper marine charts, radio communications and adequate safety precautions.

The first rescue happened around three o' clock on Thursday morning when the yacht was spotted, apparently lost and going in circles, in the North Sea off the Norfolk coast.

The captain of a ship working at the Sheringham Shoal wind farm 14 miles out to sea reported the bewildered yachtsman had hailed his crew, shouting ‘Which way is Hull?’
Route: Andy Brown was attempting to sail from Great Yarmouth to Hull. On his second voyage he ran aground after missing the harbour channel at Wells

Cromer's all-weather lifeboat Lester was launched and found the yacht wandering forlornly.

A spokesman said ‘The yachtsman was trying to get from Great Yarmouth to Hull without navigational aids and he was totally disorientated - he wasn't sure where he was.’

Rescuers towed the yacht to the safety of the shore and passed it on to another lifeboat, which took it to Great Yarmouth.

Dave Moore, watch officer at Yarmouth Coastguard on the east coast looking out over the North Sea, said ‘The yacht had none of the recommended safety equipment like VHF radio or flares nor navigation aids such as GPS or even charts.

‘This incident was the third in the last few weeks involving recently-purchased craft that were inadequately prepared for the sea. Purchasing a craft over the internet can certainly be problematic.
Ill-equipped: Mr Brown was trying to navigate around the North Sea using a road map (posed by model)

Ill-equipped: Mr Brown was trying to navigate around the North Sea using a road map (posed by model)

‘People get over-enthusiastic with their new purchase and often over-estimate their ability and under-estimate the possible dangers.

‘Especially at the start of the good weather we see an increase in ill-equipped craft and untrained sailors getting into trouble off our coast.’

The second rescue happened yesterday when the Aloysia ran aground after missing the harbour channel at Wells, just down the coast from Cromer.

The Wells inshore lifeboat was launched and the rescue services were astounded to discover it was the same yacht.

Wells lifeboat coxswain Allen Frary said he was alerted by harbourmaster Bob Smith that the Aloysia had run aground on the west side of the harbour channel.

Mr Frary said ‘He went out on the morning tide but apparently turned back because of engine problems.’

He said the craft was stuck fast on the sand, and he and lifeboat operations manager Chris Hardy remained on standby as the yachtsman tried to refloat her.

Then, at around noon, they paged the inshore lifeboat crew, which launched to take the vessel in tow and see it safely to a mooring near the harbour office.

Mr Frary said the sole crewman on board, named as Andrew Brown, appeared to have changed his original plan to sail from Yarmouth to Hull and had instead been making for the Wash port of Boston.

He added that Mr Brown appeared to be ‘using a road atlas to navigate’ rather than GPS and charts and was relying on a mobile phone to liaise with the coastguard.

Mr Frary said huge gusts were blowing...a ‘good south-westerly wind’.

He added ‘I'm trying to find a printable way of putting it - I think the man was completely foolhardy, really.

‘It is absolutely unacceptable for people to put to sea without basic navigational equipment and safety equipment.

‘He is putting his own life at risk and wasting the time and resources of the RNLI.’

Each rescue was reckoned to cost the charity about £3,500, Mr Frary said

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...D-ATLAS-navigate-North-Sea.html#ixzz1zT2bcpH1
 
Yarp... there are already loads of people making 'comments' that there must/should be laws making sure that boats can only be handled by people with 'proper' qualifications and licences... :rolleyes:
 
If we were all master mariners, the RNLI wouldn't have much to do, ok it sounds like the guy's a bit of a Richard Head,7k for rescuing the same man twice is small potatoes to the money spent on a redecoration of the chairmans office:rolleyes: so gossip has it, allegedly.
 
‘It is absolutely unacceptable for people to put to sea without basic navigational equipment and safety equipment.

‘He is putting his own life at risk and wasting the time and resources of the RNLI.’
All the gear and no idea?!

Could you navigate around the coast of the UK using a road atlas? Ok - a road atlas AND a compass?

So, this guy gets a lambasting for having no kit - yet we have a famous mariner who got lost despite having at least 2 chart plotters onboard, flares, lifejackets, liferaft etc etc - and still required the services of the local LB ...

Ok - this guy is obviously a bit of a twot - but not having the kit doesn't make him the twot - not having a clue as to what he's doing does that ...
 
The quoted costs of the rescues are interesting.I suspect they take the entire cost of running the RNLI then divide it by the number of rescues they do per year.

The fact is that a lifeboat costs a fortune to run wether it goes out or not.The only additional costs are the fuel used and a bit of extra engine servicing. Unlikely to add up to an additional cost of £3500 per rescue IMHO.

If that figure were true then the crews weekly training exercise would also cost £3500.
 
Furious RNLI chiefs were left with a bill of thousands of pounds after a lifeboat was sent twice in 48 hours to save the same yachtsman – who was using a road atlas to navigate at sea.

While the yachtsman is rather foolhardy why should RNLI chiefs be furious? They are in "business" to save lives and that costs money. Don't you love the press?
 
I would just like to inform people that the Andy Brown from Cumbria is not the same person as this plonker - although I do have a AA map in my car!!
 
While the yachtsman is rather foolhardy why should RNLI chiefs be furious? They are in "business" to save lives and that costs money. Don't you love the press?

Plus, it ain't even their money, it's ours, Joe Public's!

This sort of criticism of an individual boater in the public domain doesn't aid their cause,

Afterall he's just another satisfied customer:D
 
In the first drama, Andy Brown had to be saved after he got lost in the middle of the North Sea and wailed to a passing ship, ‘Er, excuse me, which way is it to Hull?

Nothing new here! A few years back, I was about 6-7 miles out from Brightlingsea, out of sight of land, when I saw a jet-ski. The guy rode over to me, gave a cheery wave and said "Hey mate, which way is Clacton?"

Being a kind hearted chap, I gave him a cheap hand bearing compass and told him to drive due east. Never heard if he made it back though.

I also once picked up a kid on a lilo just west of the Needles. I took him back to Alum Bay and his parents didn't even know he was missing!

The world is full of idiots, as they say there is one born every minute.

John
 
Furious RNLI chiefs were left with a bill of thousands of pounds after a lifeboat was sent twice in 48 hours to save the same yachtsman – who was using a road atlas to navigate at sea.

"Fury" ... that old favourite of tabloid subeditors trying to make a non-event newsworthy. So, is the Daily Mail trying to knock irresponsible yachtsmen, or to make "RNLI chiefs" - who even the dumbest reader knows do not pay lifeboat bills personally - seem like self-righteous prigs.

It's up there with the recent moronic Mail headline, "Fergie fury at kick-off time for FA Cup final".
 

Other threads that may be of interest

Top