Kill Cords - another incident

Hurricane

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 Nov 2005
Messages
9,859
Location
Sant Carles de la Ràpita
Visit site
We all read about these dangerous events but this time it is it getting "closer to home".
A group of my yachting friends from Sant Carles are out in Mallorca at the moment.
Some of them have been there for several months and will be for several months yet.
Others have joined them recently - indeed we will also be joining them at the end of the month.

One of them has just posted this on the Sant Carles Marina Forum and asked me to circulate it on here - I'll also put a link to here from Scuttlebutt

KILL CORDS CAN KILL
or lack of them, a tragedy can be avoided. Yesterday the 15th July 2014 we were anchored in the beautiful but busy 'es trench' on the south of Mallorca, we are in company of three other
Sant Carles boats, Jane had been snorkelling and came back to the boat complaining of a couple of lads with a jet rib and wakeboard close by the boats, Jane alway drags an orange float behind her so as to make her more visible to the many dinghys, jet ribs, ribs and ski boats that are constantly weaving their way between the anchored boats. It's great fun for them to see the whites of our eyes when they see how I close they can get to us with the biggest wash. But hey it's part of the boating bit and we have to accept it.
So one lad falls off his wakeboard and his mate in the powerful jet rib decides it's gonna be great fun to do multiple donoughts around him, this is 30 metres from our boat, the centrifugal force throws him out of the rib and guess what he has no KILL CORD attached. The rib now being much lighter accelerates out of control in a huge arc around and between anchored power and sailing boats as well as swimmers, then like an Exocet it makes a return curve and we watched helplessly as it crashed at some 25 knots into the back of Geoffs dinghy which is tied to the back of his catamaran "Mee Too". Geoff was sitting in the back of his dinghy tinkering with the engine with the cover off, the rib smashed away his outboard, rode over the top of Geoff injuring his arm, head, face, back and leg, the rib then carried on and smashed into the upper transom of the catamaran taking away all of the guard rails, barbecue and fenders, had the fenders and guardrail not been there then the rib would have carried on through the seating area of the cat where Lynn and dog Meg were sitting, this in itself could have been tragic.
The damaged rib then slid back into the water, fortunately it had now knocked itself out of gear but was still revving madly. Jane and I along with a German man and son were first on the scene, thankfully the German guy managed to turn the rib engine off while we attended to Geoff who was more worried that the driver of the rib might be under or in the water, he was in a bit of a daze, but still both him and Lynn were concerned more for the driver than themselves. With the aid of Alistair ' Viking' and Peter ' White Cat' we were able to help out. I am not going to go now into aftermath in dealing with the charter boats captain, the police and the coastguard, suffice to say that it is now a case of Geoff and Lynn having to sort out their insurance and us going by cab to Palma to make a formal police report. Geoff now has to source a new outboard, but stoic people that they are they are not going to let it spoil there Balearics cruise.
Please let it be a warning to all of us, these toys that we all love are fun but also dangerous, it is up to us as skippers and owners to make sure we show the initiative to alway wear a Kill Cord, to make sure our love ones and friends always do, especially the younger more exuberant members. This thankfully ended up with no one seriously hurt it could have ended up as a tragedy with someone facing a manslaughter charge. We all remember that family tragedy a while ago in Cornwall, it can be prevented. BTW, neither off the Spanish lads involved in the wake boarding had bouancy aids on or a spotter in the rear of the rib.
Please,nI don't want this post to be a tirade of replies or anecdotes, just a warning. I am going to also post this on the Cruising Association forum and ask that Mike JW posts it YBM forum

This could have been a very nasty incident.
 
scary indeed - though the anchorage doesn't sound like much fun either.

kill cords are simply not good enough. The RNLI has it right, spring loaded throttles. Jet skis do too (do they all?). They should be more common.
 
We were anchored in es trenc today, I was surprised at the speed the various ribs were going between the boats, it doesn't seem to be as big an issue in other anchorages, I wonder if the wide open nature of the bay encourages people to go faster than they would in a smaller bay.
 
We all read about these dangerous events but this time it is it getting "closer to home".
A group of my yachting friends from Sant Carles are out in Mallorca at the moment.
Some of them have been there for several months and will be for several months yet.
Others have joined them recently - indeed we will also be joining them at the end of the month.

One of them has just posted this on the Sant Carles Marina Forum and asked me to circulate it on here - I'll also put a link to here from Scuttlebutt

KILL CORDS CAN KILL
or lack of them, a tragedy can be avoided. Yesterday the 15th July 2014 we were anchored in the beautiful but busy 'es trench' on the south of Mallorca, we are in company of three other
Sant Carles boats, Jane had been snorkelling and came back to the boat complaining of a couple of lads with a jet rib and wakeboard close by the boats, Jane alway drags an orange float behind her so as to make her more visible to the many dinghys, jet ribs, ribs and ski boats that are constantly weaving their way between the anchored boats. It's great fun for them to see the whites of our eyes when they see how I close they can get to us with the biggest wash. But hey it's part of the boating bit and we have to accept it.
So one lad falls off his wakeboard and his mate in the powerful jet rib decides it's gonna be great fun to do multiple donoughts around him, this is 30 metres from our boat, the centrifugal force throws him out of the rib and guess what he has no KILL CORD attached. The rib now being much lighter accelerates out of control in a huge arc around and between anchored power and sailing boats as well as swimmers, then like an Exocet it makes a return curve and we watched helplessly as it crashed at some 25 knots into the back of Geoffs dinghy which is tied to the back of his catamaran "Mee Too". Geoff was sitting in the back of his dinghy tinkering with the engine with the cover off, the rib smashed away his outboard, rode over the top of Geoff injuring his arm, head, face, back and leg, the rib then carried on and smashed into the upper transom of the catamaran taking away all of the guard rails, barbecue and fenders, had the fenders and guardrail not been there then the rib would have carried on through the seating area of the cat where Lynn and dog Meg were sitting, this in itself could have been tragic.
The damaged rib then slid back into the water, fortunately it had now knocked itself out of gear but was still revving madly. Jane and I along with a German man and son were first on the scene, thankfully the German guy managed to turn the rib engine off while we attended to Geoff who was more worried that the driver of the rib might be under or in the water, he was in a bit of a daze, but still both him and Lynn were concerned more for the driver than themselves. With the aid of Alistair ' Viking' and Peter ' White Cat' we were able to help out. I am not going to go now into aftermath in dealing with the charter boats captain, the police and the coastguard, suffice to say that it is now a case of Geoff and Lynn having to sort out their insurance and us going by cab to Palma to make a formal police report. Geoff now has to source a new outboard, but stoic people that they are they are not going to let it spoil there Balearics cruise.
Please let it be a warning to all of us, these toys that we all love are fun but also dangerous, it is up to us as skippers and owners to make sure we show the initiative to alway wear a Kill Cord, to make sure our love ones and friends always do, especially the younger more exuberant members. This thankfully ended up with no one seriously hurt it could have ended up as a tragedy with someone facing a manslaughter charge. We all remember that family tragedy a while ago in Cornwall, it can be prevented. BTW, neither off the Spanish lads involved in the wake boarding had bouancy aids on or a spotter in the rear of the rib.
Please,nI don't want this post to be a tirade of replies or anecdotes, just a warning. I am going to also post this on the Cruising Association forum and ask that Mike JW posts it YBM forum

This could have been a very nasty incident.
A filleting knife would have proved useful, to stop it ever happening again
 
Incredible story. I will knock es Trenc of places to go this summer which is sad as I know how beautiful it is.... Espalmador is as bad, perhaps not the speed but just so busy people are almost always hitting swimmers...

Glad that your friends are ok and that they are cracking on with their cruise. Let's hope that's the end of heir bad luck.
 
Something I realised this weekend too (while at 34kts in a speedboat) is that it's not sufficient to simply attach the kill cord to your leg/lifejacket if you're in a comfy seat in a speedboat. When attached to your wrist a short kill cord can stop the engine if you fall unconscious for instance when hitting a wave and knocking your head on the dashboard. Attached to your leg while seated it would do nothing at all. Obviously on a RIB seat you'd probably fall off if you were unconscious but in a speedboat seat this wouldn't happen.
 
Re-located the kill switch from my 15HP Suzuki on my little RIB 'Kita' from the front of the engine to the flat dash panel just below the wheel last Winter - a piece of two core, a couple of bullet connectors and about 20 minutes including drilling the new mount hole. Now whoever is driving clips it on, and already it has stopped the engine when they have left the wheel without unclipping a few times. I proudly wore it around the market in Lymington this weekend past, dangling from my lifejacket strap.

Acts as a mild theft deterrent too.
 
Coincidentally, have been anchored next to 'Me Too' in Es Trenc for the last couple of days. My wife was on the flybridge when this happened and it was truly shocking - the chap on the back of the cat was very nearly killed and the outboard on the tender was snapped clean in two. I didn't see the accident because I'd just swum to the beach with four kids, doesn't bear thinking about. Apparently the Spanish police rather philosophically said they have saying for these near death events, something about 'today being the start of your second life', very true in this case...
 
Coincidentally, have been anchored next to 'Me Too' in Es Trenc for the last couple of days. My wife was on the flybridge when this happened and it was truly shocking - the chap on the back of the cat was very nearly killed and the outboard on the tender was snapped clean in two. I didn't see the accident because I'd just swum to the beach with four kids, doesn't bear thinking about. Apparently the Spanish police rather philosophically said they have saying for these near death events, something about 'today being the start of your second life', very true in this case...

Wow it was worse than I originally thought.
Last I heard was yesterday - the day after the accident.
It seems that Geoff did take a trip to the hospital - the writer of the report went with him.
I think all is ok though.
 
Just had this posted by Geoff himself on the Sant Carles Marina Forum.

Thank you for all your kind wishes, I am feeling a lot better today, although the hassle factor with insurance companies etc I could do without. We are still at anchor in Trench relying on the SC crowd we are with, to take us ashore.

So, it seems that this was a very lucky escape.
 
That is a horrible story to read. But, if it even makes 1 person to remember to wear their killcord then there's a positive outcome (sorry i'm an optimist)

I hope your friends get back to health soon, and secondly that they get their boat repaired. IMHO once a toy (whether a car or boat) has been damaged, it'll never be seen in the same light again.
 
Re-located the kill switch from my 15HP Suzuki on my little RIB 'Kita' from the front of the engine to the flat dash panel just below the wheel last Winter - a piece of two core, a couple of bullet connectors and about 20 minutes including drilling the new mount hole. Now whoever is driving clips it on, and already it has stopped the engine when they have left the wheel without unclipping a few times. I proudly wore it around the market in Lymington this weekend past, dangling from my lifejacket strap.


Acts as a mild theft deterrent too.

We could start a new fashion.....Medalian man
 
Top