Jordan series drogue attachement point

geem

Well-known member
Joined
27 Apr 2006
Messages
8,043
Location
Caribbean
Visit site
Are there ever side loads on a drogue? That might rip the toerail off bolt by bolt.
I have never used it anger but I had the same thought.
I use both the 400mm long deck cleats (4x M10 fixings) and the toerail. I have some dyneema strops that tie the cleats to the toerail fixings. This limits sideways force, hopefully. The idea is to share the load. I did consider bespoke fixing to the hull but it's a lot of work since the hull is lined with teak tongue and groove in the back cabin. I would need to remove it. I am not sure how we would deal with the fixings and the teak finish. I have never been in conditions that I ever thought I needed it. Hope to remain that way🙂
 

AntarcticPilot

Well-known member
Joined
4 May 2007
Messages
10,444
Location
Cambridge, UK
www.cooperandyau.co.uk
They sometimes are. I have s/s sandwich plates to bolt to my toerail. 150 M8 bolts each side should be enough🙂
I think it depends on the engineering of the toerail. Mine is an integral part of the hull/deck join, and I can't imagine any chain plate type structure being stronger. But a toerail that is bolted on and not part of the structure might not be so strong. That said, mine is probably too high to be a good attachment point for a drogue - freeboard at the stern is well over a metre, maybe 1.5m, and I suspect there would be too great a downward force. Just visualising it, I guess you want the pull of the drogue to be level with the centre of buoyancy?

Theoretical interest to me; I don't intend to do the kind of sailing where it would be a useful precaution!
 

RunAgroundHard

Well-known member
Joined
20 Aug 2022
Messages
2,124
Visit site
... What am I overlooking?

1. Are you sure the cleats are strong enough? Do you have data for the cleat stating its strength?
2. Are the cleats in sound condition? Is there unseen strain within the cleat due to deformation or previous overloading?
3. Have you inspected the cleats for external cracks or internal flaws created when forged or cast?
4. What is the GRP like under the cleat and internally?
5. Is the cleat in the right position to allow the JSD to be attached and used in the safest and securest manner?

I think using the cleats is a shit idea, mainly because they are in the wrong position, too far forward and you have no idea of the actual condition of the cleat. Under survival conditions the load may be too much. Personally I would not rely on the existing cleats. Of course, you could remove them and have the cleat load tested, then modify the lead for the JSD by mounting them in a different position, or fitting something to deflect the JSD and protect it against wear at the pushpit.

If it was me, I would add side plates to the quarter, just below the gunwale. Inside I would build up the GRP to make a much thicker area with the GRP shaped to distribute the loading as evenly as possible i.e. tear drop shaped, tapered layers of cloth. I wonder if stronger winds, less easily predicted, and therefore more likely to catch us out, is now starting due to MMGW and therefore use of a JSD or other device is more likely, even using current prediction tools. Or, in other words, when you need to rely on a JSD, you need to be certain that it will work and not fail in a manner that puts the boat at greater risk.

Lots of information on JSD attachment points. Remove the head lining and fit side plates , or top mounted plates. Don't use the cleats.

OceanBrake
A subscription service with details on mounts for JSD Category: Online Book: Heavy Weather Tactics
 

zoidberg

Well-known member
Joined
12 Nov 2016
Messages
6,192
Visit site
I think we need a clear idea of what we're trying to achieve with a Jordan Series Drogue, before we get too far into the minutiae of how we do it.

Don Jordan was appalled at the loss of life in the '79 Fastnet Disaster. Many boats were rolled by breaking, jetting seas. People died in consequence. He set out to find a way to prevent a repetition, and came up with the 'Jordan Series Drogue'.

It's worth bearing in mind that the seas and conditions that killed so many happened in our backyard. And could again.
I've sailed in such sea states off Portland. And off the SW of Wales. Even the bottom end of the Needles Channel does, as the local lifeboat coxn will tell you. Certainly, the Celtic Sea produces such conditions, in places, quite frequently.

'A breaking sea >60% of a boat's length will ALWAYS roll a boat which is beam on....'


Those sea conditions happen quite frequently for a <30' boat ( e.g. Jesters ) in 'home waters'. They happen often for up to 50' boats on a Biscay passage....
Should you wish to challenge, or dismiss, those findings then take it up with the Wolfson Institute of Southampton University who did the research.

Now, Don Jordan calculated that a Maximum Sea Strike would impart into a boat up to 70% of its LADEN weight. That's what the JSD - and each part of its fittings and fastenings - must withstand. I've learned that few ensure the hull structure - into which that load may be imparted - is up to the task.
Sure, the steel straps and/or cleats are - or seem to be - sufficient. Sure, the JSD rode itself is usually more than sufficient ( provided the LADEN weight is factored in ). But few, I'm advised, take professional/competent advice on the local strength of the hull and its local reinforcements.

My concern is for the 'That looks about right' eyeball judgement..... and others agree that's not good enough.

I'd also challenge the 'I don't intend to do that kind of sailing' attitude. Bluntly, if you're out of sight of a weather haven, you don't get the choice......
 

WindyWindyWindy

Active member
Joined
5 Feb 2022
Messages
401
Visit site
If it was me, I would add side plates to the quarter, just below the gunwale. Inside I would build up the GRP to make a much thicker area with the GRP shaped to distribute the loading as evenly as possible i.e. tear drop shaped, tapered layers of cloth.
You've still just eyeballed it, to call it engineering would require some adding up.

Cleats might well be designed to take the weight of the boat for all I know.

It's perhaps also worth considering the breaking strength of the rope that's transmitting the load it can't be more than that can it?

Could you put enough stretch in with octoplait nylon to significantly reduce snatch loads?

Can you say that with a bridle on two cleats that the load is halved or could it still load up entirely on one side if the boat sheared?
 

zoidberg

Well-known member
Joined
12 Nov 2016
Messages
6,192
Visit site
* You've still just eyeballed it, to call it engineering would require some adding up.

** Cleats might well be designed to take the weight of the boat for all I know.

*** It's perhaps also worth considering the breaking strength of the rope that's transmitting the load it can't be more than that can it?

**** Could you put enough stretch in with octoplait nylon to significantly reduce snatch loads?

***** Can you say that with a bridle on two cleats that the load is halved or could it still load up entirely on one side if the boat sheared?

Er....

* That's been done for me by pros in composites structural engineering, found via Sailing Anarchy. Checked valid by another pro in the UK.

** Possible, but consider also the bolts. It would be surprising if a cleat was SPECIFICALLY designed for such. 'Welded-on' would likely suffice.

*** I have specified 11mm Dyneema. That's capable of more than the AUW of my laden boat. 12mm diameter is even easier to handle....

**** The core principle of the JSD is that the Reverse Catenary created by the far end sinking achieves the desired 'soft snubbing' effect. Don Jordan specifically ruled out the 'dynamic recovery' concept - obvious why when one watches Offroad Vehicle Snatch Recovery videos.
Nylon loses significant strength when wet. It also loses significant strength under UV exposure. It is significantly worse than polyester and other modern ropes.

***** Don Jordan's premise is that the Maximum Wave Strike load is shared between both bridle arms. The JSD concept is that a sudden asymmetric load caused by wave-strike would pull the rear of the boat in line as the load progressively increased. This is experienced in practice.
It is conceivable that one bridle-arm could part/detach through chafe or unscrewed shackle pin. Making each bridle arm capable of absorbing the WHOLE MaxWaveStrike load is easy, using Dyneema..... and anti-chafe protection.

The above represents one conscientious student's understanding, There may be scope for preferences and for use of better materials, but the mechanics of what's wanted and how to achieve it are well established.
 

Roberto

Well-known member
Joined
20 Jul 2001
Messages
5,330
Location
Lorient/Paris
sybrancaleone.blogspot.com
Some consideration should be given to the construction of the JSD itself, the OCC Flying Fish magazine has a picture of what was left of a commercial JSD after having been used, it has copyright but it's basically a long rope with shredded pieces of webbing and fabric all along its length. The crew praised its effects, one wonders if towing a long "dirty"rope would be much different
 

WindyWindyWindy

Active member
Joined
5 Feb 2022
Messages
401
Visit site
Er....

* That's been done for me by pros in composites structural engineering, found via Sailing Anarchy. Checked valid by another pro in the UK.
I think that's what I was saying to the other guy. To do it right requires an engineer to design it for the specific boat.

That said I wonder what weight a cleat can take, they do usually have pretty hefty attachments.
 

dgadee

Well-known member
Joined
13 Oct 2010
Messages
3,862
Visit site
I contacted West with my plan to fit two 12mm eyes to the stern of my Dehler and tie the stern to the inside of the hull. Ply and SS plates encapsulated in epoxy glass. They said "should be fine". I can send pics - am on board now.

Oceanbrake (UK) said
Under normal operation the load on the bridles would be around 250 Kg. It is only for an exceptional wave strike that Jordan's design had the higher figures, so with everything secured well as you propose, it will be good.
 

14K478

Well-known member
Joined
15 Aug 2023
Messages
593
Visit site
A very interesting thread.

I keep thinking about a JSD and making or buying the JSD is the easy part.

The chain plates each able to take 70% of the laden displacement are more challenging.

Ripping the stern off the boat would be counterproductive.

I can’t do the maths, so I would need someone who can.

I fancy that at the least some more glassing on an already old and very well cured hull will be needed. I really don’t want to take the internal reinforcements past the aft watertight bulkhead… the laden displacement is 24 tons, so that’s a load of 17 tons, not necessarily coming in line with either chain plate.

I want the series drogue and its gubbins stowed in the lazarette and not already secured to the chain plates but able to be secured quickly and simply to chains secured to the chain plates with their free ends held on deck.

I think we are looking at internal backing plates bolted to external chain plates, probably with some extra glassing. Certainly the deck moulding is nowhere near strong enough in tension.

IMG_0942.jpeg
 
Last edited:

noelex

Well-known member
Joined
2 Jul 2005
Messages
4,779
Visit site
These are the rear cleats and fairleads on our boat. These have been professionally engineered to cope with the loads expected from a JSD.

The cleats are not just welded on the deck, instead the twin aluminium Sampson posts continue under the deck and are welded to multiple stringers. In addition, gussets spread the load.

This is probably overkill, but it does show how a professional design team engineer attachment points suitable for a JSD.

The photo below was taken during construction:

P5210748.jpeg
 
Last edited:

zoidberg

Well-known member
Joined
12 Nov 2016
Messages
6,192
Visit site
I think we need a clear idea of what we're trying to achieve with a Jordan Series Drogue, before we get too far into the minutiae of how we do it.

'A breaking sea >60% of a boat's length will ALWAYS roll a boat which is beam on....'

Those sea conditions happen quite frequently for a <30' boat ( e.g. Jesters ) in 'home waters'. They happen often for up to 50' boats on a Biscay passage....

I came across this short video-clip, which should remind us of what the problem looks like...

 

veshengro

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jan 2023
Messages
1,052
Visit site
Did the designer/seller of these Drogues go bust? If everyone who attempted to buy one was advised to uprate/rebuild their boats to the standards that some people are suggesting, I doubt he sold very many. Certainly none to the major European boat makers I would think.
 

geem

Well-known member
Joined
27 Apr 2006
Messages
8,043
Location
Caribbean
Visit site
Did the designer/seller of these Drogues go bust? If everyone who attempted to buy one was advised to uprate/rebuild their boats to the standards that some people are suggesting, I doubt he sold very many. Certainly none to the major European boat makers I would think.
He didn't sell them. He gave away the design so others could build their own or have them made. Most European sailors don't need one if you are coastal cruising.
 

noelex

Well-known member
Joined
2 Jul 2005
Messages
4,779
Visit site
Did the designer/seller of these Drogues go bust? If everyone who attempted to buy one was advised to uprate/rebuild their boats to the standards that some people are suggesting, I doubt he sold very many. Certainly none to the major European boat makers I would think.
A drogue is a specialised piece of equipment that is likely to be carried only by some long distance cruising boats, so the market is quite small. A suitable attachment point can be fabricated for most production yachts. Yachts contemplating carrying a JSD will typically have already been modified with additions such as solar panels, extra shade, davits, larger battery bank, more significant ground tackle etc. Installing attachment points for a JSD is just one additional modification.

This attachment also provides a strong point should the boat need towing from the stern off a serious grounding.
 
Top