I Keep getting offers on my boat

Best thing to do is photograph the boat when you buy it then use the same pics to sell it on (assuming you've not ruined it in the intervening period)!

I'm not sure that's legal unless you draw attention to the fact that the photos are not current. I'm no legal beagle but possibly the Sale of Goods Act and the Misrepresentation Act may have something to say about this
 
No, but as a generalisation (there will always be exceptions) they do take marketing seriously..

I posted the Ancasta thread ( http://www.ybw.com/forums/showthread.php?t=287457 ) in response to your comment that they (Ancasta) take their marketing seriously when we can clearly see that this isn’t the case at all. Ancasta are prepared to accept any cr*p as marketing material and use it – the photos they’ve used in this add is testament to that.
And, and it’s a big and, if I was to accept the argument put forward by Scaramoosh that the seller of the boat has chosen to use Ancasta because they are the best ( or at least I inferred that this was his point of the post ) how on earth are they going to market a boat that could be many hundreds of miles away? Have Ancasta even been on board the boat? Are Ancasta going to escort a prospective buyer around a boat that could be several hours drive away on the slight chance that they might make a sale? I think not.
Scarmoosh has used several suppositions in his post but the fact remains that I can’t accept that Ancasta “take marketing seriously”.
 
Last edited:
I posted the Ancasta thread ( http://www.ybw.com/forums/showthread.php?t=287457 ) in response to your comment that they (Ancasta) take their marketing seriously when we can clearly see that this isn’t the case at all. Ancasta are prepared to accept any cr*p as marketing material and use it – the photos they’ve used in this add is testament to that.
And, and it’s a big and, if I was to accept the argument put forward by Scaramoosh that the seller of the boat has chosen to use Ancasta because they are the best ( or at least I inferred that this was his point of the post ) how on earth are they going to market a boat that could be many hundreds of miles away? Have Ancasta even been on board the boat? Are Ancasta going to escort a prospective buyer around a boat that could be several hours drive away on the slight chance that they might make a sale? I think not.
Scarmoosh has used several suppositions in his post but the fact remains that I can’t accept that Ancasta “take marketing seriously”.

I think I have to assume from the handbags at dawn post you are not the secretary of the Ancasta fan club? :D
 
I'm not sure that's legal unless you draw attention to the fact that the photos are not current. I'm no legal beagle but possibly the Sale of Goods Act and the Misrepresentation Act may have something to say about this

Can't see that. Brokers use brochure shots (for instance) all the time. They're not only not current, but not even the actual boat.

As long as they're not stating "these were taken two weeks ago" and their actual claims for the boat are legitimate then I can't imagine it would be a problem.
 
excellent publicity for a boat for sale! 11 pages and numerous posts and viewings..what would that sort of advertising cost? not sold it yet?
Pitching the price using other boats for sale as a comparison is all well and good..except they are still for sale, i.e. they haven't sold.
I am in the market for something around 10m/twin diesels but it would be much newer ...however before I travel to view I would be wanting to have it understood that, as a cash buyer in this buyers' market I have no intention of paying the asking price and am looking for an exceptionally good deal for m'pennies. The buyer wants to sell while I just fancy a new toy. Once bought I am going to have to sell again at some time or other in the future and I am sure prospective buyers will then be just as rare as they are now, so I need to make sure I buy right now.
 
excellent publicity for a boat for sale! 11 pages and numerous posts and viewings..what would that sort of advertising cost? not sold it yet?
Pitching the price using other boats for sale as a comparison is all well and good..except they are still for sale, i.e. they haven't sold.
I am in the market for something around 10m/twin diesels but it would be much newer ...however before I travel to view I would be wanting to have it understood that, as a cash buyer in this buyers' market I have no intention of paying the asking price and am looking for an exceptionally good deal for m'pennies. The buyer wants to sell while I just fancy a new toy. Once bought I am going to have to sell again at some time or other in the future and I am sure prospective buyers will then be just as rare as they are now, so I need to make sure I buy right now.

Some bargains to be had for sure but beware of the duff stuff.

Had a call this morning and an offer (unseen) on a £75K boat for £50k, due to the "current climate and it was cash".

The chap was genuinely surprised to be turned down flat at his 33% under asking offer.

Couldn't grasp the fact that they were all cash at the end of the day anyway.
 
excellent publicity for a boat for sale! 11 pages and numerous posts and viewings..what would that sort of advertising cost? not sold it yet?
Pitching the price using other boats for sale as a comparison is all well and good..except they are still for sale, i.e. they haven't sold.
I am in the market for something around 10m/twin diesels but it would be much newer ...however before I travel to view I would be wanting to have it understood that, as a cash buyer in this buyers' market I have no intention of paying the asking price and am looking for an exceptionally good deal for m'pennies. The buyer wants to sell while I just fancy a new toy. Once bought I am going to have to sell again at some time or other in the future and I am sure prospective buyers will then be just as rare as they are now, so I need to make sure I buy right now.


Can't really get my head around this cash buyer business, makes no difference to me where the money comes from, be it cash, a cheque, finance, credit card, loan account etc, just so long as it ends up in my bank account.

I would hazard a guess that you probably won't be paying a large sum, say £50K in £20 notes?
 
I would hazard a guess that you probably won't be paying a large sum, say £50K in £20 notes?

Actually a cash buyer would put me off as a seller. First, you can't tell whether the notes are forged and second, no bank would accept £50k in cash unless you regularly deposit large amounts of cash. Due to money laundering rules, the max they'll generally accept these days is about £10k and even then, they might ask questions. So it would be a case of keeping it under your mattress
 
ok cash buyer meaning I have the money, the wherewithall, with which I would like to pay, and not a dreamer/tyre kicker/fender kicker and do not have to, and would not, go searching for finance.
If I can't pay for it then I can't afford it and then I don't buy it.
It would be unlikely that I would place £20 notes in any ones hand both for their and my protection. I wouldnt want it in cash myself particularly for security risks and also cos the bank likes to charge me for cash deposits but not other forms of money transfer.
I don't think I'm going to get what I'm looking for for that £50k guess but am always prepared to be pleasantly surprised.
 
excellent publicity for a boat for sale! 11 pages and numerous posts and viewings..what would that sort of advertising cost? not sold it yet?
Pitching the price using other boats for sale as a comparison is all well and good..except they are still for sale, i.e. they haven't sold.
I am in the market for something around 10m/twin diesels but it would be much newer ...however before I travel to view I would be wanting to have it understood that, as a cash buyer in this buyers' market I have no intention of paying the asking price and am looking for an exceptionally good deal for m'pennies. The buyer wants to sell while I just fancy a new toy. Once bought I am going to have to sell again at some time or other in the future and I am sure prospective buyers will then be just as rare as they are now, so I need to make sure I buy right now.


That sound like a bit of a smartarse attitude, what if the boat you wants is new to the market at an absolute bargain price, then your refusal to pay the asking may well result in a more realistic buyer beating you to it.
 
Some bargains to be had for sure but beware of the duff stuff.

Had a call this morning and an offer (unseen) on a £75K boat for £50k, due to the "current climate and it was cash".

The chap was genuinely surprised to be turned down flat at his 33% under asking offer.

Couldn't grasp the fact that they were all cash at the end of the day anyway.

Interesting as I am a buyer with funds availble and have also had a similar offer rejected today. I didn't portray myself as a 'cash buyer' but did make it known that I have money available and was serious (we had viewed the boat).

Thing is, I have no problem with the offer being rejected as the boat is someone else's pride and joy and if they don't want to let it go for what I am offering that is their prerogative and is completely understandable.

What I am unable to understand is the tone of the response from the broker. He was less than constructive and his e-mail came across as being a bit snotty. Now I would have thought that a professional broker would have done his best to keep us on side and to see if he could close the gap between our offer and what the seller wants to achieve but no, he didn't and instead will probably see a relativley rare buyer for a mobo going elsewhere.

Not bashing Brokers here and certainly not you jonic - just surprised at the response.
 
Last edited:
That sound like a bit of a smartarse attitude, what if the boat you wants is new to the market at an absolute bargain price, then your refusal to pay the asking may well result in a more realistic buyer beating you to it.
then so be it....plenty of fish in the sea etc. for as seems to be agreed it is a buyer's market and the loss of a particular boat is not going top keep me awake at night, but I am unlikely to be so naive as to not to have researched the length of time the boat has been for sale etc
Smartarse... hmm maybe, that is a matter of opinion, but never ever rude and if the seller rejects a proposed price then thats fine, there are no hard feelings, I have not wasted their time, and I would wish him/her well in securing a better price whilst I look elsewhere.
Cash buyer...funny when I bought a house I was described as a cash buyer as I had the funds & did not have to sell a property before buying this one and could just get on with it-but nobody ever thought I was going to place actual notes in their hand.
 
then so be it....plenty of fish in the sea etc. for as seems to be agreed it is a buyer's market and the loss of a particular boat is not going top keep me awake at night, but I am unlikely to be so naive as to not to have researched the length of time the boat has been for sale etc
Smartarse... hmm maybe, that is a matter of opinion, but never ever rude and if the seller rejects a proposed price then thats fine, there are no hard feelings, I have not wasted their time, and I would wish him/her well in securing a better price whilst I look elsewhere.
Cash buyer...funny when I bought a house I was described as a cash buyer as I had the funds & did not have to sell a property before buying this one and could just get on with it-but nobody ever thought I was going to place actual notes in their hand.

Have you thought, that you might just be coming across as aragant.

Folk may want to sell, but that does not mean there peniless. Or want treating like a plonker.

On at least one occasion, I just decided, I did not want to deal with that type of folk.
 
Interesting as I am a buyer with funds availble and have also had a similar offer rejected today. I didn't portray myself as a 'cash buyer' but did make it known that I have money available and was serious (we had viewed the boat).

Thing is, I have no problem with the offer being rejected as the boat is someone else's pride and joy and if they don't want to let it go for what I am offering that is their prerogative and is completely understandable.

What I am unable to understand is the tone of the response from the broker. He was less than constructive and his e-mail came across as being a bit snotty. Now I would have thought that a professional broker would have done his best to keep us on side and to see if he could close the gap between our offer and what the seller wants to achieve but no, he didn't and instead will probably see a relativley rare buyer for a mobo going elsewhere.

Not bashing Brokers here and certainly not you jonic - just surprised at the response.

Ok, I am going to be gentle here Greg and absolutely no offence is meant. :)

But if you have made an offer 33% under a fair asking price he has seen you absolutely as you have portrayed yourself....as someone who clearly can't afford it.

His client is paying him to keep time wasters away and that is also exactly how you have presented yourself to him. All be it unknowingly.

Sorry but it's true, and I say again there is no offence meant here at all.

The problem is that over the last 10 years, the fake house price boom has created a get rich quick mentality as houses go up, followed by a get rich quick on the downside mentality by bidding low as they come down.

In very simplistic terms.

Fuelled entirely by the deliberate extension and availability of credit everybody's house went "up" in value. Some people thought they were geniuses because they had made so much money. Then found they were nothing more than lambs to the slaughter as they "released" their new found equity by taking out an even bigger loan with the gleeful banker who had created the illusion in the first place. (Some of them bought brand new boats and more of them later.)

So now the inevitable is happening and the music has stopped, that house price inflation is deflating. Along come the next level of geniuses who offer well under the inflated asking price and get such a bargain. Perhaps as much as 30% off. Not realising that all that is happening is the excess is coming back off as credit contracts.

The gleeful banker gives our new round of buyers more credit to buy the houses he is now repossessing from the first lot. If our banker gets his sums wrong and runs out of his fictitious credit it doesn't matter. He can lawfully get the tax payer to bail him out. (That's the same guy he's saddling the loans with.) The amount of fictitious credit allowed in the system is set by the central bank. In basic terms this is the amount of pass the parcel money they can get away with before Mr and Mrs Saver smell a rat and en-mass (like Northern Rock) they all demand their money back at the same time only to discover there isn't enough to go round.No problem as the tax payer can again bail them out and the central bank can do some quantitative easing. I.E create some more fictitious money.

But also, houses are generally bought and sold out of need.

They are bought when you need another bedroom for the new baby or when you need a smaller house when the kids go to Uni.

They are sold when the owner needs to pay back the 100's of 1000's that he owes the bank and can no longer service the loan

Apart from the new boats bought with the fictitious release of equity none of these factors apply in the same way to a brokerage boat.

It probably wasn't bought out of need, more like desire.

It was probably paid for without a loan, so there is no banker chasing.

It definitely didn't go up in value so there is no excess to bid low against.

In fact it has slowly fallen in value.

Unless our owner is in serious trouble elsewhere he has no need to sell at 30% under. If you can't service your house mortgage you are in trouble but our cash strapped boaters main cost is his berthing.

Lets say it cost £6,000 a year and cash is getting a bit tight. Does he take a 30% (say £20,000 or £30,000) hit on his boat....or move to a swinging mooring for a £1000 for the next year.

Unless he owes money on the boat he's going on the mooring.

The thing to remember is that unlike houses most brokerage boats did not go up and are not subject to a loan. So that 30% off mentality you find in a house price crash simply does not exist.

The market tends to just go stagnant then drop a bit as buyer numbers diminish for a while.

You will find bargains due to personal circumstances, but not in the numbers you may imagine.

Greg I am honestly not bashing you here, just trying to show the differences.

If you want a bargain get serious with the broker because he is as keen as you are to do a deal, but it wont happen with ridiculous bids unless the seller has very pressing personal circumstances.

Another broker I know likens the housing market to steep peaks and deep valleys whereas the brokerage boat market is more like gentle undulating meadows.
 
Last edited:
Have you thought, that you might just be coming across as aragant.

Folk may want to sell, but that does not mean there peniless. Or want treating like a plonker.

On at least one occasion, I just decided, I did not want to deal with that type of folk.

Different scale but the first boat I bought many years ago, a Boston Whaler Montauk, about a year old, I got for a bargain price. The seller wanted a certain price which we both knew was well under the true value and on this basis I considered it excellent value so did not quibble about paying the asking price.
When we concluded the paperwork I asked if he had had much interest (the boat had not been advertised, it was all local word of mouth) and he told me that someone had phoned up and offered the asking price minus 10%. He immediately said no. The phone rang again 15 minutes later and the same chap then offered the asking price. The seller asked why he hadn't done this in the first place and the potential buyer said that it was a matter of principle to always offer less than the asking price. The vendor then told him that as a matter of principle he wouldn't sell it to him at any price! End of conversation.
So the idea of always looking for a bargain even if it's already a bargain doesn't always work. I bought the boat, used it for a year or so and then sold it for 50% more than I paid for it.
So what lessons did I learn from this. Quite simply if I want to buy something and I consider it already to be priced right I won't haggle. If I consider it to be overpriced then I will haggle. Maybe others think differently, that's up to them, but as evidenced first hand that way is not always successful.
 
Ok, I am going to be gentle here Greg and absolutely no offence is meant. :)

But if you have made an offer 33% under a fair asking price he has seen you absolutely as you have portrayed yourself....as someone who clearly can't afford it.

His client is paying him to keep time wasters away and that is also exactly how you have presented yourself to him. All be it unknowingly.

Sorry but it's true, and I say again there is no offence meant here at all.

The problem is that over the last 10 years, the fake house price boom has created a get rich quick mentality as houses go up, followed by a get rich quick on the downside mentality by bidding low as they come down.

In very simplistic terms.

Fuelled entirely by the deliberate extension and availability of credit everybody's house went "up" in value. Some people thought they were geniuses because they had made so much money. Then found they were nothing more than lambs to the slaughter as they "released" their new found equity by taking out an even bigger loan with the gleeful banker who had created the illusion in the first place. (Some of them bought brand new boats and more of them later.)

So now the inevitable is happening and the music has stopped, that house price inflation is deflating. Along come the next level of geniuses who offer well under the inflated asking price and get such a bargain. Perhaps as much as 30% off. Not realising that all that is happening is the excess is coming back off as credit contracts.

The gleeful banker gives our new round of buyers more credit to buy the houses he is now repossessing from the first lot. If our banker gets his sums wrong and runs out of his fictitious credit it doesn't matter. He can lawfully get the tax payer to bail him out. (That's the same guy he's saddling the loans with.) The amount of fictitious credit allowed in the system is set by the central bank. In basic terms this is the amount of pass the parcel money they can get away with before Mr and Mrs Saver smell a rat and en-mass (like Northern Rock) they all demand their money back at the same time only to discover there isn't enough to go round.No problem as the tax payer can again bail them out and the central bank can do some quantitative easing. I.E create some more fictitious money.

But also, houses are generally bought and sold out of need.

They are bought when you need another bedroom for the new baby or when you need a smaller house when the kids go to Uni.

They are sold when the owner needs to pay back the 100's of 1000's that he owes the bank and can no longer service the loan

Apart from the new boats bought with the fictitious release of equity none of these factors apply in the same way to a brokerage boat.

It probably wasn't bought out of need, more like desire.

It was probably paid for without a loan, so there is no banker chasing.

It definitely didn't go up in value so there is no excess to bid low against.

In fact it has slowly fallen in value.

Unless our owner is in serious trouble elsewhere he has no need to sell at 30% under. If you can't service your house mortgage you are in trouble but our cash strapped boaters main cost is his berthing.

Lets say it cost £6,000 a year and cash is getting a bit tight. Does he take a 30% (say £20,000 or £30,000) hit on his boat....or move to a swinging mooring for a £1000 for the next year.

Unless he owes money on the boat he's going on the mooring.

The thing to remember is that unlike houses most brokerage boats did not go up and are not subject to a loan. So that 30% off mentality you find in a house price crash simply does not exist.

The market tends to just go stagnant then drop a bit as buyer numbers diminish for a while.

You will find bargains due to personal circumstances, but not in the numbers you may imagine.

Greg I am honestly not bashing you here, just trying to show the differences.

If you want a bargain get serious with the broker because he is as keen as you are to do a deal, but it wont happen with ridiculous bids unless the seller has very pressing personal circumstances.

Another broker I know likens the housing market to steep peaks and deep valleys whereas the brokerage boat market is more like gentle undulating meadows.

Jonic,
Don't worry, not taken has having a bash at me :)

Interesting to hear your perspective actually and it is fair to say that the Broker (and seller) did make the (incorrect) assumption that I couldn't afford the boat and I think that influenced the tone of the response. To be fair further e-mails have been exchanged since then which have moved us into a different place but I still think that it would have been better all round if the offer was treated in a different (more constructive) way.

I get what you are saying about the housing market and the difference with boat brokerage but I also think that we are in very different times currently. Sure, we have had recessions in the relatively recent past but they haven't been on the same scale as this one with, for example, spiralling energy costs and the spectre of the Eurozone going down the pan. We have also reached a point where fuel is becoming a very real consideration in terms of mobo ownership with the outlook being for ever increasing prices. Take the two together and I would suggest that we are experiencing a little more than an 'undulating meadow' and like BlackMagic I want to protect the family finances as much as possible when buying our next boat.

All of this means, in very coarse terms (and I don't want to appear arrogant), that I am looking for a very good deal. Now the reality is that it is a buyers market, that the mobo market has probably been more badly affected than the sail market and that sellers face the prospect of sticking to their price and running the very real risk (IMHO) of being in exactly the same position in one, two or maybe even three years time. During this time inflation will have made the value of money a little lower, there will have been costs incurred in keeping the boat (accepting that cheaper options may be sought) and they will not have been able to move on with whatever they want to do instead.

Of course, many owners will want to hang on in the hope that someone comes along with what they consider to be the right money and I fully respect that and genuinely wish them luck, after all we have all been sellers and I understand their perspective. But, IMHO some are simply unrealistic about what they can achieve.

Time will tell whether or not my view is correct and I accept that I may end up with no motor boat but I am comfortable with that - after all we could go back to plan A, which was to buy a yacht!!! :)
 
All of this means, in very coarse terms (and I don't want to appear arrogant), that I am looking for a very good deal.
You would probably be better off looking at private sales on places like ebay, rather than wasting your time dealing with brokers who can't be arsed to put a deal together. Unless a seller is desperate to sell, they really aren't going to drop their asking price by a huge amount, so find a "motivated seller" advert somewhere and give them some motivation to sell. :D
 
You would probably be better off looking at private sales on places like ebay, rather than wasting your time dealing with brokers who can't be arsed to put a deal together. Unless a seller is desperate to sell, they really aren't going to drop their asking price by a huge amount, so find a "motivated seller" advert somewhere and give them some motivation to sell. :D

Might be something in this (looking for private sellers). Whilst I fully accept that I am no expert in terms of the brokerage business it has been interesting to hear the Broker talking in terms of what has been the norm when making offers and negotiating.....as if these are normal times!! It may, of course, simply be a tactic as he seeks to do his job and get the best possible deal for his client but it lacks realism for me.

Have to say though that I would think that the Broker has a real interest in a deal being struck because without one he doesn't get his commission.
 
Top