Dogs onboard

Joined
28 Jul 2020
Messages
30
Visit site
We used to sail with 3 dogs and lived aboard subsequently for 2 years on another boat with 2 of them. They just like being with you and adapt really quickly if introduced young. They used to get excited seeing the masts as we drove to the marine. I’ve had more problems caused by people than dogs in marinas…AAEAB667-E27B-4557-87C0-DD4BACEE473E.jpeg
 

dgadee

Well-known member
Joined
13 Oct 2010
Messages
3,976
Visit site
We used to sail with 3 dogs and lived aboard subsequently for 2 years on another boat with 2 of them. They just like being with you and adapt really quickly if introduced young. They used to get excited seeing the masts as we drove to the marine. I’ve had more problems caused by people than dogs in marinas…View attachment 152879

Problems caused by people complaining about your dogs?
 

AntarcticPilot

Well-known member
Joined
4 May 2007
Messages
10,576
Location
Cambridge, UK
www.cooperandyau.co.uk
We used to sail with 3 dogs and lived aboard subsequently for 2 years on another boat with 2 of them. They just like being with you and adapt really quickly if introduced young. They used to get excited seeing the masts as we drove to the marine. I’ve had more problems caused by people than dogs in marinas…View attachment 152879
Amen! For those who don't know dogs, many breeds, especially smaller ones, have been bred to be companions. Even those not specifically bred as companions see "their" humans as senior members of their pack; it's just stronger with companion breeds. A big part of their "psychology" is that they want to be with "their" humans, and life without their humans is diminished. I'm trying not to be too anthropomorphic; all that I say is really an analogy to describe what we observe. But the bottom line is that dogs want to be with "their" humans.

One of my dogs is half Shi-Tzu, an out and out companion breed. He goes absolutely bananas when I come back, even if I've only been away for ten minutes. He settles while I'm away, but my presence fills some sort of hole in his psyche. My other dog likes to be physically in contact with me, as well, but is less demonstrative!
 

mjcoon

Well-known member
Joined
18 Jun 2011
Messages
4,650
Location
Berkshire, UK
www.mjcoon.plus.com
Amen! For those who don't know dogs, many breeds, especially smaller ones, have been bred to be companions. Even those not specifically bred as companions see "their" humans as senior members of their pack; it's just stronger with companion breeds. A big part of their "psychology" is that they want to be with "their" humans, and life without their humans is diminished. I'm trying not to be too anthropomorphic; all that I say is really an analogy to describe what we observe. But the bottom line is that dogs want to be with "their" humans.

One of my dogs is half Shi-Tzu, an out and out companion breed. He goes absolutely bananas when I come back, even if I've only been away for ten minutes. He settles while I'm away, but my presence fills some sort of hole in his psyche. My other dog likes to be physically in contact with me, as well, but is less demonstrative!
Plus the infantilisation, in which puppies are not allowed to grow up and keep their dependency and lack of maturity.
 

dgadee

Well-known member
Joined
13 Oct 2010
Messages
3,976
Visit site
Amen! For those who don't know dogs, many breeds, especially smaller ones, have been bred to be companions. Even those not specifically bred as companions see "their" humans as senior members of their pack; it's just stronger with companion breeds. A big part of their "psychology" is that they want to be with "their" humans, and life without their humans is diminished. I'm trying not to be too anthropomorphic; all that I say is really an analogy to describe what we observe. But the bottom line is that dogs want to be with "their" humans.

One of my dogs is half Shi-Tzu, an out and out companion breed. He goes absolutely bananas when I come back, even if I've only been away for ten minutes. He settles while I'm away, but my presence fills some sort of hole in his psyche. My other dog likes to be physically in contact with me, as well, but is less demonstrative!

Surely they are group/social animals? Leaving them alone all day long - as many dog lovers do - doesn't fit with their psychology. They might prefer to run around in a pack (as they used to do when I was young) than be tied to one owner.
 

AntarcticPilot

Well-known member
Joined
4 May 2007
Messages
10,576
Location
Cambridge, UK
www.cooperandyau.co.uk
Plus the infantilisation, in which puppies are not allowed to grow up and keep their dependency and lack of maturity.
Dogs are, to some extent at least, neotenous wolves (they are a subspecies of Canis lupus ). Their fixation in puppy ways is something that was actively selected for during the process of domestication. So it's not a case of "not allowed to", it's a case of "their ancestors were selected for". In some breeds this has been taken further than in others.
 

Dellquay13

Well-known member
Joined
19 Feb 2021
Messages
992
Location
Boat at Milford Haven, Home in Chesterfield
Visit site
What's the concern about them pissing on the pontoon? Genuine question, and probably pertains to to the circumstances of some marinas; most of the ones I've seen seem to acquire guano regularly which then gets washed off by the rain & spray pretty quickly and is a lot more unpleasant on the nose and feet in the interim... the pontoons themselves seem pretty much impervious and the wee washes into the harbour/marina/bay along with the rest of the animal waste in the vicinity.
I get incensed when the dogs around the marina cock their leg over the shore power posts, and then I have to lift the mains socket cover to plug my lead in…
Bad enough when the dogs have been left to roam, worse when the owner has it it on a lead and doesn’t stop it
 
Last edited:

mjcoon

Well-known member
Joined
18 Jun 2011
Messages
4,650
Location
Berkshire, UK
www.mjcoon.plus.com
Dogs are, to some extent at least, neotenous wolves (they are a subspecies of Canis lupus ). Their fixation in puppy ways is something that was actively selected for during the process of domestication. So it's not a case of "not allowed to", it's a case of "their ancestors were selected for". In some breeds this has been taken further than in others.
I wonder if anyone has done the experiment. Just because something has been selected for does not mean that it becomes genetic. Admittedly, dogs' genomes are so flexible that they can be moulded into all sorts of ridiculous shapes, and kept there, by diligent breeding...
 

Stemar

Well-known member
Joined
12 Sep 2001
Messages
23,854
Location
Home - Southampton, Boat - Gosport
Visit site
I get incensed when the dogs around the marina cock their leg over the shore power posts, and then I have to lift the mains socket cover to plug my lead in…
Bad enough when the dogs have been left to roam, worse when the owner has it it on a lead and doesn’t stop it
It's a big dog that can reach the mains sockets I've seen.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2008
Messages
702
Location
Cornwall
Visit site
As opposed to our current boat that had more criteria to be dog friendly than it had to be human friendly!

If you have a dog as a pet, then it is part of your family, so you take it anywhere you would take the other (human) members of your family if you can, and you put up with the hassle of taking your dog in the same way as you would put up with the hassle of taking the other family members, because it's not hassle, it's just what you do for your family.
Dogs are not human albeit a part of your family . They have a place as do disruptive or a pain in the a55 family members ....... not on my boat, end of.
 

Koeketiene

Well-known member
Joined
24 Sep 2003
Messages
18,075
Location
Le Roussillon (South of France)
www.sailblogs.com
Dogs are not human albeit a part of your family . They have a place as do disruptive or a pain in the a55 family members ....... not on my boat, end of.

I must admit I'm somewhat surprised by the venim in this thread towards dog owners.

FWIW: I tend to steer clear of two kinds of people
1. People who don't like dogs
2. People my dogs don't like
Served me well so far, and I think I'm sticking with it.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2008
Messages
702
Location
Cornwall
Visit site
I must admit I'm somewhat surprised by the venim in this thread towards dog owners.

FWIW: I tend to steer clear of two kinds of people
1. People who don't like dogs
2. People my dogs don't like
Served me well so far, and I think I'm sticking with it.
I think you may find my post was addressing Dogs onboard not the owners.
What people or their dogs think of me is none of my business anyway.
 

SaltyC

Well-known member
Joined
15 Feb 2020
Messages
491
Location
Yorkshire
Visit site
I must admit I'm somewhat surprised by the venim in this thread towards dog owners.

FWIW: I tend to steer clear of two kinds of people
1. People who don't like dogs
2. People my dogs don't like
Served me well so far, and I think I'm sticking with it.

I like dogs, however I do not like owners who let dogs run free on pontoons and 'Do their Business' on the pontoons leaving for me to trail on board.

I personally would not want to be on a 32 foot boat with 3 dogs, but each to their own.

Unfortunately, once again, minority spoil it for the majority.
 

dgadee

Well-known member
Joined
13 Oct 2010
Messages
3,976
Visit site
I like dogs, however I do not like owners who let dogs run free on pontoons and 'Do their Business' on the pontoons leaving for me to trail on board.

I personally would not want to be on a 32 foot boat with 3 dogs, but each to their own.

Unfortunately, once again, minority spoil it for the majority.

Yep, dog owners take things so personally. But for me it is just about the fouling and the control.
 
Top