Clacton and Walton Lifeboats

nortada

Well-known member
Joined
24 May 2012
Messages
15,488
Location
Walton-on-the-Naze.
Visit site
Fancy putting off to the Outer Gabbard to pull a boat off in the gathering gloom and a rising wind in a rubber dinghy that is kept in a shed the size of an ISO container?

No? Nor me.
From experience trying to tow keel a boat with a dinghy is not easy. One solution is to moor the dinghy alongside and use it as the motive power whilst the casualty provides steerage but this is not practical with any sea running.

Back to the primary function of the RNLI; saving lives not boats, the crew would be taken off and the stricken vessel left to it’s own devices; possibly to be salvaged later. This then raises the question, “In rough conditions what is the maximum number of people that can be safely carried❓

I suppose the answer is in the name, Inshore. The Outer Gabbard is hardly inshore so the Clacton or Harwich boat would attend.
 
Last edited:

davidej

Well-known member
Joined
17 Nov 2004
Messages
6,676
Location
West Mersea. north Essex
Visit site
I’m a bit late to this and haven’t read all eight pages but…………

IMHO the decision by RNLI management makes sense but their handling of the volunteers is absolutely sh*t. - not for the first time!

Do they have an HR department? If so sack them.
 

Juan Twothree

Well-known member
Joined
24 Aug 2010
Messages
826
Visit site
I’m a bit late to this and haven’t read all eight pages but…………

IMHO the decision by RNLI management makes sense but their handling of the volunteers is absolutely sh*t. - not for the first time!

Do they have an HR department? If so sack them.

You only ever hear one side of the story.

The press always take the side of the volunteer, and makes out the institution to be at fault, as that's what makes a good story.

I have had a lot of dealings with the RNLI personnel department over many years, and although they're a bit slow to respond sometimes, they're not malicious or vindictive.

They don't stand crew down for no reason.
 

ylop

Well-known member
Joined
10 Oct 2016
Messages
2,737
Visit site
I’m a bit late to this and haven’t read all eight pages but…………

IMHO the decision by RNLI management makes sense but their handling of the volunteers is absolutely sh*t. - not for the first time!

Do they have an HR department? If so sack them.
Volunteers are a nightmare to manage in any organisation. Could they have done it better? Perhaps. But I’ve worked in similar scale “institutions” when a “unit” goes rogue (sometime that’s the reason for closure, sometime it’s the threat of closure that drives it) and the emotional energy invested in trying to resolve things amicably is rarely obvious to outside observers. Often the volunteers don’t realise that even if they have invested their entire life in an organisation they don’t own it.
 

nortada

Well-known member
Joined
24 May 2012
Messages
15,488
Location
Walton-on-the-Naze.
Visit site
I am told that the Walton boat has departed to the Solent for a refit; rumour has it never to return.

Does this mean that the Walton station is currently without lifeboat cover at this the beginning of the busy summer (silly) season?
 

nortada

Well-known member
Joined
24 May 2012
Messages
15,488
Location
Walton-on-the-Naze.
Visit site
Understand yesterday evening there was a meeting in Walton to discuss the lifeboat situation.

Unfortunately I was not able to attend so would appreciate comments from anyone who went along.
 

Andy61

Member
Joined
2 May 2012
Messages
125
Location
Frankby boat Walton-on-the Naze
Visit site
I was at the meeting. It was just to tell the story of what had happened. A big issue was that a local lady resident had provided the legacy for the lifeboat (a couple of million pounds) apparently on the condition that it was to be the Walton lifeboat. The fact that her wishes have not been respected has upset people. It was mentioned that other lifeboat stations have had similar events eg. New Brighton. Last weekend Trevor Halls (the last cox of Walton lifeboat and owner of Halls Boatyard) told me that there was no lifeboat coverage on the East Coast for the weekend.
 

Juan Twothree

Well-known member
Joined
24 Aug 2010
Messages
826
Visit site
I was at the meeting. It was just to tell the story of what had happened. A big issue was that a local lady resident had provided the legacy for the lifeboat (a couple of million pounds) apparently on the condition that it was to be the Walton lifeboat. The fact that her wishes have not been respected has upset people. It was mentioned that other lifeboat stations have had similar events eg. New Brighton. Last weekend Trevor Halls (the last cox of Walton lifeboat and owner of Halls Boatyard) told me that there was no lifeboat coverage on the East Coast for the weekend.

There would not have been "no lifeboat coverage on the East Coast for the weekend".

You occasionally get one or two boats off service with a mechanical issue or whatever, but not all of them. And if ever there's a situation where two flank stations are off service at the same time, they'll usually get a relief boat to cover at one of them.

Bringing up New Brighton was totally irrelevant, other than to say "look, here's another station that was in dispute with the RNLI, therefore the RNLI must be wrong".

The RNLI has a training system in place to ensure that the crews are all trained to a high standard, and that each crew member goes to sea on exercise a minimum of times a year to maintain currency in those skills.
Some of the crew at New Brighton decided that they didn't want to do that, so dug their heels in, and after many months of refusing to engage, were eventually stood down.

Nothing at all like the situation with Walton, where the mooring at the end of the pier had become unusable, therefore an alternative had to be found.

That alternative involved putting a brand new Shannon at Clacton, a few miles along the coast. Of course, if the legacy had originally been used to fund a Shannon rather than a Tamar then the Walton boat could just have been moved to Clacton, but unfortunately no one could foresee at the time that there would be issues with the pier.
And you can't launch a Tamar from a carriage.
 
Last edited:

ianc1200

Well-known member
Joined
6 Dec 2005
Messages
3,375
Location
Frinton on Sea
Visit site
Juan Twothree, you seem to defend the RNLI's actions re Walton - how do they justify not using the old lady's legacy as being for the Walton lifeboat?
 

Juan Twothree

Well-known member
Joined
24 Aug 2010
Messages
826
Visit site
Juan Twothree, you seem to defend the RNLI's actions re Walton - how do they justify not using the old lady's legacy as being for the Walton lifeboat?

Of course I would support the legacy being used for the Walton lifeboat.

But where do you suggest they put it?
 

Juan Twothree

Well-known member
Joined
24 Aug 2010
Messages
826
Visit site
At Titchmarsh. It was there a large % anyway. It would then be for filling her legacy.

Titchmarsh is totally impractical. It takes quite a while for the boat to reach the open sea, and even when it does, it's only two miles from Harwich Lifeboat station. So if time were of the essence, it would be far easier and quicker just to send Harwich.

So Walton Lifeboat would do hardly any calls, which is not only demotivating for the crew, but also a waste of money, given that an ALB needs at least one full time staff member to maintain it.
 

nortada

Well-known member
Joined
24 May 2012
Messages
15,488
Location
Walton-on-the-Naze.
Visit site
At Titchmarsh. It was there a large % anyway. It would then be for filling her legacy.
From local knowledge and observation, the Walton Lifeboat could operate at all states of the tide from Titchmarsh and the Twizzle and the reaction time for a 25kn+ vessel from Titchmarsh would be as good as from the end of the pier, with the need to transfer to the ‘big boat’ in often treacherous conditions.

But, Ian, I fear that horse has bolted. As you know the Walton boat has gone and the crew disbanded.

A done deal.

p.s. Out of interest, did the Walton boat have a paid full time ‘staff member’ or was it voluntarily supported by the local boatyards, both of whom would have been more than up to the task❓

Locally the issue is seldom discussed.
 
Last edited:

nortada

Well-known member
Joined
24 May 2012
Messages
15,488
Location
Walton-on-the-Naze.
Visit site
Titchmarsh is totally impractical. It takes quite a while for the boat to reach the open sea, and even when it does, it's only two miles from Harwich Lifeboat station. So if time were of the essence, it would be far easier and quicker just to send Harwich.

So Walton Lifeboat would do hardly any calls, which is not only demotivating for the crew, but also a waste of money, given that an ALB needs at least one full time staff member to maintain it.
Clearly your knowledge of Titchmarsh is inferior to mine.

Understandable, as I keep a power vessel with similar draft and performance to the Walton life boat at Walton and live at the Naze, a vantage point overlooking the whole Backwaters. I have ‘boated’ the area for the past 30 years.

To be pedantic; Stone Point (open sea from the Backwaters and about one mile from Titchmarsh) is a tad more than 2 miles from the Harwich lifeboat station but this is irrelevant.

The Walton situation was always two issues, one operational the other sentimental/emotional. The operational discussion has been done to death and I have commented previously (#48 onward) but the other issue was very poorly handled, with the detriment to all parties.

With your continued acute interest in Walton affairs, I look forward to your PM.
 
Last edited:

Mark-1

Well-known member
Joined
22 Sep 2008
Messages
4,500
Visit site
A big issue was that a local lady resident had provided the legacy for the lifeboat (a couple of million pounds) apparently on the condition that it was to be the Walton lifeboat. The fact that her wishes have not been respected has upset people.

What would you propose they do? There is no Walton Lifeboat Station any more so how can her wishes possibly be respected? Should they spend £5 million on reopening and running a Lifeboat station in perpetuity to claim the £2m? (£5 million is made up, but you get the point.)

The problem here seems to be a badly written will, not the RNLI.

Google tells me this:
If a condition precedent is not met then it will be seen to have failed, with the beneficiary receiving no benefit at all. The gift will then fall into the residue of the Will or pass under the rules of intestacy.

You'd hope that the Solicitor would have catered for this eventuality and added "or in the event of closure the next nearest station." but they obviously didn't.
 

nortada

Well-known member
Joined
24 May 2012
Messages
15,488
Location
Walton-on-the-Naze.
Visit site
What would you propose they do? There is no Walton Lifeboat Station any more so how can her wishes possibly be respected? Should they spend £5 million on reopening and running a Lifeboat station in perpetuity to claim the £2m? (£5 million is made up, but you get the point.)

The problem here seems to be a badly written will, not the RNLI.

Google tells me this:
If a condition precedent is not met then it will be seen to have failed, with the beneficiary receiving no benefit at all. The gift will then fall into the residue of the Will or pass under the rules of intestacy.

You'd hope that the Solicitor would have catered for this eventuality and added "or in the event of closure the next nearest station." but they obviously didn't.
I rather suspect this has nothing to do with ‘a badly written Will’.

I understand that once probate has been granted, it is not possible to have additional complementary bequests i.e. If this happens then a second set of bequests will come into play. I believe this can be called, wishes beyond the grave. In this situation as the Walton Station was active at the point of death then that set of bequests stand.

Rather this was a request possibly in the form of a codicil. Codicils are just requests from the deceased that carry no legal power.

No doubt someone with more knowledge than me will be along soon.

As you raise it, there is no need for a new station at Walton as the boat could operate from the Backwaters at minimal costs but from an operational perspective, Harwich can cover the Walton patch so this is all about hearts and minds and has been handled badly.👎🏻

Yet to get any response from Juan.
 
Last edited:
Top