Boat show review from Southampton - I enjoyed it!

henryf

Well-known member
Joined
31 May 2007
Messages
4,624
Location
Uxbridge
www.911virgin.com
Firstly congratulations. I've always seen Broom as a purveyor of pink carpets and dated interiors. I met with Tom from this forum whilst in Brixham recently and he mentioned the new 455. Wow, what a transformation. Gone are the garish colours, fabrics and rather home made interiors of old, replaced by bang up to date materials, contemporary design and a feeling that you couldn't create the space yourself. There's a bit of added magic in there which is just what you want.

Secondly some humble pie. I recently said on here that Fairline has always been a bugger of a company when it came to getting on boats. Well I managed to walk straight on unchallenged on 2 occasions without a problem. I felt as though they knew what I'd previously typed and had been instructed to allow me free passage! Yes, there is a glass fence meaning you have to enter via the central hub but I just walked straight in both Saturday and Sunday.

My target was the Squadron 50. I ended up speaking with James Barke a director of Essex Boatyards at length. Our paths have crossed on the phone in relation to a couple of Porsches & I like him as someone to deal with. We had an open discussion about the 50. Not one for us but I'm sure others will disagree and vote with their credit cards.

What put me off? Rear cleats that were hidden and hard to use, a folding cleat on the bathing platform which is a bit fiddly. I don't like the small seat in the cockpit which conceals the impossible crew cabin with it's sliding bed, lift out section to house you whilst you set the bed, hidden toilet and so on. James quite rightly pointed out that the smaller cockpit seat meant entry was possible from both sides when moored up and he is absolutely correct. It doesn't look right though, possibly this would change with the addition of some nice free standing furniture.*

I'm on the fence re: the rear galley but my biggest shock was the lack of a full width mid-ships owner's cabin. This has become a must have on all circa 50 foot flybridges. Indeed Fairline set the trend with their 48. James pointed out that the front cabin was most generous in proportion and he is correct, but it's in the front of the boat. I want the luxury of a mid cabin with large windows. The 2 double cabins made me think of a sports boat traditional layout rather than a second cabin you are proud to show friends when they come for the weekend.

Heading down from the saloon you are met with a blank wall and have to turn through 90 degrees. It's a bit gloomy.

On the flybridge I was left gobsmacked by the seating arrangements. A seat and a half forward facing helm position with a sun lounger to starboard. You have to lounge rather than sit! There is a window hidden under the cushion so no option to adjust things. James told me that was likely to change. Should it have been there in the first instance? I could just imaging being spread full length as a wave breaks over the bow and spray drowns the flybridge leaving you wallowing in water!

Then there was the coffee brown hull..... I suspect there will be some changes taking place to tweak the design. Oh, and I can't see what all this folding work top over the toilet is all about. Very odd ?

A final observation from Fairline make sure your staff know their onions. My favourite overheard moment from the show was when someone asked the girl if there was fender storage? There is plenty of storage in the boat she said whilst helpfully opening cupboards in the saloon :) Or am I just cruel to my fenders not keeping them cosy warm under the telly ;)

Sealine had the C48 on debut. The boat physically injured me. I can still feel it now. It's a very busy arrangement of floor and ceiling heights particularly in the galley area. I haven't a clue what's going on underneath that galley but you keep having to step up, step down, duck to get into bed and so on. The stairs from the saloon to the galley are lethal. I guarantee you someone will slip and break an arm, leg or pelvis. It's an open drop of some distance off to the left as you descend. They really must sort this out. It needs a rail and also a small lip to the side of the stair treads. Ignore that advice at your peril. I have first hand experience of how a shattered pelvis can ruin your life and those steps are broken bones in the making I guarantee you.

As you climb up the stairs back towards the saloon the top step has a higher rise and the angle between your toe pad and knee means your shin catches on the hard edge of the dining room floor. It bloody hurt as well. I left feeling very disappointed.

Now for my declaration of interests. I was at the show courtesy of Princess having purchased from them in 2007. They drove me from the Novatel where we were staying to the show in a combination of Mercedes van, Range Rover and Rolls Royce - both a Phantom and a Ghost :)*

We were asked if we could come back a little later when going to see the Sealine as a potential customer was on board. I so nearly said "do you know who I am" recollecting my descent from the Phantom moments earlier :)

Princess also kept us watered for 2 days threw in a couple of glasses of wine, some biscuits and the odd canapé. I want to get that out of the way because my review of their boats is favourable and I dont want you to later discover their hospitality and think it had anything to do with my kind words. I will be putting my money where my mouth is when the right deal comes along so it's not just a case of feeling I owe them something.

The new 60 flybridge is a masterpiece. It's too expensive for me so I can't have one but it felt like being on something 20 metres plus. Loads of space and beautifully executed. A fantastic crew cabin even had me doing the maths for some overnight charters!*

The P54 is equally lovely, not a new model but still fresh with a lovely feeling of space particularly as you descent to the cabins from the dining area. The P50 closer to my budget is a boat I have explored extensively in the past and defies logic in the way it fits everything in without feeling crammed. The steps down to the galley are the only place where you feel the designer was beginning to panic that they might not get everything in.The 50 was working for it's supper ferrying people around on the premier boat show experience so I only saw it from afar.

I didn't see anything at the show to touch Princess this year, not in my interest zone anyway to the point where we are cautiously exploring ways of getting into something which starts with a 5 !!!

Coming from the current P42, the small flybridge of choice for many everything in the Princess range is a natural progression and very familiar territory. Fit, finish and importantly detailed design were all very well sorted. A couple of little snags on new boats not yet fully PDI checked prior to delivery but that's it even after over a week of high traffic prodding and poking.

We spent some time aboard the relatively new V52. A more economic way into a large owner's cabin and an interesting concept with it's hard top and patio doors. We had 10 or 15 minutes alone in there just imagining it was ours and seeing what we thought. Roof open, roof closed, patio doors open and closed etc. For us the flybridge arrangement works best overhanging the cockpit to create a roof. An extremely easy cover arrangement to fully enclose the cockpit & in a couple of minutes you end up with an extended saloon. Princess do offer a retractable cover framework to enclose the V52 rear sun deck but the boat show example didn't have it fitted.*

We are not sports boat people. But that's just us. I have a friend who owns a sports boat and he would kill for a V52. I think it's the best boat in it's class, just not a class of boat that works for us.

We also spent time on the Princess 98 foot motor yacht which was stunning. To be fair I am no expert on vessels of this size so am probably a bit of a push over but enjoyed 15 minutes living the dream and feeling the warmth of the sun on deck :) If you have a spare £12-14 million the 40 metre yacht currently in production looks sublime, especially when you have the concepts explained to you. The closest I will ever get to owning one is the brochure but as something to dream about it hits all the branches of the tree.*

If the new owner of the Princess 98 Motor Yacht is reading this we will be in Thailand over Christmas so if you need any help or want to know how anything works feel free to invite us over from Krabi for a couple of days. We know where the Boat Lagoon is and can make our own way over ;)

The Navy presence was noticeable and a good practical exhibit for hundreds of visitors. We also saw the BananaShark racing */ E-Lites race boat owned by Cookee from this forum which brought back memories of the Cowes Torquay powerboat racing weekend.

I had a chat to the MBY team who sadly offered nothing by way of sustenance ;) We discussed the issues of electronic media and it would appear that for the moment at least a monopoly exists which will see prices kept relatively high and exclude a link in subscriptions between printed and electronic media.

I like Southampton for it's feeling of reality. When the wind picks up the boats get a bit of movement and you know you're afloat. You're looking out over familiar water and so the transition from display boat to you own property is an easy one to bridge. Yes, a can of pop and a sandwich costs more than it does in Tescos but to be fair if you put your mind to it you'd be able to cover several times the difference in complimentary drinks or nibbles, especially if you're genuinely there to spend a few quid.

For me it was an enjoyable couple of days made all the more enjoyable for having a base at Princess to return to. We didn't even get to have a small glass of something with the guys from our Marina at Haslar! Ah well, next year.......

Henry :)
 

aquapower

New member
Joined
22 Jul 2009
Messages
1,789
Visit site
Henry, an excellent summary of the show, thanks for taking the time to write, you picked the best days to visit, sorry I missed you saturday but being the warmest day also meant it was the busiest, but I was informed of your visit.

I was impressed to see the Princess driver letting some young children have their photo taken in the Rolls Royce.
 

jfm

Well-known member
Joined
16 May 2001
Messages
23,900
Location
Jersey/Antibes
Visit site
Thanks for the write up henry. I agree with you about broom: the 455 interior is suddenly very good indeed. Such a contrast from the pink carpets, which were of course specced by customers not broom, but Broom were stupid to let them be photographed for brochures etc when a couple of rolls of something nicer or a photoshop disc would have kept the pink a secret from the wider world. But anyway, yes that 455 is quite something. In a few years when they have modernised the exterior shapes they will be a serious contender and it would be great to see them succeed. Under the pink carpet, they have always been well-built boats made by a skilled team. I had the pleasure of visiting the factory a couple of times last year
 

OAF

New member
Joined
22 Apr 2009
Messages
613
Location
Shropshire/Southampton
Visit site
Then there was the coffee brown hull..... I suspect there will be some changes taking place to tweak the design. Oh, and I can't see what all this folding work top over the toilet is all about. Very odd ?

Sealine had the C48 on debut. The boat physically injured me. I can still feel it now. It's a very busy arrangement of floor and ceiling heights particularly in the galley area. I haven't a clue what's going on underneath that galley but you keep having to step up, step down, duck to get into bed and so on. The stairs from the saloon to the galley are lethal. I guarantee you someone will slip and break an arm, leg or pelvis. It's an open drop of some distance off to the left as you descend. They really must sort this out. It needs a rail and also a small lip to the side of the stair treads. Ignore that advice at your peril. I have first hand experience of how a shattered pelvis can ruin your life and those steps are broken bones in the making I guarantee you.

As you climb up the stairs back towards the saloon the top step has a higher rise and the angle between your toe pad and knee means your shin catches on the hard edge of the dining room floor. It bloody hurt as well. I left feeling very disappointed.

Now for my declaration of interests. I was at the show courtesy of Princess having purchased from them in 2007. They drove me from the Novatel where we were staying to the show in a combination of Mercedes van, Range Rover and Rolls Royce - both a Phantom and a Ghost :)*

We were asked if we could come back a little later when going to see the Sealine as a potential customer was on board. I so nearly said "do you know who I am" recollecting my descent from the Phantom moments earlier :)

Princess also kept us watered for 2 days threw in a couple of glasses of wine, some biscuits and the odd canapé. I want to get that out of the way because my review of their boats is favourable and I dont want you to later discover their hospitality and think it had anything to do with my kind words. I will be putting my money where my mouth is when the right deal comes along so it's not just a case of feeling I owe them something.

The new 60 flybridge is a masterpiece. It's too expensive for me so I can't have one but it felt like being on something 20 metres plus. Loads of space and beautifully executed. A fantastic crew cabin even had me doing the maths for some overnight charters!*

The P54 is equally lovely, not a new model but still fresh with a lovely feeling of space particularly as you descent to the cabins from the dining area. The P50 closer to my budget is a boat I have explored extensively in the past and defies logic in the way it fits everything in without feeling crammed. The steps down to the galley are the only place where you feel the designer was beginning to panic that they might not get everything in.The 50 was working for it's supper ferrying people around on the premier boat show experience so I only saw it from afar.

I didn't see anything at the show to touch Princess this year, not in my interest zone anyway to the point where we are cautiously exploring ways of getting into something which starts with a 5 !!!

Coming from the current P42, the small flybridge of choice for many everything in the Princess range is a natural progression and very familiar territory. Fit, finish and importantly detailed design were all very well sorted. A couple of little snags on new boats not yet fully PDI checked prior to delivery but that's it even after over a week of high traffic prodding and poking.

We spent some time aboard the relatively new V52. A more economic way into a large owner's cabin and an interesting concept with it's hard top and patio doors. We had 10 or 15 minutes alone in there just imagining it was ours and seeing what we thought. Roof open, roof closed, patio doors open and closed etc. For us the flybridge arrangement works best overhanging the cockpit to create a roof. An extremely easy cover arrangement to fully enclose the cockpit & in a couple of minutes you end up with an extended saloon. Princess do offer a retractable cover framework to enclose the V52 rear sun deck but the boat show example didn't have it fitted.*

We are not sports boat people. But that's just us. I have a friend who owns a sports boat and he would kill for a V52. I think it's the best boat in it's class, just not a class of boat that works for us.

We also spent time on the Princess 98 foot motor yacht which was stunning. To be fair I am no expert on vessels of this size so am probably a bit of a push over but enjoyed 15 minutes living the dream and feeling the warmth of the sun on deck :) If you have a spare £12-14 million the 40 metre yacht currently in production looks sublime, especially when you have the concepts explained to you. The closest I will ever get to owning one is the brochure but as something to dream about it hits all the branches of the tree.*

If the new owner of the Princess 98 Motor Yacht is reading this we will be in Thailand over Christmas so if you need any help or want to know how anything works feel free to invite us over from Krabi for a couple of days. We know where the Boat Lagoon is and can make our own way over ;)

The Navy presence was noticeable and a good practical exhibit for hundreds of visitors. We also saw the BananaShark racing */ E-Lites race boat owned by Cookee from this forum which brought back memories of the Cowes Torquay powerboat racing weekend.

I had a chat to the MBY team who sadly offered nothing by way of sustenance ;) We discussed the issues of electronic media and it would appear that for the moment at least a monopoly exists which will see prices kept relatively high and exclude a link in subscriptions between printed and electronic media.

I like Southampton for it's feeling of reality. When the wind picks up the boats get a bit of movement and you know you're afloat. You're looking out over familiar water and so the transition from display boat to you own property is an easy one to bridge. Yes, a can of pop and a sandwich costs more than it does in Tescos but to be fair if you put your mind to it you'd be able to cover several times the difference in complimentary drinks or nibbles, especially if you're genuinely there to spend a few quid.

For me it was an enjoyable couple of days made all the more enjoyable for having a base at Princess to return to. We didn't even get to have a small glass of something with the guys from our Marina at Haslar! Ah well, next year.......

Henry :)

Its a shame that you could not get on to the P50, we were there to look at it so we managed to get a tour in between the trips, I personally thought that it was the same as the 54 but obviously a bit smaller, the designer in my eyes has got it right on so many levels, providing you are not looking for something that stands out from the crowd in terms of radical styling, its a bit like a Porsche (of which I am not a fan) but their styling has not radically changed out of all recognition over the years but they can still look modern but in a classic way.

For me anyway the mid cabin P50 is right on the top of my shopping list, it wont be a new one at 800k and it wont be a 2 year old one (which they have on their books) at 500k, I will have to wait a little longer until I can afford one, but it certainly wont be a similar Fairline or a Sealine or a Sunseeker.

I wonder, how long will it be before the current FL,SL and SS models start to look dated with their almost radical styling, Its just my opinion of course!

The P98 was just lovely, when we were it was very blowy indeed, it made standing on the pontoons very difficult however the P98 didn't move at all, when standing at the helm the reason for this was pointed out to us, the hydraulic stabilisers were in operation, Wow what a craft! Ships like that are worlds apart from boats like ours! H you were lucky when you were on the sun deck, feeling the sun, when we were on the sun deck it p******d it down, everyone made a hasty decent back in side clutching the soft furnishings from up top lol.

Great show, I did feel that Princess had the largest presence there?
 

PowerYachtBlog

Well-known member
Joined
21 May 2007
Messages
4,269
Location
Malta - Med Sea
www.poweryachtblog.com
Have to disagree on some pointers.

Fairline 48 Phantom
The midship cabin of this, was one of the most critisized. Yes it is a just 14 meter plust vessel but that midship cabin always felt out of place. Indeed the 50 was still selling better then the 48 when these where togather in production. I remember a post how many here one from Deleted User kept saying how the 48 Phantom midship cabin was dreadful.

Princess 50 & 54
While both of these are nice yachts outside the galley remains the problem of these boats, as was on the just change by the 60, 58. I mean a galley in between the cabins in this size is a no no in my opinion, I could live with it on the 50, but on the 54 it just feels so wrong.

Fairline 50 Squadron.
I don't know how the forecabin on the Flines looks, as I never boarded one. But I went on the Rizzardi 63 HT in 2006, and the 55 Incredible hull one in 2009, and this worked very well. Fairline has since 2010 started using this layout with the 58 Targa GT and it also looks well. The astern galley by the patio door was started from Ferretti 630 and I liked the concept from the start. Copied first by Prestige and now by other builders from Australia too like Riviera and Maritimo, and the Ferretti owned Bertram.
What I don't like from the pictures shown of 50 Squadron is that it looks to be too much part and open with the saloon. The Ferretti concept makes it a bit seperate while at the same time part of the saloon. On the bigger models this can also be closed completly. But the pictures can be misleading and may be this is hull one and some changes are on the way.
 

henryf

Well-known member
Joined
31 May 2007
Messages
4,624
Location
Uxbridge
www.911virgin.com
Of course you know boat show is from Italian word............ The Italians were first to host boat show in 67AD ;)

We we loved the mid ship cabin on the 48 when it came out. I can still remember the show boat to this day. Light oak finish.

Galley down below works really well for us. I don't want it to get in the way of our living space and we don't cook much on the boat. We tend to eat out. Just breakfast and a snack from time to time. We sometimes cook when anchored in somewhere like Newtown Creek, (you know Italians first discovered Newtown Creek in 600 BC), but I don't want to keep looking at the kitchen whilst relaxing in the saloon which we do a lot.

The new 60 has it's galley mid-ship behind the helm position with a neat electrical screen which shields it from view if required. No boat can be all things to all people.

No problems Tom, you are there to do a job! I was really impressed with the design and execution of the 455. I can imagine that for a relatively small company it represented a lot of hard work but you got the sense that at no point had panic set in. The layout flowed well, there were no "botched" height changes or cover-ups. A few tweaks to external fixtures and fittings but a good bit of kit.

Re: the P50 I've seen it before on a number of occasions. I did wander down to the pontoon a couple of times to see if there was a chance to pop on for 4 minutes but it looked busy down there so I stayed away. There is always a chance to see one at Swanwick. I agree the 50 is ample in terms of layout. The 54 just feels a little bit more at ease in the saloon to kitchen transition and the 3rd cabin is side by side rather than bunks. There's no hurry but as and when Princess take one into stock rather than on brokerage who knows, we may treat ourselves :)

A little worried about moving up fro the P42 given we can slot it in anywhere. Even though the 50 is only 5ft longer and 1ft 5 inches wider is has a volume which means places may think it won't fit even if it would in reality. We also know the P42 and it does everything we want it to.

Henry :)
 

OAF

New member
Joined
22 Apr 2009
Messages
613
Location
Shropshire/Southampton
Visit site
Agreed H the 420 we have does everything we want and like you I too am wondering about getting in to places where the 42 will go but it aint that much bigger we are not talking about going to 60 or 70ft! Again I don't like the galley up in the saloon, much prefer it tucked out of the way, I could live with it between the two cabins on the p50.

If I were to think of all of the reasons not to upgrade then I wouldn't do it but ha ho you only live once so as soon as I can I probably will.
 

mjf

Active member
Joined
18 Jun 2003
Messages
3,994
Location
w.london - boat on solent- RIB on Tidal Thames
Visit site
Good post henryf.

I thought the discontinued fairline master with midships cabin and twartships bed was too tight and the SIBS boat at launch had doors that were far too narrow. I was disappointed - the flybridge was fab however.

The Sq50 did not float my boat this time either - the flybridge has no protection as the dodger is far too low IMHO it looks like the whole boat was designed by a team who have
completely the opposite view of how I like a boat to 'feel'. I'm not a galley aft fab either.

Bit like boarding a plane where the door is right where the toilets and galley are sited! why?


Princess have over the years offered me huge support and wonderful hospitality at their events - this year an already great show experience has been moved a great way forward. I too enjoyed the Phantom experience and as soon as we hit the stand we were promptly escorted to the 98 'before it gets too busy' for a look see.

Also went out with Powerskipper on the fairline 48 as charterered by Range Rover - that was a laugh!

I'm with henryf here as i like the P50 a lot as its just about Solent friendly on size and I do not need extra toilets and berths but like the galley down and space in the volume allows vs. the next size down P42
 

Nick_H

Active member
Joined
20 Apr 2004
Messages
7,662
www.ybw-boatsforsale.com
The new 60 flybridge is a masterpiece

Agreed. The crew cabin is so good (spacious, twin berths, steps access instead of ladder, and no need to move cushions), that you can class it as a 4 cabin boat, all en-suite, which is amazing at this size. The full beam master cabin is big and full height all over, 'cept for a tiny intrusion at the aft end, and despite the extra heads, there's no horrible circular sliding doors on any of the showers. The flybridge is streaks ahead of previous Princess efforts, i'd say best in class now because you get forward facing seats at the helm for at least four, big teak table to seat six comfortably, and big sunpad at the back where it should be. Throw in a hydraulic bathing platform, big comfy saloon, and nicely updated exterior which looks no higher despite the full beam cabin, and you have a real winner IMO.

We seriously considered buying one, we even went to the factory before the show to have a look at one in build, but decided to wait a bit. I think there are just a couple of downsides, it doesn't look as cutting edge inside as some of the competition, I think the new Sq58 feels much more contemporary (but worse in every other respect), and I also think the price is on the high side.
 

henryf

Well-known member
Joined
31 May 2007
Messages
4,624
Location
Uxbridge
www.911virgin.com
Price is relative and something you have to work on especially if you already have a boat that needs putting into the deal. As for the "not as cutting edge" comment, is that a bad thing?

Someone likened Princess to Porsche in their evolution rather than revolution approach and I agree. There are too many builders trying to re-invent themselves at the moment and almost changing designs for the sake of changing designs. That can't bode well for residual values if your 3 or 4 year old boat is totally different from the current model and so last Year's stock.

Cutting edge design does have a habit of dating quickly and unlike your living room a boat can't easily be re-decorated.

I suspect many of the styling elements of the 60 will start finding their way onto other boats, particularly the treatment of the flybridge wrap around at the stern. It looked great and felt very secure when on the flybridge it's self.

Maybe if they have a buy one get one free offer we should club together :)

Henry :)
 
Top