Black tank smell

sailaboutvic

sailaboutvic

Well-Known Member
Joined
26 Jan 2004
Messages
9,972
Location
Northern Europe
Visit site
We always had a smell coming from the vent holding tank vent.
What makes it worst the vent is high by the toe rail and near the cockpit .
We tryed changing the vent pipe but it made no different ,
We tryed cutting into the vent pipe and putting in a carbon filter , that only worked for a while .
I have opened the holding tank and it clean in side .
Need to sort the problem out has at time it embarrassing when we near other boats .
The problem happen when the two way valve is set to the holding tank , and it happen even when you only pump water .
Over to the panel , any suggestion ? Please
 
Last edited:
sailaboutvic said:
What do you do with it ? Drop it into the holding tank of flush it down the toilet?
Click to expand...

It tells you how to eliminate head smells by who is considered the world expert of boat heads.

The smells in a holding tank is generally due to reduced oxygen flow and one way is to make the vent pipe as large as possible.
 
oldvarnish said:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/books/dp/18...557082&sr=8-1&keywords=get+rid+of+boat+odours
Click to expand...

OldVarnish is right, all the answers are in the book but it may be heavy weather finding the information you require.

Put simply the smell is from anaerobic bacteria, aerobic bacteria don’t smell. The answer is in more and better ventilation of the tank.
1. Remove the carbon and anything else that restricts free flow of air.
2. Make sure there are the minimum of bends in the vent pipe with absolutely NO sharp bends.
3. Make sure that no water can get trapped in the vent pipe.
4. Use the largest diameter and shortest vent pipe as possible.
5. If all this fails then add a second vent pipe preferably from the other side of the boat.
6. Finally after emptying the toilet always continue to pump for a while so that air is pumped into the tank.

I am sure you can completely cure the problem. Good luck, George
 
GeorgeLlewellin said:
4. Use the largest diameter and shortest vent pipe as possible.
Click to expand...

I was going to say that our vent is well below the holding tank and just above the water line and we don't get any smells. Perhaps the gas is heavier than air?

However, this contradicts the advice above although our vent pipe is quite large diameter - I'm guessing around 30mm - so perhaps a low vent and a big, if longish, pipe works?

Richard
 
GeorgeLlewellin said:
OldVarnish is right, all the answers are in the book but it may be heavy weather finding the information you require.

Put simply the smell is from anaerobic bacteria, aerobic bacteria don’t smell. The answer is in more and better ventilation of the tank.
1. Remove the carbon and anything else that restricts free flow of air.( it was removed about a year ago as it didn't real work )
2. Make sure there are the minimum of bends in the vent pipe with absolutely NO sharp bends. ( pipe goes amost up I to an goose neck then out )
3. Make sure that no water can get trapped in the vent pipe. ( don't think that's possable has it comes out the top of the tank )
4. Use the largest diameter and shortest vent pipe as possible. ( this I will have to try only thing is the exit from the tank can't be change with lots of welding and cutting )
5. If all this fails then add a second vent pipe preferably from the other side of the boat. ( another possibility )
6. Finally after emptying the toilet always continue to pump for a while so that air is pumped into the tank. ( we alway do this )

I am sure you can completely cure the problem. Good luck, George
Click to expand...

See above
Some good suggestion , thanks
 
Last edited:
I away like to report back after asking a question then finding what the problem was , so here what I found .
By removing the hull discharge cap , the problem has just disappear , so the suggestion from George of a ventilation problem seen to be the problem after all .
 
sailaboutvic said:
I away like to report back after asking a question then finding what the problem was , so here what I found .
By removing the hull discharge cap , the problem has just disappear , so the suggestion from George of a ventilation problem seen to be the problem after all .
Click to expand...
OK if it works, but I don't see how it does unless the tank is empty as the pump out connection has a dip pipe to the bottom of the tank.
 
johnphilip said:
OK if it works, but I don't see how it does unless the tank is empty as the pump out connection has a dip pipe to the bottom of the tank.
Click to expand...

I can only tell you what I have found , tank partly full or empty , the smell that happens every time the two way valve was turned to holding tank no matter how empty or full the tank was has gone , so for now we leave the cap off . Just for you john if it returned I shall let you know .
 
The solution is lots of fresh air, then even more fresh air, and finally lots more fresh air.

Apparently their are two types of bacteria that feed on human waste, one is aerobic and makes no smell, the other is anaerobic and makes the stinks. So more air encourages the aerobic (good) bacteria and destroys the bad (anaerobic) bacteria.

When our tank is not actually in use (so in marinas and when it's empty and we're sailing for example) we remove the pump out filler cap to allow even more air into the tank.
 
johnphilip said:
OK if it works, but I don't see how it does unless the tank is empty as the pump out connection has a dip pipe to the bottom of the tank.
Click to expand...
Simple really, boats usually move while afloat, even in a marina. This is a good thing as far as the black water is concerned, it help to aerate it. Also consider when the deck cap in on the water level in the outlet pipe to the deck discharge is static, the level does not change as the boat rocks. However when the top is off the water level changes, therefore when the water level in this pipe raises some air goes out of the pipe, it follows that some air must be sucked back into the tank, through the vent, to compensate. Bingo, you have achieved are circulation.
George.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Other threads that may be of interest

S
Replace Vetus black water tank fitting
Replies
4
Views
106
PCUK
P
webcraft
Beta 16 pressure in fuel tank
Replies
6
Views
219
RunAgroundHard
RunAgroundHard

Share this page

Top