1/2/Both switch bust?

R

richardabeattie

Well-Known Member
Joined
9 Jan 2004
Messages
1,386
Location
Wiltshire
Visit site
Please don't shoot me for having a 1/2/B.

This morning I brought just one battery to the boat to start the engine to move out to my berth. I put it into one of the two battery spaces. The cables to the empty space were left disconnected. All went well and everything worked - but it all continued to work irrespective of whether the switch was turned to 1 or 2 or both. Surely either position 1 or 2 should have switched everything off?
 
richardabeattie said:
Please don't shoot me for having a 1/2/B.

This morning I brought just one battery to the boat to start the engine to move out to my berth. I put it into one of the two battery spaces. The cables to the empty space were left disconnected. All went well and everything worked - but it all continued to work irrespective of whether the switch was turned to 1 or 2 or both. Surely either position 1 or 2 should have switched everything off?
Click to expand...

Depends how it's wired. Conventionally you are right, but I have heard of people using the 1-2-B just to distribute the charge.
 
richardabeattie said:
Please don't shoot me for having a 1/2/B.

This morning I brought just one battery to the boat to start the engine to move out to my berth. I put it into one of the two battery spaces. The cables to the empty space were left disconnected. All went well and everything worked - but it all continued to work irrespective of whether the switch was turned to 1 or 2 or both. Surely either position 1 or 2 should have switched everything off?
Click to expand...

If it is supposed to select either, or both, of two batteries then something is wrong. Did it switch every thing off if turned to the off position ?

I dont suppose you know what would have happened if you'd put the battery in the other position
 
Last edited:
pvb said:
What a brilliant opportunity to sort out the wiring and get rid of the 1-2-Both switch!
Click to expand...

Perhaps an idea worth considering if the OP is considering significant modifications to the electrics otherwise just replacing the switch, if it is indeed defective, is all that is required. No need to fix what's not broken

Many people happily use a 1,2 both switch and do not share your bias against them.
 
VicS said:
Many people happily use a 1,2 both switch and do not share your bias against them.
Click to expand...

"Bias" is a rather harsh word, isn't it? It has implications of unfairness, which isn't justified. 1-2-Both switches are old technology, a cheap solution which has lots of potential for mistakes, possibly leading to inability to start the engine. There are much better ways of switching batteries, which is why today's boat manufacturers generally avoid 1-2-Both switches.
 
richardabeattie said:
Yes - switching to off turned everything off. I think I can live with it as it is.
Click to expand...

No, you need to investigate the wiring. Your original post suggested that the switch isn't isolating the batteries correctly. You run the risk of ending up with a flat starter battery and a visit from the RAC.
 
pvb said:
Perhaps you're still trimming wicks on paraffin lamps?
Click to expand...

That's why we have electric lights........ so we can see to do it properly. I expect JD uses a candle though.

The next thing you'll be suggesting is LEDs instead of tried and tested incandescent filament bulbs.
 
Last edited:
richardabeattie said:
This morning I brought just one battery to the boat to start the engine to move out to my berth. I put it into one of the two battery spaces. The cables to the empty space were left disconnected. All went well and everything worked - but it all continued to work irrespective of whether the switch was turned to 1 or 2 or both. Surely either position 1 or 2 should have switched everything off?
Click to expand...
Sounds very odd, if the battery was in position 1 then everything should have worked with the switch in position 1 and vice versa.

Clearly a multimeter is needed to check stuff.

Personally, I am a huge fan of 1-both-2-off switches as they are simple, flexible and pretty bomb proof; it is the people who use them that are usually the problem.
 
Last edited:
VicS said:
The next thing you'll be suggesting is LEDs instead of tried and tested incandescent filament bulbs.
Click to expand...

Every light source on my boat is LED except the compass light (haven't found an LED one), the chart light (ditto) and the fluorescent tube over the galley (my fitting held the Boatlamps LED "tube" at a silly angle to I had to return it.
 
If you have two matching batteries, a very simple setup and don't mind messing around trying to remember which battery you should be charging, then 1-2-B switches work OK.

I have a single battery for starting my engine and 3 x 130ah batteries for domestics. Why would i want to select the single engine battery and run the whole boat from that ? I'm not alone, a great many cruising boats now have a lot of electrics, which require several batteries, the engine still only needs a single battery. Wiring such boats to a 1-2-B switch would be madness.
 
JumbleDuck said:
Every light source on my boat is LED except the compass light (haven't found an LED one), the chart light (ditto) and the fluorescent tube over the galley (my fitting held the Boatlamps LED "tube" at a silly angle to I had to return it.
Click to expand...

My compass now has red "grain of rice" LEDs in it :encouragement:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Other threads that may be of interest

Baggywrinkle
Test run of the Lithium system that has been sitting in my cellar for most of this year.
Replies
14
Views
524
Baggywrinkle
Baggywrinkle

Share this page

Top