Mmn, I dont think that you can rush an answer to a question like that.
In order to properley evaluate the pluses and minuses of each establishment, one would have to visit for a period of at least a week in order to make a full and meaningful assessment.
I could be prepared to undertake such in-depth analysis providing the owners are prepared to waive their rental fees (in the name of research) and the forum would fund my reasonable travel and out of pocket expenses /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
Try www.destination-cornwall.co.uk and click on Accommodation - you won't be disappointed. Bet none of those other places serve pasties or a dish o' tae like we do.
Never one to miss an opportunity we can do you B&B at www.seraph-apartments.com ; and we might throw in a days' Med sailing /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif