Weather Protection

In support of the Pilothouse!

Hi All

I'm very interested in starting sailing. One thing puzzles me however. Sailing yachts, even larger ones have no way of steering them from inside. So, whatever the weather, it seems the helmsman must sit outside in the wind and spray at all times.
In any other mode of transport you can sit inside out of the weather.
You wouldn't drive around in an open car in the rain would you!
Aircraft originally had open cockpits, but they reverted to enclosed some time in the 1930's I think.
Is it because yachting clothing manufacturers want to make a lot of money selling protective gear?

As an Evasion owner, I can vouch for the flexibility that the Pilothouse arrangement offers. As mentioned earlier, the inside steering postion is not used that often, but when I do use it, it is for good weather-related reasons. If I don't have full wet-weather gear on, being able to nip below whilst a shower passes is great. Also, if sailing with crew and it is wet, everyone can go into the warmth inside, without leaving the poor helmsman on his(her) own outside.

I've often sailed her from inside as well and can see all the sails through the Evasion's sunroof, including the wind indicator. I might not get the optimum sail adjustment, though, because I would slightly over-sheet the sails meaning that small wind direction changes don't leave the sails flogging. All sail adjustments are immediately outside the cabin door, so adjustment is actually no problem.

Combine a pilothouse with a warm-air heating system and you've got a lovely balance between helming outside as normal against keeping warm and dry if required. The main cabin table also allows charts to be viewed from the helm which is good.

My evasion was also used a race committee boat on one particularly foul evening - it beat the pant off other boats because all the race paperwork, binoculars, race information etc. etc. could all be laid out in the warm and dry whilst watching the race progress from inside...lovely!
 
Enclosed sailing etc.

Good to see so many have replied to my thread. Thanks all.

Two points occur to me from the replies.
Firstly, it seems I'm probably thinking on the wrong lines when I consider sailing to be a form of transport.
It's not really, its not just a question of going from A to B. It is a sport and challenge.
As mentioned in the point about the difference between dinghies and yachts, the more easier it is the less interesting it becomes.
That's why things like kitesurfing and windsurfing are popular, neither are easy to do, that's why people like to try.
To go from A to B without hassle I guess the answer is a motorboat.
Another point that emerged is that fact that sails need to be adjusted all the time and that is not very easy if you're in a cabin away from the action.
 
My boat has the option of internal steering but it is seldom used. In Scotland ,if it rains it is usually cold so you have your full kit on. In the Med. it is usually warm if it rains (at least in Summer) and it doesn't matter.
The interior steering position is used in thunderstorms and sometimes for tricky navigation to be right beside the chartplotter pilots and charts. The main advantage of the deck saloon/pilot house is the great outlook andgood light without the "submarine effect" when you go below in many yachts.

"In Scotland ,if it rains"

Your having a laugh surely!
 
Firstly, it seems I'm probably thinking on the wrong lines when I consider sailing to be a form of transport.

That's the key to it. If you want practical transport at sea you want a commercial motor craft, not a yacht.

I was talking about some aspect or other of square rig sailing once, and how this was detrimental to the pure efficiency of the rig. My friend was trying to propose ways this could be fixed, all of which would result in a vessel no longer traditionally square-rigged. He didn't understand my point of view until I said "mate, if I was just trying to get from Tenerife to Gibraltar as quickly as possible, I'd get on a plane".

Pete
 
Top