The keelboat: evolution or disaster, for my dinghy-cruising ambitions?

keep looking

Keep looking it took us 2.5 years to find the boat we wanted.. Although do not knock off the dragon. Look at the last boat on this list looks like a plastic one too...

Do not knock keels for good sailing maybe you should consider the old 1/4 tonners if you are thinking of sporting sailing on a mooring... Great sailing on a budjet..

you will find the right boat eventually

but I think the nimrod is perfect

a clapped out one will soon turn up

Dylan
 
Thanks to Onesea, I do love Dragons, but the budget for even a tired old one is at least treble what I'm expecting to spend...

...I reckon Dylan is right, the Nimrod, assuming I find a clean one when I can afford one, is the answer to my endless questions.

Although, to keep the part of me that wanted a Contender (or other speedster) happy, I may then start windsurfing...

windsurfing2.jpg


...perfect...small enough to tow or stow on the Westerly, and so practical! And I can paint "Tender to Nimrod" on the board. :rolleyes:
 
buy a tatty one - who cares?

Thanks to Onesea, I do love Dragons, but the budget for even a tired old one is at least treble what I'm expecting to spend...

...I reckon Dylan is right, the Nimrod, assuming I find a clean one when I can afford one, is the answer to my endless questions.

Although, to keep the part of me that wanted a Contender (or other speedster) happy, I may then start windsurfing...

windsurfing2.jpg


...perfect...small enough to tow or stow on the Westerly, and so practical! And I can paint "Tender to Nimrod" on the board. :rolleyes:

buy a tatty one

better to be sailing the boat you can afford now than dreaming about the one you think you need

boats and outboards

http://www.boatsandoutboards.co.uk/trailer-sailers/sailfish-18-PAA61474

http://www.boatsandoutboards.co.uk/trailer-sailers/sailfish-18-trailer-sailer-PAA58826



Dylan
 
You're quite right of course...and I'd really enjoy making minor repairs and modifications even before I can launch her.

I'd forgotten the Sailfish - thanks for the links. :)
 
How d'you know pensioner-status isn't already the reason I'm financially restricted in my choice of craft? :rolleyes:

I admit, I'm not particularly firm on what I want most of all from a boat. And differing characteristics each appeal a great deal, when described by contributors who are acutely alive to their own boat's benefits. I'm very glad if you enjoy the enduring topic.

I'd like a quicker dinghy than I could probably handle, most of the time...meanwhile I'd like a ballasted keel for offshore security...I'd like a centreboarder for creek-crawling, I'd like a cabin to obviate using a boom-tent, and I'd like it in GRP to reduce maintenance.

Oh, and I'll need to find it for pennies, otherwise you gents'll have to listen to my dreaming until I can make the cash!

Actually I think the Westerly Nimrod is high up there amongst the front-runners...except it's at least double my ££££.

I'll stop moaning on speculatively, once I have the cash. I'll acquire the boat - yet unknown - and my output on here will switch instantly to "can I tow a launching trolley with a bicycle?", or "can I turn the prop using compressed carbon dioxide?" or such other nonsense.

I do like the Nimrod. Looks like a dinghy with a lid, rather than a heavy, slow, complex yacht-in-miniature. It'd be nice to get a boat from a trusted manufacturer, too.

Cheers. ;)

OK you have my sympathies. Remember you can't take it with you and living is about pleasure in this lifetime but heck who am I to talk - I enjoy 2 boats but am still working years after retirement age to pay for them!!
 
OK you have my sympathies. Remember you can't take it with you and living is about pleasure in this lifetime but heck who am I to talk - I enjoy 2 boats but am still working years after retirement age to pay for them!!

My respects to you. In truth, I haven't quite reached your seniority, but then I haven't got your boats or the fulfilment you enjoy from them, either. This next spring, I'll get afloat. Cheers.
 
Can you please3 restate your mission statement so we can all be on the same page.I have cruised dinghies 15 foot cruisers with bilge keels,large schooners and small sloops,yours as ever.
 
Can you please restate your mission statement so we can all be on the same page?

Do you have all night? :rolleyes:

Truth is, I vacillate. Or rather, I require more of any one design than can easily be comprised. That said, this thread has largely reminded me that I'm too fond of variable-draft flexibility to switch to a fixed deep keel in a single bound. And, the smallest centreboard cruisers have much of the appeal of cruising dinghies, which I'm familiar with...

...although, they're usually a bit slow and thrice the price of similarly proportioned fast dinghies...so, maybe a nice scruffy old Osprey instead, as a project to have ready for summer?...and, back I go, seeking impractical performance over ever-useable proven fun...

...as the wise gents here have said, I just need to buy something and sail it for a while, to know the answers to all my own questions...but I'm keen to make a sound choice, first time out.
 
buy a tatty one

better to be sailing the boat you can afford now than dreaming about the one you think you need
Now there is a truthful statement...

Dan in the meantime if you are down our way and want to try a 2m draft that is not so slow of the mark PM me.

That sail fish does look tempting...
 
Do you have all night? :rolleyes:

Truth is, I vacillate. Or rather, I require more of any one design than can easily be comprised. That said, this thread has largely reminded me that I'm too fond of variable-draft flexibility to switch to a fixed deep keel in a single bound. And, the smallest centreboard cruisers have much of the appeal of cruising dinghies, which I'm familiar with...

...although, they're usually a bit slow and thrice the price of similarly proportioned fast dinghies...so, maybe a nice scruffy old Osprey instead, as a project to have ready for summer?...and, back I go, seeking impractical performance over ever-useable proven fun...

...as the wise gents here have said, I just need to buy something and sail it for a while, to know the answers to all my own questions...but I'm keen to make a sound choice, first time out.

Just don't stress over it. If it's not what you actually wanted, just sell it & buy something else. Chances are you will get most of your money back within a year or two if you decide to move on. Follow lakey's example until you settle on what you actually want.

Each boat will teach you something that will ultimately help you get the best out of your sailing experience.
 

Other threads that may be of interest

Top