Praise for Crinan Canal

R

richardjacobs

New Member
Joined
5 Jun 2015
Messages
17
Visit site
There seem to be a lot of complaints about the Crinan Canal here. I'm sure the problems are real, but it's also worth remembering that people are more likely to post problems than praise. We went through from East to West 2 weeks ago and it couldn't have been easier, or the staff more helpful.
We didn't book. We phoned Ardrishaig, when an hour way at 11am. We were able to go straight into the sea lock. One boat joined us, but stopped in the basin. With just 2 of us on board, the staff helped us through the first group of locks. We overnighted above Cairnbaan, which was idyllic. Then worked our way down the other side. We stopped for lunch below lock 10 and were then asked to wait for 2 boats coming down behind us, which was fine. We chose to stop in the Crinan Basin to enjoy the Seafood bar at the hotel, then took the first sea lock out to catch the tide North.
We had started to think we should skip the canal, but are very glad that we didn't. We look forward to going back that way.
 
We had pretty much the same experience 4 weeks ago.
The staff couldn't have been more helpful.
Sure, some of the lock gates are in need of serious work but we got through without any issues.

We overnighted at Cairnbaan and were asked to wait 30 minutes for a boat coming up behind us.
As well as saving some water it made the locks much easier having the extra muscle.

The fish and chips at the Crinan Hotel are fabulous!
 
These stories are charming, but I note that both of you were happy - and why not? - to take two days to make a trip which twenty years ago would only have taken five hours if you decided to dawdle.

Dawdling can be great fun, of course, but the delays and unpredictability are less fun when you just want to get from A to B efficiently.
 
Not sure I'd equate a stop at Cairnbaan to look at the Cut Stones and enjoy a meal at the Cairnbaan Hotel with "dawdling".
Incidentally the yacht we were asked to wait for on day 2 transited in less than 6 hours. The only problem they reported was with the sea lock at Ardrishaig. They entered at LWS and the gates took a few minutes to seal shut.

It's 25 years since our last Crinan Canal experience and I'll admit I was nearly put off by all the doom-laden posts here. All I can say is our transit was fine. We didn't have to wait for any locks. There was enough water for our 1.7m draught. The staff couldn't have been more helpful. The other half a dozen boats we spoke to were equally positive.
 
I love the Crinan Canal and have never had any problems. But then I think the transit is an experience to savour and not to rush.
Now that I have sailed back South I will miss the Crinan Canal.
 
Mud Lark said:
Not sure I'd equate a stop at Cairnbaan to look at the Cut Stones and enjoy a meal at the Cairnbaan Hotel with "dawdling".
Click to expand...

I am not for one instant criticizing your choices - each to his or her own - but stopping for lunch at Cairnbaan and then overnighting in the summit reach is textbook dawdling. I expect the canal is still a nice experience for those with plenty of time or experiencing it for the first time, but after a while the problems grate. This week was my young crew's fourteenth transit. Nice as the canal is, we really didn't want to take a day and a half to get through.

mainsail1 said:
I love the Crinan Canal and have never had any problems. But then I think the transit is an experience to savour and not to rush.
Now that I have sailed back South I will miss the Crinan Canal.
Click to expand...

I miss the old canal. Not just the well maintained equipment, but also the camaraderie and efficient passages you got when most other boats were regulars. It's not just the operator's fault that things have gone downhill. With bigger boats capable of rounding the mull in more conditions and marinas in the west, the old demand is never coming back, and modern wide boats often can't fit in side by side, reducing capacity and available crew.

No easy solutions. A morning convoy for those who just want to get through quickly sounds like a good idea, but they just aren't backing up the promise with staff.
 
JumbleDuck said:
..... With bigger boats capable of rounding the mull in more conditions and marinas in the west,.....
Click to expand...

An interesting point and one which may actually drive up demand for marina berths on the west coast, even if only slightly. I came round the MOK last week to the FOC and when I left Gigha, there were 6 boats behind me, around the 30-40' range, older models, not that proves anything.

The holes are worrying as that suggests serious structural, foundation issues.
 
There have been structural issues for decades. What struck me this year compared to 25 years ago was the condition of some of the lock gates. Whilst this lack of maintenance is obviously a concern, it didn't delay my transit or that of any of the other vessels over the 2 days we were there. We could easily have transited in one day if we had wanted to.
 
You miss the point, no (zero) maintenance has been carried out for at least five years, despite the canal only transiting perhaps a total of four boats between November and March. It is not that the lock/bridgekeepers do not help, there are now as few as 7 to man the two sea locks and 6 bridges and the situation in the office is worse with only four or five in Ardrishaig and a similar number in Glasgow to support them. (Irony emoji?)
For example, lock 3 which is at the bottom of our garden has massive leaks around the top gates and only one working sluice on the bottom pair to drain it. This situation delayed JD for an hour; over the last two days while I have been cutting my grass and hedges I have had to go down half a dozen times to assist folk struggling futilely to try to open it, it takes three strong males to shift one gate to release the pressure from the through flow. My wife has been going down to help push even more often. Otherwise they have to phone and wait until the sea lock keeper can get away to come and help them. A situation like this would not have been tolerated in the past, it used to be that a couple of yachts each with one woman or child ashore could transit without injury.
I have an axe to grind here, I stopped the car one day to help a lady struggling at lock 6 , bit too macho, crushed and split the cartilage in my left knee and had to suffer pain and limited mobility for almost a year while they put a steel joint in. I know of one lady sailor who is incapacitated by a permanent back injury sustained in a similar way, that lock is still as bad today.
 
When lock 11 is full the water is pissing out of the downstream stone work and this is not the only one whre the grouting has clearly gone,the water is flowing freely behind the wall to create these cavities, a collapse can not be far off, hope it is not your boat that the wall falls on.
 
Not sure what, I am on the Canal almost every day and not seen it, though they did hammer half a sheet of plywood over a big leak in 10 last year. Just spoke to one of the keepers, he confirms that maintenance has ceased though they still have a priority list. The expectation of a major failure is pretty general among the staff though there are different opinions about where. Lock 11, Lock 4 and the Ardrishaig sea lock are the shortest odds.
 
Quandary said:
Not sure what, I am on the Canal almost every day and not seen it, though they did hammer half a sheet of plywood over a big leak in 10 last year. Just spoke to one of the keepers, he confirms that maintenance has ceased though they still have a priority list. The expectation of a major failure is pretty general among the staff though there are different opinions about where. Lock 11, Lock 4 and the Ardrishaig sea lock are the shortest odds.
Click to expand...

When the Ardrishaig sea lock gate fails it will only need a new one, and expect that CaRT will be able to supply quite fast, at a cost. When Lock 11 collapses there will be months of work. Storm Frank flooding took down 4m of a 2m high river wall in my garden and just that little bit had contractors in for two months at a cost to my insurers of £50k. And that was easy, because SEPA agreed that it was repairs to an existing wall and no work in a watercourse was needed ...if a new Lock 11 costs less than a million I'll eat my hat.
 
JumbleDuck said:
When the Ardrishaig sea lock gate fails it will only need a new one, and expect that CaRT will be able to supply quite fast, at a cost. When Lock 11 collapses there will be months of work. Storm Frank flooding took down 4m of a 2m high river wall in my garden and just that little bit had contractors in for two months at a cost to my insurers of £50k. And that was easy, because SEPA agreed that it was repairs to an existing wall and no work in a watercourse was needed ...if a new Lock 11 costs less than a million I'll eat my hat.
Click to expand...

Depends a bit on what is happening, if it goes overnight, (not likely as the locks are empty ) okay, but if there is a fatality it will take months of recrimination before they do anything. Just worked out that my house is just above the level of the reach above 4 but the discharge will probably wash away the driveway.
 
mainsail1 said:
Why not write to your Scottish MP and complain?
No use someone from England like me taking the matter up.
Click to expand...

This thread has encouraged me to think I should but Scottish Canals already know me as a trouble maker when I used to campaign through the Community Council and since they are my neigbour on all four sides and I keep my boat in their canal, I already find them hard to deal with. The Scottish Canals are devolved which means that it would be my MSP, you will not have heard of Michael Russell but he appears to be a bit lacking in the dynamism department. A letter cataloguing the defects and risks if copied to Scottish Canals might encourage the management to think they might be vulnerable when an event occurs but living where I do I am loathe to risk it, some of them can be quite vindictive, I might try to find someone else a bit more detached and willing to front up.
 
Quandary said:
Depends a bit on what is happening, if it goes overnight, (not likely as the locks are empty ) okay, but if there is a fatality it will take months of recrimination before they do anything. Just worked out that my house is just above the level of the reach above 4 but the discharge will probably wash away the driveway.
Click to expand...

It's actually most likely to go when the lock is empty, because that's when the pressure difference across the wall (water behind it, air in front of it) is highest. For similar reasons my local swimming pool can't be drained, because it they try the tiles start popping off. Of course when it does go all the other locks will need checked ...
 
Once infrastructure has been allow to decay it is almost impossible for the dilapidated result to earn enough for its refurbishment. Maybe, at this stage, even a refurbished Crinan Canal couldn't earn enough to pay for its upkeep. Criticism of those trying to make it work won't help. Fixing it is going to cost money - yours as a user or someone else's. I (perhaps unusually) am in favour of government setting taxes high enough to fix infrastructure. If they did you'd still have a bit of an argument about where the Crinan Canal sits in the priorities among countless neglected infrastructures.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Other threads that may be of interest

zoidberg
Rigging Checklist
Replies
0
Views
121
zoidberg
zoidberg
T
Notices to Mariners - Week 50
Replies
2
Views
653
tillergirl
T

Share this page

Top