Mayday - But who cares ?

Woodentop

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 Nov 2004
Messages
330
Visit site
It is Thursday 12 May, about 0600 GMT. We are about 15 miles north of Cape Finesterre, 25 miles NW of La Corunna. The Biscay crossing has been a dream with winds F6 aft of the beam and going like a greased weasel, though the wind is now fading out.
The boat is a brand new 40 foot sloop. Crew is two YM instructors plus the owner, we are all fit men in our late fourties. The autopilot is steering so we have one on watch, one on standby(dozing) and one asleep.

I hear a strange call on the radio (radio set to Ch 16, cockpit speaker on, volume high, as is my normal practice). Is it a Mayday ? It is a French voice. He calls again. I move below to hear better and prepare to answer. He calls again. Something like "Medemedemede ...motuer en panne..".
I am confused. Is this a Mayday call? Who is he? Where is he? What is the problem?
I call my mate from his bunk to listen.
After the fifth call in fifteen minutes I decide we are listening to a Mayday.
It is not clear at all. No position has been given.
My French is pure schoolboy standard and I am not sure what I heard.

We respond, my mate speaks better French but even he has problems. We call and they answer, after a couple of goes we finally extract a position from them. They speak too fast for us to understand but we get a lat/long.
It is 12 miles south of us.

I fire up the brand new Yanmar with only 12 hours on the gauge, "red-line it" and set a course. The owner wakes up for his cornflakes and we explain what is happening.
"They called Mayday. It is the Law. We go. Now. No question."

They are 90 minutes away and no one else has responded so we go.

Our assesment - from limited information and poor linguistics is that they have lost power and are in danger of being swept onto the rocks by the tide. Their position is close into shore on the "Costa del Muerte" (Coast of Death as the Spanish call it).

We arrive at the position and can only see 4 Spanish fishing boats. We seek an update from the boat. Now we learn it is a 12 metre yacht called Mahe and it is now 6 miles east of us. We motor on.

Finally we catch up with the yacht sailing very slowly/drifting past the shoals at Isla Sisargas. A British yacth motors south past it.

We tow it into La Corunna.

Significant Points.

No one answered the Mayday. If you call Mayday take a deep breathe and say it slowly and clearly. The rushed French m´aidez was not the slow British Maaaaydaaay nor the Spanish Meeedeee and no one bothered, except me.

We SAW eight other vessels that would have been in range and two coast radio stations (La Corrunna and Finnisterre Traffic) but none of them responded.

No position was given in the initial call. In a Mayday call there are only 3 important things to remember. Your position, your position and your position. Because the initial call did not include a position we did not recognise it as a mayday.

Speak slowly. I know that most of the world does not speak English but our forefathers got round that by speaking clearly and loudly. Giving your position as "Four Zero degrees" instead of "fourty degrees" is better. Even amongst English natives we can confuse thirteen with thirty.

With our limited schoolboy French and his thick Breton accent we needed the simple clear speech.

Was it really a Mayday ? A 12 metre yacht with sails and an anchor ? Is failure of the secondary propulsion system grounds for concern ?
In this case they were 12 day out of the Canaries, hard on the wind. They had many equipment failures and diesel algae. It was not the skipper that sent mayady but one of his crew. The skipper had "lost the plot".
It was a mayday because they thought it was, at the time of calling they were in risk of drifting with the tide onto the cliff base with no wind to sail to.

We towed them in. With no pre-agreed contract. The skipper - when he got his act together- was bricking himself about salvage claims. We told him in the harbour we wanted a belly full of beer and dinner. The claim was paid in full and we sang Jacque Brel´s songs through the back streets of La Corunna that following early morning on our way home.

The incident is now a formal complaint from myself to the Spanish authorities and the Salvamento Maritimo for failing to keep a proper radio watch. I hope to update you in due course.

Just another little tale of a day at sea. Another thing to learn from.
 
If nothing else, congratulate yourself on responding. Until you arrived on scene you did not know that they could have sailed off.
 
Agreed, well done. Any potential mayday is worth responding to, as a some time you may be in the opposite position, and for ever grateful to the one crew who were listening
 
You did the only honourable thing, well done. Not surprised to hear you were alone in your efforts to decipher the message and give it the benefit of the doubt. If I ever found myself in a genuine pickle I would hope you were somewhere within listening range!
 
An excellent posting. Thanks and well done!

KIM... I think this should be picked up and reported far and wide in all the YBW the Magazines.
 
mayday calling is abused so much around the spanish coast that there is a regular panpan warning broadcast from canary mcc on sat c, warning about the penalties for abuse - why on that mode of communication is a mystery to me.
I have diverted a few times around the canaries for spurious messages, with the las palmas mcc becoming involved.

cry wolf comes to mind and as you have found - it has its price

the other 'problem' is incessant chatter on ch 16 by idiots thinking that as they cant hear anyone else on channel 16 they must be the only ones on the surface of the earth (or water to be exact) - this causes others to turn down/off their vhf radios - again leading to a lack of response to an alert ......... and it doesnt take a rocket scientist to work out this will only adversly effect those without dsc - normally the prats abusing the emergency frequency in the first place (small boat fishermen as well as recreational users)

as for dsc calling, it would alert all commercial shipping in the area, which are obliged to react and enter their action into the official radio log book, (including a mayday relay as appropriate if a mayday in not responded too (this log book is available for inspection during port state control visits) on receiving a dsc alert in their area.
fyi this mode of transmission has about double the range of 'normal' voice vhf traffic so is a very effective means in educated hands.

lessons learned are the same for the last few decades ...... dont abuse the vhf - it can save you life
 
What you did was exemplary however this incident just goes to show the unreliablilty of VHF. Carry an epirb and a mobile phone your chances of rescue increase exponentialy.
 
PanPan as bad

[ QUOTE ]
It is Thursday 12 May, about 0600 GMT. We are about 15 miles north of Cape Finesterre, 25 miles NW of La Corunna. ...
Just another little tale of a day at sea. Another thing to learn from.

[/ QUOTE ]
Last summer, I called the CROSS coastguard, when I spotted smoke on the horizon, with the coast about 25M on that bearing. Didn't know what it was, so thought would put the ball in their court. They called a PanPan, putting the source of the smoke 10M from my position, asking other vessels to report, and asked me to proceed to the smoke. Told them I could make about 6kts and would take some time to get there. Took a bearing, extrapolated to coastline and put on autopilot to a new WP on the coast. No reply to PanPan heard by me. After about an hour, a chopper arrived, took its direction from my heading and shot off to the coast. My heading included allowance for about 1.5kts cross current !! CG queried bearing with me again, chopper came back then shot off in right direction. After flapping around for about half an hour, the chopper departed. I asked CG if I could resume my course. CG asked me to keep going. Saw a couple of fishing boats, and two yachts - coming from roughly the direction of the smoke - by now, I am convinced that the smoke was ashore - even though shore was 25M away and thus over my horizon - smoke has disappeared by now. After another half hour, heard CG stand down the PanPan. No call to me. So asked again if I could resume my orinal course. CG very abruptly told me I had wasted their time, there was nothing to see, and yes I could go back on course.

Big contrast with HMCG, where false alarms are positively welcomed, on the basis 'it just could have been'. And it was the CG who turned my doubt into a PanPan in the first place.

The fishing boats and yacht were probably within range of my masthead vhf, so I would have heard them if they had reacted at all to the PanPan request for observation.

I would still call it up again, even if just as doubtful.
 
But with a DSC ?

I am not really a fan of DSC - all those blessed alarms going off every time you nip to the heads.

But in this instance I think it would have been better with DSC, so I will tone my bigoted/luddite dislike of it.

The main point, and the worrying one, was the lack of response by any other boat or coast radio station.
 
Yes Matt. this is generally the case. Ive been asked by my Marina to go out to a couple of boats in trouble in the last 3 months, none of the boats in question had got a vhf or any idea of their position & I found them by asking them what landmarks they could see on the coast. The worst one was a 18ft speedboat, with no lifejackets,flares,ropes,fuel,or any heavy coats, 2 people 6 miles away from where they thought they were, weather had changed from 2-3 to 5-6 with heavy rain in 30 minutes. When I got to them they were soaked to the skin freezing cold & scared shitless
In Campoarmar now there are a small group of boaters that have made themselves available for rescue work, there are also a couple in Torrevieja.this seems to be the norm as any one who breaks down always seem to phone for help rather than radio.......Nat
 
Well done for your actions.

As an SRC assessor it's always interesting to have real life stories with which to encourage students to use proper procedure and simple english.

One point though. Did you try a Mayday Relay? Does your boat have DSC? If time had been an important factor here - MOB, severe illness, fire or sinking - then a fast ship with better supplies would have been the better craft to go to the rescue. A DSC set would have woken up the surrounding ships - including the Fishing boats.

Bluebird
 
Re: PanPan

Sailing in Scotland and heard the CG asking for all vessels to check out some smoke that had been reported about 25nm north of us. Local fishing boat and us would've taken some time to get there at about 6kts. So I phoned up work and got one of our guys on his way back to Lossie to check it out, took him 4 mins to get there as opposed to us taking 4hrs. After much looking round worked out that there was nothing anywhere near the position. Cue briefly confused but happy CG, about how a Sun Odessey could do 500kts and an area search so quickly.

Once told the story he got off the phone to the RYA to change the handicap.

/forums/images/graemlins/cool.gif
 
Top