Mark-1
Well-known member
.
Last edited:
That is very interesting. Do you have any practical experience of how visible an LED flare is from helicopter height?Before you make the leap, could I suggest the following thoughts? (I used to fly SAR helicopters but these are my own views, opinions and observations). The MCA have regulations so that their SAR assets are optimised to the kit used by mariners to raise the alarm and attract attention. It might be useful to put yourself in the point of view of the searchers. Lifeboats are similar to boats, but head up to the top of a 200’ cliff and have a look at the sea in front of you. That’s what a helicopter crew sees when they are looking for you (although they do have a very fancy camera system too). If you only sail by day, just how visible is an LED on a bright sunny day? Smoke flares are unsurpassed in my opinion for pin pointing your position by day. Coloured LEDs are invisible or at best indistinct on night vision goggles. Those bright blue lights on ambulances - invisible to NVG, the red lights on TV aerials and wind turbines - bearly visible and not distinguishable against back ground lights. There is no mistaking a handheld flare. Lasers are amongst crew’s worst nightmare. The bright flash experienced is distracting and severely damages night vision. Pilots are trained to turn away from lasers and as with LEDs, just how effective are they by day?
I still fly over the sea for a living and am provided with a lifejacket with lights whistles sprayhood and have a night/day flare and PLB stuffed under my right armpit. Trust me if I thought an LED flare was better, that’s what I’d carry but I am very happy with the night/day. Still have flares on the boat and will continue to do so.
I wasn't setting out a comprehensive case that flares are less safe\effective than the alternatives. I was just stating a few random thoughts.
If you want the basis of the case then this is a starting point:
Carriage of Pyrotechnic Flares | Current Affairs | Knowledge & Advice | RYA - Royal Yachting Association
And have you looked into the safety of laser devices they can present serious risk of eye damage if used wrongly
Thank you for posting.Before you make the leap, could I suggest the following thoughts? (I used to fly SAR helicopters but these are my own views, opinions and observations). The MCA have regulations so that their SAR assets are optimised to the kit used by mariners to raise the alarm and attract attention. It might be useful to put yourself in the point of view of the searchers. Lifeboats are similar to boats, but head up to the top of a 200’ cliff and have a look at the sea in front of you. That’s what a helicopter crew sees when they are looking for you (although they do have a very fancy camera system too). If you only sail by day, just how visible is an LED on a bright sunny day? Smoke flares are unsurpassed in my opinion for pin pointing your position by day. Coloured LEDs are invisible or at best indistinct on night vision goggles. Those bright blue lights on ambulances - invisible to NVG, the red lights on TV aerials and wind turbines - bearly visible and not distinguishable against back ground lights. There is no mistaking a handheld flare. Lasers are amongst crew’s worst nightmare. The bright flash experienced is distracting and severely damages night vision. Pilots are trained to turn away from lasers and as with LEDs, just how effective are they by day?
I still fly over the sea for a living and am provided with a lifejacket with lights whistles sprayhood and have a night/day flare and PLB stuffed under my right armpit. Trust me if I thought an LED flare was better, that’s what I’d carry but I am very happy with the night/day. Still have flares on the boat and will continue to do so.
I'll be honest here and say no I don't. That is why I am careful to say that these are my own observations, opinions etc. All I am doing is pointing out that coloured LEDs are not always compatible with Night Vision Goggles. I personally have doubts about LED flares which might prove to be unfounded. The fact that they are not approved at the moment suggests to me that either testing has not been done or they don't meet the required standard (or there isn't a standard to test them by).That is very interesting. Do you have any practical experience of how visible an LED flare is from helicopter height?
I would think that the likelihood of being able to point a laser flare at someone's eye long enough to harm them in a bouncing boat is pretty small. Certainly far less than the risk of dropping a pyrotechnic or getting a spark in the eye. It's a theoretical risk, but not one that would concern me overly. It may be instant death to night vision, but certainly not instant eye damage, unlike burns.And have you looked into the safety of laser devices they can present serious risk of eye damage if used wrongly
I plan never to use Mayday flares or electro flares in earnest. But if fates take no notice of my plans and I must request urgent assistance I want to maximise my chances of sucess and survivalLagos Navigators used to have the results of their occasional old flares tests on the beach. All well organised with the GNR.
The year I tried my oldest, just in case, flares were ten years old. The failure rate of old flares was surprisingly high, although looking in good condition. The weakness was the fuzes, they failed to light. Of those that did light need two hands to start and one hand to hold at arms length. So while hanging on to a rocking boat, that's all one does for about 60 seconds. God forbid one drops it in board.
Rocket flares require practice to use safely, in my view, even then, mind where you point them.
I carry them only because they are required and plan never to use them in earnest.
You might like to take that up with the CAA and BALPA.I would think that the likelihood of being able to point a laser flare at someone's eye long enough to harm them in a bouncing boat is pretty small. Certainly far less than the risk of dropping a pyrotechnic or getting a spark in the eye. It's a theoretical risk, but not one that would concern me overly. It may be instant death to night vision, but certainly not instant eye damage, unlike burns.
This might help (from link in #81)That is very interesting. Do you have any practical experience of how visible an LED flare is from helicopter height?
I would think that the likelihood of being able to point a laser flare at someone's eye long enough to harm them in a bouncing boat is pretty small. Certainly far less than the risk of dropping a pyrotechnic or getting a spark in the eye. It's a theoretical risk, but not one that would concern me overly. It may be instant death to night vision, but certainly not instant eye damage, unlike burns.
You might like to take that up with the CAA and BALPA.
The video of laser pens being shone at aircraft cockpits and the affect on the crew is terrifying.