ah but this is the morning after and it may be difficult to prove that the port navigation light was working (or faulty depending on who's arguing what) now............
[ QUOTE ]
Sure as h*ll weren't looking where they were going anyway!
[/ QUOTE ]
Look at the mooring lines. Either the collision happened while one of them was moored, or else they were brought in in that condition. If the latter, steering must have been awkward, particularly on a compass course!