DaveS
Well-Known Member
As very much a 'newbie' here, I hoped to avoid getting involved too early (softly, softly, catchee monkey) but, as a Scotsman and a supporter of the Gaelic language, I think all the owners, past and present, should be chastised for use of pseudo-Gaelic.
The correct name SHOULD be 'Sgian Dubh'.
You are, of course, strictly correct. It gets a bit more difficult, however, with geographical terms where the anglicised spelling is in common use. Corryvreckan is "incorrect" but probably much more recognisable than Coire Bhreacain. Then there is Kintyre (Cantyre in the old CCC "Blue Book"); would Cinn Tire be recognised by many?