ColRegs and solo sailors

For those of you who are content to sail single handed offshore and sleep instead of keeping a lookout relying on other vessels to see you.

It’s your choice your life on your head be it. At least if you are hit by a big ship your are only risking your own life.
Oddly I believe free society allows the freedom for people to do things I believe to be less than wise so long as you do not harm or risk harm to anyone else.

As it happens a couple of decades ago. I was a junior ship driver. I might even have been the prankster who saw your little boat on the horizon altered course to have a closer look sneaked up behind you and when only a couple of cables away blew my whistle. Crossing oceans can be a bit dull.

Or I might have been sailing with an old timer who used to come up on the bridge and complain about all us youngsters who relied to much on modern tech. And make me turn the radar of so as not to wear it out. I would try and explain I could keep an effective lookout by sight without needing the RADAR during the day and it was actually more harm to the bits inside it to keep turning it on and off.
Unfortunately a lot of the old chaps wouldn’t believe me.
So contrary to popular belief big ships do not all ways have their RADAR on.
Even when they are on you have to actually look at them. Most big ship drivers back in my day would not use auto acquire and guard zones or alarms. The Alarms are annoying and most captains used to think you were shirking your duty if you relied on them.
Along with getting remarkably upset if they ever found you sitting down in the pilot chair.
Even so from time to time your attention wanders when you are staring for days on end at an empty horizon.
You are think of your next port ,beer, girls, football almost anything except ships.
Funny thing its harder to keep a good look out far out in the ocean on a bright sunny day with clear visibility than it is an a foul day in the channel.

Nowadays ships a bigger have way more electronic gadgets climate controlled full width air conditioned bridges comfy Captain Kirk arm chairs for you to sit in.
Back in the day Id be out on the wing in my shorts and sunglasses working on my bronzy at least I had my eye on the horizon. Nowadays you get skin cancer.

As for lookout I would be alone with auto during the day. At night I always had a lookout with me.
Some guys used to correct charts at night when their lookout was on the bridge relying upon him to report a sighting.
I knew a few 2nd mates who would correct charts during the day if they could see ahead from the chart table. I was never comfortable with that

A full BA world folio had about 3600 charts updated weekly. A never ending job like painting the Forth Bridge. If you were lucky you also carried a folio of American charts for the entire US

Fortunately for the single handed sailor its been decades since anyone was foolish enough to leave me in charge of a tanker. Perhaps they pay better attention today.
There again I used to take evasive action for an other large ship which hadn’t seen mine or didn’t give a toss at least once or twice a month.

The OOCL President is a container ship I still get shudders about. I came within about 50 feet of that one.

As far as I know I never ran over a small boat.
 
Last edited:
That was me :)
Not necessarily OK, but it's either that or stay at home. it's so empty out there I'm OK taking the risk. :)

Its a choice you have to make for your self. If you understand the risk its your right to do so.:)
Hope it continues to work out for you. good luck
I sail single handed from time to time myself. I stick to shorter voyages where I think I can remain awake.:)
 
For those of you who are content to sail single handed offshore and sleep instead of keeping a lookout relying on other vessels to see you.

It’s your choice your life on your head be it.

Do singlehanders rely on others to see them offshore? sounds crazy. AIS reciever will sound an alarm for the vast majority, radar will pick up d squalls and the slim chance of a yacht doing the same thing as you.

as far as collisions go it's much safe out there. :cool:
 
Its a choice you have to make for your self. If you understand the risk its your right to do so.:)
Hope it continues to work out for you. good luck
I sail single handed from time to time myself. I stick to shorter voyages where I think I can remain awake.:)
It's beautiful out there on your own, when you don't see anything else for a week or more and the gadgets pick up everything you do see well before you do you kind of start thinking it's a lot safer that than coastal solo. :cool:
 
Do singlehanders rely on others to see them offshore? sounds crazy. AIS reciever will sound an alarm for the vast majority, radar will pick up d squalls and the slim chance of a yacht doing the same thing as you.

as far as collisions go it's much safe out there. :cool:

I don't know how else to describe it. If you are asleep. :)
I know I have seen many diferent posts on different threads about setting timers and alarms. Single handed sailors deal with the need to sleep by a wide variety of methodes. Yet I can't see how gradualy fatigue would not set in without a decent amount of continuios sleep from time to time.
As fatigue sets in the ability to waken to the sound of an alarm will inevetably decrease.
 
It's beautiful out there on your own, when you don't see anything else for a week or more and the gadgets pick up everything you do see well before you do you kind of start thinking it's a lot safer that than coastal solo. :cool:

There is something quite special about a clear night at sea on your own. Not seeing anything for a weeks. I don't miss that. :)
Leaving aside the issue of lookout. It is much safer out there.

The sea is quite safe, its the bits round the edges which are dangerous.:) and more challenging.
Coastal folks won't see it that way.
 
Last edited:
I don't know how else to describe it. If you are asleep. :)
I know I have seen many diferent posts on different threads about setting timers and alarms. Single handed sailors deal with the need to sleep by a wide variety of methodes. Yet I can't see how gradualy fatigue would not set in without a decent amount of continuios sleep from time to time.
As fatigue sets in the ability to waken to the sound of an alarm will inevetably decrease.
I think I actually sleep *more* mid ocean than on land. Maybe you'll see a ship once a week on average. Night time when the timer goes off you never really wake up fully unless there's something to deal with, just a look around and make a note in the log as memory is something not to be relied upon. If anything is amiss then big coffee first while you wake up properly and think about it then do something. Coastal is where fatigue is problem, way offshore is a well rested place :) as for other ships off the shelf, in 15,000 miles I can think of only one ship which was picked up by radar but not by the ais. The alarms are loud and always seem to pick up traffic before it appears over the horizon.
There's still the problem of running into debris but that exists every night for fully crewed boats as well. A long keeled steel boat like mine will run over cast off fishing nets and hopefully bounce off containers adrift. Ran over nets and hawsers before Midocean but yet to put bouncing of a container to the test. :)
 
C'mon, Uricanejack and GHA and Aries and others....

Wot about being better seen, on a small boat? What d'you recommend and why...?

Personally I would get a seame or a similar bit of kit. You can't do much better than ensuring you are picked up clearly on radar which is still, and shall remain all big ships primary tool for navigation and watch keeping.
 
Personally I would get a seame or a similar bit of kit. You can't do much better than ensuring you are picked up clearly on radar which is still, and shall remain all big ships primary tool for navigation and watch keeping.

+1, but again to be used with discretion. There is a world of difference between sailing in the Solent on a rainy afternoon and crossing the Channel in fog, or catching 40 winks alone in the middle of the Atlantic.

In the Solent (except in fog, perhaps) you don't need any of those electronic gadgets to be seen. You need to keep a very good lookout yourself and follow the applicable rules.

Once offshore it is different. There is much less potential for cluttered sensors, so the electronic gadgets can be useful and turned on. As I said in my first post in this thread, Sea-Me (or equivalent) plus AIS transmitter allow others to see you more easily. It is like wearing hi-vis clothing. Of course if everyone on Oxford Street wore hi-vis clothing, none of them would stand out (equivalent of everyone transmitting their AIS info in the Solent).

Then there are things you can do to help see others better. AIS receiver, radar, and radar detector.

It ain't complicated.

And if anyone doubts the ability of an alarm to wake you up when you are completely exhausted, they have never used a Screaming Meanie. If that alarm doesn't wake you up, you've got problems that go beyond being tired.
 
C'mon, Uricanejack and GHA and Aries and others....

Wot about being better seen, on a small boat? What d'you recommend and why...?
Offshore I only turn on the masthead at night as it seems traditional, I really don't expect anyone to see it :)
Having a big lump of steel getting picked up on radar 15 miles away works for me :cool:
But much happier to see them first rather than rely on them seeing me and actually doing something about it. Which the big boys all seem to be very good at Midocean, I can watch them change course for a few minutes 5 miles away to give more sea room. But nice to know that someone's around before they pop up over the horizon.
 
I offered a possible solution. Your counter is only concerned with one scenario a busy day in the Solent.

I've nothing against the solution. Unfortunately you didn't just offer a solution you demanded that it be made compulsory. When you are talking about legislation you have a responsibility to consider the one or two scenarios where it is stupid.

Without your demand for AIS to be compulsory I think we're in agreement.
 
C'mon, Uricanejack and GHA and Aries and others....

Wot about being better seen, on a small boat? What d'you recommend and why...?

I tend to think of it in similar terms to defensive driving.
I make the assumption the other driver is less than careful and not particularly observant. This way when proven wrong it is a pleasant and much appreciated surprise.

A good set of Navigation lights. Brighter than required. Most are. (back up?)
A good properly hung radar reflector(so it catches rain)
I’m not very familiar with AIS its limitations, reliability and how A and B transponders fits in with commercial equipment.
An AIS transponder seems sensible.
I’ve seen large ships with just a digital display giving vessel details bearing and distance.
I’ve also seen AIS set up to display on electronic chart systems.
And optionally on RADAR screens.

A good big bright flash light to shine in direction of other vessel to attract attention and to illuminate sails.

For coastal sailing I would say deck level separate side lights well forward are the best and easiest to see from the Bridge of a ship. Combination bow lights are almost as good.
Deck level side lights well aft on coach roof are the ones which tend to get obscured.

The tri color can be lost in background light and appears much further away. Well of shore it will be seen much much further away. Most lookouts tend to focus more on the horizon than close in

The funny thing about how the eye works. You often don’t see a steady contact you are looking right at. The peripheral vision usually detects something first. Its attracted to movement spotted by the corner of your eye.

Strobes or flashing lights take advantage of this. They are a grey area it non compliant to show lights which may be confused with something else. A small white strobe. I’m going to think lifebuoy life raft also fishing float.

The Red Green all-round is rare.
 
From left field....... A helium balloon at night with a luminescent (light) element in the baloon. If the helium balloon is 100 feet above the boat, that is a pretty visible signal. just a thought. A mad. crazy, thought, admittedly. But, I can't see how it wouldn't work!
 
C'mon, Uricanejack and GHA and Aries and others....

Wot about being better seen, on a small boat? What d'you recommend and why...?
Thinking a bit more about being seen....
In China recently I bought a 1000mW laser pen, will easily bounce off buildings a mile away. Bet that would get me seen. :cool:
Must be completely illegal though.
 
From left field....... A helium balloon at night with a luminescent (light) element in the baloon. If the helium balloon is 100 feet above the boat, that is a pretty visible signal. just a thought. A mad. crazy, thought, admittedly. But, I can't see how it wouldn't work!

Chinese lanterns? :D
 
From left field....... A helium balloon at night with a luminescent (light) element in the baloon. If the helium balloon is 100 feet above the boat, that is a pretty visible signal. just a thought. A mad. crazy, thought, admittedly. But, I can't see how it wouldn't work!



a view of the Solent at night :D



yee-peng-floating-lanterns.jpg
 
Top