Hardly surprising as butyl tape is for sealing, not an adhesive.I used butyl tape to bond new windows to the hull, a week later the starboard window sagged due to direct sunlight and I had to re fit them. After a lot of research I used Bostik Simson ISR 70-08 AP and have been very pleased with the results.
I used a Stanley blade years ago to trim round a fitting and even though gentle still see the blade marks.Do not use a metal blade as you will cut the gel coat. Use a sharp piece of plastic such as the type of spreader used for plastic padding. Keep a sharpish edge on it with a file or a sharp blade.
You will need to tighten the fastenings and re-trim the surplus in a few months time.