ARC - safer or not safer than going alone?

tcm

...
Joined
11 Jan 2002
Messages
23,958
Location
Caribbean at the moment
Visit site
I had a few chats/run-ins with people over this, perhaps worth another thread?

I did the ARC (initially) because the numbers add up - and because instead of being in some canarian resort-hotel marina ("no, there's no chandlery here but would you be interested in buying a villa, sir?") where just me and Barry The Gangster are gonna transat, in Las Palmas there's loads with common cause and lots of suppliers than don't need explaining that it's gotta be supplied/done right now, not in a few weeks. Las Palmas marina fees plus the arc fee was less money than other if not all marinas.

Henyway, i did say (just in passing) to one of the yellow coats er arc staff that huh, not really "safer" is it? She looked at me as though i was bonkers. She cited an example of world arc where they got a ship to escort the arcies through pirate zone and erm, ok, fair point. But not for transat?

With the ARC you set off at 1pm so everyone has a look at the nice saily boats. But it wd be a lot safer to go earlyish morning, plenty of time to get away from land/rocks and or return in daylight?

You set off in a bunfight of 220other yachts plus sightseers. Ooer. two or three had smashups and set off a day or so later. Not that safe there, really? But ok, if it's organised i spose it's gotta have a start. Or as they say, they like starts and so do the locals.

The safety in numbers seems to be attractive, but of coure in reality, what exactly am i gonna do on my boat and 2+ metres swell to help you fix things? At no point did i expect or ask for people to help with our busted relays. One guy within range midatlantic sed he's got relays but they weren't the right partno and even so, i'm not gonna try getting too close in 3m swell with added squalliness.

Once set off, your one yer own, as others say. Or you should expect that, really. I initially toldem i don't want race positions but erm, then relented and ok, yes we do. Then, i got right into it and nipped into st lucia at 4am. Again, i wouldn't normally do this. Ok, my decision, my red mist. But they give these positions all the time and if anyone did this on a car rally, everyone would be uninsured. Heyho.

Wcc don't say or do much to the effect that - er by the way everyone - we organise the onshore parties and stuff - but out there yer on yer own pal. They even invite people with a problem to email wcc in cowes "or leave a message on the answerphone". Yeah, right.

Oh, and i didn't mention Starfire, Sadler 25footer, but i should. Alan (aged 22) and also young tom set out same day as the arc off the far end of the arc startline. They cdn't join the arc cos boat too small. But fab sailors, wd have been fine. Then their rudder broke and they contacted an arc boat Silver Bear who agreed/offered to sail along with range. WCC clumsliy reported this as Silver Bear agreeing to escort starfire "despite the fact that Starfire wasn't an ARC boat" (!) and even as they appraoched, wcc staff seemed to only see their responsibilities to find a space for silver bear, not starfire as well, and well, if that means they're not gonna be in separate berths well, whatever. Several explained the situation. A lot of bods went out on another yot to whoop them in, i decided to go on the dinghy perhaps if they need bit of pushing in if no rudder. Just before we set off, knowing they were in the bay, i went to arc office at the last moment to say look, you gotta puttem together for crissakes, bonding and all that, what about near here, eh? But they sed hm, bit shallow. What's their draft? I asked. A random bloke waiting in the arc office sed "starfire draws 5ft 9inches". Hm, who are you? I'm the skipper's dad, just turned up. Does he know you're here? No. I'm going out to meetem on the dinghy, i said, dya wanna come along? I'd love to, he said. So lights, mobile vhf, armband beacons each, we set off. Bit choppy in the bay. Alan's dad asked if any chance we could gettim on the boat and i sed we'll try. Starfire was having to motor speedily 6+knots to keep way on with teeny jury-riggd rudder but we got the dink up alongside and boosted his dad on board to big surprise and pretty emotional father/son reunion, very memorable. WCC seemed to have seen the light at last and put starfire and silver bear together, big dockside welcome etc, and silver bear later got a special prize for being a good chap etc so all fine.

The smallest "official" arc boat, a sadler29 turned up a couple of days later, and skipper bit narked that he got thrashed by a sadler25 with no rudder, and angrily sed that they shouldn't have even been on the startline. Bad show, Ron...

I *didn't* get any prize, cos we used our engine (quite a lot on windless days) total reported 14hours but an identical boat with three extra people managed to average 8 knots and arrived 3hours latr but with zero (reported) engine hours, even on days with almost no wind, so obviously i need sail trimming lessons. Zefender says "boll*cks, surely?" and i saw some boats with spinny on and engine blaring, but what the heck. Being there first was ok for us.

Anyway, i've already signed up to do it again next year, so -even from a sceptic like me- it must've been more than ok, really? Or maybe it's healthier to be a sceptic. My favourite bit of the arc was the frst welcome party - the Gran Canaria Minister of Tourism gaping open-mouthed at the official welcome party parade of the local Gays and Drag Queens, haha. He must've known what was gonna happen tho. Perhaps he asked for it to be not to outrageous, family show etc, and er, well, bit of a hoot...
 
Last edited:
After doing the ARC I wrote an article about the good and bad of rallies for the benefit of others considering it.

FWIW, here it is....

Pros and Cons of rallying
Many sailors speak disparagingly of rally participants, assuming they are all beginners who wouldn’t leave the Solent without a nanny organisation to look after them and imply that real sailors travel independently. We have done both and would consider another rally in future. We met no-one on the rallies who couldn’t have gone across the ocean on their own, the supposed wet-behind-the-ears beginner is a complete myth.

Pro

The biggest draw for many people is the social side, getting to meet other crews, not to mention the numerous parties. For us the party circuit started in Lagos when we invited everyone who was flying an ARC flag aboard for drinks; we regularly met up with that group over the next 6 months in many anchorages.
The support provided by the rally organisers was useful, for example they found me an English-speaking dentist when I lost a tooth three days before departure from Las Palmas.
The daily radio net and position reporting meant that our family knew where we were (at least some of the time) and when things went wrong there was help at hand. Our friends on Spirit of Clyde rescued a French singlehander whose boat sank and two other boats stood by to help. Most rescues involve ARC participants helping non-ARC boats
Reserved berths at either end were useful, especially in Las Palmas and it was good to have someone to take our lines as we came into St Lucia with engine problems.
The ARC rallies are run as races and the friendly competition added to the interest of the passage. For the keen racers there was also an all-out racing division.
Because of the number of people taking part, some of the big names in ocean cruising came to give seminars, for example Jimmy Cornell on routes beyond the Caribbean and David Jones on Caribbean meteorology.

Con
Rallies always have pre-set start times and there is pressure to stick to those because of the shore team’s hotel and flight bookings. If the weather turns bad, as it did when we left Bermuda for the Azores, you have to be strong-minded to stay in harbour when others are pressing on.
In a very structured rally like the ARC there is no opportunity for unplanned stops so we missed out on the Cape Verdes and Barbados. For that reason alone we will probably avoid the ARC next time round.
Some crews get a bit over-enthusiastic about completing the crossing and hit the party scene hard. That gets a bit wearing if you’re moored right in front of the marina bar and the music is still going strong at 5a.m.
The downside of the racing element is the temptation to hang on to canvas a bit longer and risk damage to gear.
On a multi-leg rally like ARC Europe, the fast boats spend a lot of time in port waiting for the others to catch up and the slow boats have a shorter time to rest and repair before moving on.
The ARC isn't cheap. It is better value for money than others because the cost of staff flights is spread over 200+ boats but it still takes a big lump out of a cruising budget. The current cost for a 40 footer with 4 crew is over £900.
 
I have never crossed any oceans/seas in an organised group. Why would you want to do that is beyond me. APART from the people who are afraid or in the early days of learning to sail.

Just my humble opinion.

Peter
 
The current cost for a 40 footer with 4 crew is over £900.

Nine Hundred Quid ?????? for what ? A guaranteed berth at each end & someone to chat too on SSB/HF.

220 odd boats. Someone is on a nice little earner.
 
"What's their lower limit and reasoning for it?"

A cynic might say that the reason is that the Organisers wanted to get everybody in and accounted for long before Christmas, hence they are not too keen on smaller boats - also, smaller boats would still involve almost as much 'administration' yet earn a fraction of what a bigger boat would pay.

I sailed in the first ARC, and there was a specific class then for boats under (I think) 30' - and a fair few of these were singlehanders as well.
They included :
'Raggles' (a Hurley 22 with 2 on board, plus a dog),
'Mithril' (a home completed Frances 26 with 2 on board - they sailed back to the UK the following summer),
'Shuffle' (a steel double ended 23' built in the IoW, singlehanded and surprisingly fast),
'Crumpet' (a 25' Trapper, singlehanded),
'Tahit' (a singlehanded Sadler 26),
'Andani' (an Elizabethan 29, singlehanded, and blisteringly fast, I think Tim won the class).

Oh, and 'Dunkers', a singlehanded Achilles 24, who came in last, after (I think) 31 days at sea, cos his Navik self steering packed up soon after leaving the Canaries, and he hand steered the rest of the way, heaving to when he needed some shut eye.

But all 200 boats in that first ARC made it across safely, despite quite a few them being of a size / standard that would not permit them to enter this year.
 
Last edited:
But all 200 boats in that first ARC made it across safely, despite quite a few them being of a size / standard that would not permit them to enter this year.
And these days they won't accept singlehanders. It's like the Ostar - Jester wouldn't be allowed to enter in the Jester class.
 
As someone who thought about joining the ARC but didn’t, someone with this dilemma might be interested in my reasons and experiences.

I thoroughly approve of the original idea of the ARC, a “leg-up” for the inexperienced skipper who (rightly) feels that their first ocean crossing is somewhat daunting and wants to be properly prepared. However, I decided to do it alone – for one thing, there was plenty of advice in books, notably Anne Hammick’s excellent “Ocean Cruising on a Budget” (most of the preparation has to be done months before you depart home shores); also I felt going in a big group slightly defeated my idea of independence in my sailing plans (e.g. timing, the option of the Cape Verdes, and where you decide to end up, e.g. Barbados.

I had no regrets, because most of the “advantages” of the ARC seemed to be available free of charge from the excellent multi-national group of companion yachts we discovered in Santa Cruz de Teneriffe.

There was no difficulty socialising (someone organised a pontoon party the evening we arrived, and we got to know loads of other yachts in the 2 weeks we were there), and on the crossing we chatted to that group and others, informally, every day on the SSB at 0800UT. This informal SSB net managed to organise 2 genuine rescues during or shortly after our crossing: one man cut his foot and rendezvoused with qualified doctors, and an Australian catermaran sailed 80 miles up-wind to “baby-sit” and elderly couple who damaged their rig by gibing about a third of the way across.

I may have been lucky, but it was never difficult to meet other yachts, socialise with them and stay in touch with SSB. Herb’s weather service was invaluable (is he still going?) and another way of making contact with yachts in your vicinity.

I am now slightly suspicious of the ARC – everyone seems to think it’s a race (why race? Isn’t the experience of crossing an ocean, successfully and safely in your own yacht, enough?), and I have met enough people who have flown down to the Canary Islands to “do the ARC” to put me off the whole idea. Also don’t be deluded: you are better off not buying the rather dubious “safety in numbers” angle. When you cross an ocean, you should accept that for most purposes, you and your crew are on your own. Prepare for that, and don’t think it’s loads easier in an organised group.
 
When I did my first transat as skipper of my own boat ( Amethyst Glory - 1988 to Barbados ) I joined the ARC. The shoreside help, the abundance of other peoples experience to learn from, the 'safety in numbers' idea and the parties !! made it all worthwhile for me, especially with my limited ocean going skippering experience.

Since then I have done it twice more, but skippering other peoples boats. hated them both. We were on a time table, once to meet the owners family in St. Lucia, once to get to the charter show in time. No time to enjoy the island on arrival and pressure to use the engine to keep the boat speed up.

So, when I next do a transat I will certainly not be doing the ARC. I will leave later ( better winds ), and cruise across stopping, if I feel like it, in the Cape Verdes or Barbados. However, I would definitely reccomend it for a firsttimer.

BTW, one of the reasons there are so many boats in the racing classes is down to the fact that to take paying guests ( which a lot of boats do these days ) the boat should be MCA category 0. ( very expensive and involves stability tests, loads of extra equipment etc. ). A yacht that is in a race does not have to have the same categorisation.

Chris
 
Top