AIS / VHF Antenna interference

sebastiannr

New member
Joined
4 Apr 2010
Messages
186
Location
Liveaboard, currently in BVI's
Visit site
Hi there,

Apologies if this has already been covered in another thread - I couldn't find the answer.

My mast is down at the moment so I thought I would take the opportunity to install a separate antenna for my AIS receiver at the mast head. I have heard conflicting information about what is the best thing to do. My father reckons that if two antennae (i.e. VHF and AIS) are within 1m of each other they will interfere with each other, so he recommends using a single antenna with a splitter. Other sources have suggested that a splitter is not ideal as if it fails, transmitting on the VHF will fry the AIS unit.

What is the best solution, given that I have a good opportunity to install a second antenna while the mast is down?

Many thanks,

Sebastian.
 

Playtime

Active member
Joined
29 Jan 2007
Messages
1,194
Location
Chichester
Visit site
Hi there,

Apologies if this has already been covered in another thread - I couldn't find the answer.

My mast is down at the moment so I thought I would take the opportunity to install a separate antenna for my AIS receiver at the mast head. I have heard conflicting information about what is the best thing to do. My father reckons that if two antennae (i.e. VHF and AIS) are within 1m of each other they will interfere with each other, so he recommends using a single antenna with a splitter. Other sources have suggested that a splitter is not ideal as if it fails, transmitting on the VHF will fry the AIS unit.

What is the best solution, given that I have a good opportunity to install a second antenna while the mast is down?

Many thanks,

Sebastian.

The best solution, IMHO, is to mount the second aerial on the pushpit, ideally on a pole to give a bit more height and make it less vulnerable. This avoids the separation versus splitter problem altogether but still gives a range for AIS reception of at least 12 miles, which is quite sufficient for all practical purposes. It also provides a 'spare' VHF aerial in the event of a dismasting.
 
Last edited:

dmayes

Member
Joined
22 Mar 2005
Messages
168
Location
Berkshire
www.drmsom.com
Wavelengths

The marine VHF is around 150MHz and the speed of radio transmissions is around 300M Km/s This makes the wavelength of a full wave about 2 meters in length. VHF aerials are aroung 1m in length as this is a 1/2 wave and makes an efficient reception. Directional aerials have similar size unconnected rods about 1/4 wave distance from the actual aerial, this receives the signal and re-radiates it increasining the strength of the signal at the aerial and making the aerial more directional as it only increases the strength in the same line as it is placed in relation to the aerial. Look at UHF television aerials and you will see many more radiating rods so it looks like a ladder, this means you have to point the aerial at the television station. VHF needs to receive from all around so don't put a second aerial near the first, certainly not in a multiple distance of the 1/4 wave signal length.
 

multihullsailor6

New member
Joined
29 Jun 2009
Messages
560
Location
Cruising in the sun! Now in Malta
Visit site
Simrad's installation recommendation for my AIS stated that one should have at least 2m vertical separation between the VHF and the AIS aerials. Hence we placed the AIS aerial on the 2nd spreader which works just fine with excellent allround and long-range reception.
 

pvb

Well-known member
Joined
16 May 2001
Messages
45,605
Location
UK East Coast
Visit site
You don't need the AIS antenna very high to get adequate reception. Stick it on the pushpit, as already suggested.
 

Elemental

Well-known member
Joined
30 May 2007
Messages
1,192
Location
Cambridge
Visit site
You don't need the AIS antenna very high to get adequate reception. Stick it on the pushpit, as already suggested.
+1 for sticking it on the pushpit.

I routinely see traffic 10NM away and have never seen anything suddenly "appear" much closer. Do you need to know about ships 20NM away?
 
Top