Which is the best anchor

[ QUOTE ]
This intrigues me. To follow the agricultural analogy, consider the shape of the tread on tractor tyres. In forward gear the tread pushes outwards like a plough, not inwards like a spade. There is a very good reason for this, as anyone who has tried reversing a tractor up a muddy slope will know.

[/ QUOTE ]It isn't really counter-intuitive. There's little analogy to anchoring.

The tire on a tractor must deal with soft mud in which it will never attain a good grip. The tread is designed to push that mud away and allow contact with more solid material underneath. Furthermore it isn't really a plough shape, most tractor tires I'm familiar with have alternating lines at opposite angles, not Vs:

175198629_a927901476_m.jpg


As the tractor moves forward, the tread first meets the ground at the center of the tire, then moves outward as the tire rotates. The direction then alternates. In reverse, this tread would be pulling loose mud toward the center of the tire and causing obvious problems.

This is similar to car tires; many wet weather tires have an obvious V pattern, or side-to-rear design, that is intended to move water underneath the tire away to the sides as well as possible.

Another issue with reversing up a hill would be the transfer of weight onto the smaller front wheels, particularly a problem if the tractor is not 4WD.

Off topic?

Disclaimer: I am not a tractor or tire expert.
 
I have no intention of anchoring with tractor tyres, but I might need to use them as fenders one day! If we assume we have a boat of 35 ft with a 16 kg anchor (type to be designated) and 60 metres of 8 mm chain, the total weight in the bow is about 101 kg (figures from Jimmy Green). Given that the most secure way of anchoring(?) is to tie to a mooring buoy attached to heavy chain attached to a heavy sinker (and it also gives the smallest swinging room), would we not be better to follow the same logic and take about the same total weight in a 25 kg anchor and 20 metres of 12 mm chain. I know you wouldn't be able to use all chain in anchorages deeper than about 6 metres but you would have much reduced swinging (a requirement in Newton River and other Solent locations), and you could use warp to extend the chain if necessary. Most of the time the chain would hang straight down anyway. Anyone any thoughts?
 
Top