Sea-kindly boat that can go upwind in a blow but can sail in light winds too?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date

Ric

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 Dec 2003
Messages
1,723
Visit site
I am looking for "next boat" suggestions.

I sail uniquely in the Med (mainly Western Med) which for all its detractions, has lots of good points - plus it is where I am lucky enough to live! However, the area is infamous for having either very little wind, or far too much, mixed with nasty short breaking waves from random directions. I mostly sail single-handed, with most passages not more than one or two nights.

My current boat is generic French 32 fin-keeler with 130% overlap genoa and small mainsail - which is not very comfortable in anything above an F5, can't sail upwind as soon as genoa is rolled, and has very limited vision from down below meaning that I am always a bit stressed just putting the kettle on when sailing inshore.

I don't want to go much above about 36ft - I want to be able to easily handle the boat single-handed, including berthing in tight marinas. I want a double head-sail arrangement with a decent upwind fore-sail (solent, or possibly even a self-tacker), plus a genoa or gennaker for off-wind sailing. I'd like a lot of cockpit storage - so would prefer deep cockpit lockers to a massive rear cabin with hanging cupboards which would only ever have a couple of t-shirts in them!

Ironically the two boats that I have identified that might suit my needs are not marketed for med-sailors at all - the RM1060 or Southerly 110...

The RM seems like a very seaworthy design that would be a cracking good sail across a wide range of wind-speeds due to the decent sail-plan, and the cold moulded hull is apparently very quiet in a big blow - but possibly the light displacement and broad "Open" style hull would make it fairly bouncy in typical short Med seas. It has good vision from down below, tiller steering which generally I find better for single-handing, and plenty of cockpit storage and space. The twin keels are rather irrelevant for Med sailing - though I guess they would be useful to reduce yard fees! I know there is also a single-keel version but the draught is limiting even in the Med.

The other is something from the Southerly range such as the 110, the 35RS or even the new 36. Seems like they would be very comfortable and powerful upwind and perhaps not too bad in light winds if fitted with a furling gennaker.

I'd be grateful for any other suggestions or observations - I think the key points are double-head sails, forward vision and sea-kindliness. I don't need internal volume and speed which seem to the the only objectives of modern designs..
 
My HR34 is from an older generation but comes somewhere towards what you want. Because it carries nearly 40% ballast of lead it can carry plenty of sail for light winds, when it performs well, but of course not like modern flyers, and in higher winds doesn't need a reef with a 110% jib up to about 24kn apparent to windward. It has a decent forefoot and is comfortable in most conditions.
 
Neither have vision from down below! I don't want another submarine like most modern boats - but nor do I need a full deck saloon with windscreen wipers! I would just like to be able to keep an eye out on the horizon from down below.
 
It's like the benefits of a car with two gears instead of one - plus having two fore-stays is not a bad idea either. I don't want hanked-on sails in case anybody is thinking of suggesting I should go down that route!

Just to be clear - not talking about a cutter rig - just want a sloop with twin forestays with one sail for upwind work and another for off wind work in lighter winds.
 
Last edited:
I have a Starlight 35 that would fit your requirements. We once sailed it upwind in a race with a steady 40 knots ( the odd gust to close on 50 - the forecast had been F9) and were the only boat ( inc some 45ft French boats) to make the windward mark. True we were daft to get involved in racing in those conditions but you know what ist like when some of the fleet go out. You cant stay behind. Anyway no damage at all though the ride wasnt that comfortable. We did it under third reef in the main and a well rolled laminate jib with a padded luff.

In very light winds the boats merit is a bit less obvious because the high ballast ratio and high stix that makes it a good bad weather boat means that it wont keep up with a benny first in 10knots of breeze.

Having said all this it isnt the boat I would chose for the med where the problem is heat rather than wind. I would go for a cat
 
I have a Starlight 35 that would fit your requirements. We once sailed it upwind in a race with a steady 40 knots ( the odd gust to close on 50 - the forecast had been F9) and were the only boat ( inc some 45ft French boats) to make the windward mark. True we were daft to get involved in racing in those conditions but you know what ist like when some of the fleet go out. You cant stay behind. Anyway no damage at all though the ride wasnt that comfortable. We did it under third reef in the main and a well rolled laminate jib with a padded luff.

In very light winds the boats merit is a bit less obvious because the high ballast ratio and high stix that makes it a good bad weather boat means that it wont keep up with a benny first in 10knots of breeze.

Having said all this it isnt the boat I would chose for the med where the problem is heat rather than wind. I would go for a cat


He wants to go to windward!
 
[/B]He wants to go to windward!

Thats what engines are for!. I've had monos and a cat and I know which I would prefer for live aboard in a hot climate. Problem with boats as with cars is that no boat does everything. Living aboard the most important biut isnt going to windward but existing at anchor. And a cat beats any mono into a cocked hat when it comes to comfort at anchor.

Starlights are nice boats - but once again don't have any visibility from down below.

Not as good as a cat or a deck saloon boat its true but definitely better than the same sized moody / westerly ( according to swmbo and she is always right). The boat had to pass that test before I was allowed to buy it.
 
Last edited:
Top