Riddle of the Rescue at sea

Badger

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 Jan 2002
Messages
582
Location
South East
Visit site
Thank heaven you saw me!" exclaimed Ted Long as he feebly helped make fast his battered yawl to Dr. Hall's chartered fishing boat.

Hall reached over the side and assisted the bedraggled yachtsman aboard.

Long staggered into the shade of the cabin and sagged upon a berth. He removed his cap to wipe the perspiration from his brow, revealing a bald, freckled head.

"Drink this," said Hall, holding out a cup of water.

Long gulped it frantically, asked for a second, and when he had downed it, told of his ordeal.

"Bill Smith and I were sailing for Bimini when the storm hit us. The sails, rudder, and radio went in the first five minutes. We barely managed to keep afloat.

"We drifted five days, lost. Three days ago our fresh water supply gave out. Bill went crazy with the heat and thirst. He started to drink the ocean water. I tried to restrain him -- I hit him. He -- he struck his head against the starboard rail. He's dead! It's my fault!"

Hall climbed into Long's disheveled yacht. In the little cabin he found Bill Smith laid out on his back, dead. The criminologist studied the bruise on Smith's jaw and the one at the base of his skull.

Back on the fishing boat, he warned Long grimly, "You're going to have to tell the police a better tale than the one you told me!"

Why didn't Hall believe Long?



<hr width=100% size=1>
 
If he was dehydrated he would'nt be perspiring?

<hr width=100% size=1>.. whit way roon should it be again ..
 
Think I may have sussed it.Would a person suffering severe dehydration still have perspiration on his brow??

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
Well Done Jimi and Graham..

and hard lines Nige......

Hall knew that Long's story of hitting Smith and accidentally killing him while retraining him from drinking ocean water was false. If the supply of fresh water had given out "three days ago," as Long claimed, he would have been dehydrated, and therefore could not have wiped "the perspiration from his brow."



<hr width=100% size=1>
 
So why didn't Ted just say "Dunno what happened to Bill - when I woke up yesterday, he'd disappeared. Poor soul!"

Oh, OK

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
Quite right, this is an obvious fit up, if this poor scapegoat had been guilty of such an offence would he have have preserved the evidence?

Anyway, I have never really trusted single handed sailors (loners or personality disorders?), and since the good doctor was single handed we have no means of corroborating his account, chances are that the sun was well over the yardstick, this had affected the good doctor's judgement, and it was only as he sobered up (having fed the scapegoat gallons of fresh water) that he noticed the sweat!

Is this the beginning of a Forensic seamanship forum?

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
hmmmm....... got me

<hr width=100% size=1><A target="_blank" HREF=http://www.bertilewis.com/queen-mary.htm>Queen Mary Ship</A>
 
Top