Puffin numbers dropping on Burhou. Don't disturb.

harry potter

Well-Known Member
Joined
21 Jun 2010
Messages
438
Visit site
Puffin numbers still dropping

News*| Published:*Apr 3, 2018

Alderney Wildlife Trust people and wildlife officer Claire Thorpe said the number of puffins breeding on Burhou dropped from 97 in 2016 to 93 last year.

In 2016 the number of puffins breeding in the burrows on Burhou was 97, which reduced to 93 last year.

Claire Thorpe said the main reasons behind the decline were changing climate and sea temperature.

‘We are at the bottom of their range so as their food goes north to colder water they will travel further north, it’s a small colony anyway here,’ she said.

Islanders have been urged to help the puffins by throwing less waste, such as plastic, in the sea and eating sustainable fish to make sure the puffin’s food resources are not used up.

Sailors have also been asked to reduce their speed and stay at least 100m from the colony to cut the disturbance as it affects the puffins’ feeding behaviour.

Ornithologist Vic Froome said the main thing islanders could do was to leave them be as birds in general are sensitive to disturbance around them.

Puffin numbers were increasing up until stormy weather killed thousands of sea birds and Mr Froome said the current situation must take this in to account.

‘The puffins are stable.

‘There’s not as many as we’d like but they are stable,’ he said.

‘When you’re talking about nature, five or ten years is a very short time.

‘When you have an event where thousands of birds die it’s going to take a long time to regroup.

‘It’s not all doom and gloom.’

Puffins will start to lay their eggs, which are likely to hatch at the end of April, before returning to sea in July.
 
I have only occasionally seen puffins, but they must come high on everyone's list of favourite birds. The last one I saw was near Herm, when we went on a (rather uncomfortable) bird-watching trip in a RIB. I was recently given a lovely book on seabirds, called 'The Seabird's Cry' by Adam Nicolson. The first couple of chapters are a bit overwritten, but the chapter on puffins deals with the problems these birds face, like many seabird species.
 
Landing is banned from March to September!

I suspect this is more to do with food sources rather than passing boats.
 
Do I understand this correctly? The experts tell us that human interaction is a threat to these birds’ existence on the rock, yet Claire and her team have counted every individual one. And they’ve done this so precisely that they know that four of the previous year’s 97 creatures are missing. Not off fishing, or taking a flying tour because there are humans out patrolling their nesting ground with clipboards, or just collecting at the other end of the island where the humans were counting their cousins this morning. Missing. That’s a remarkably accurate survey. I wonder how they did it?
 
Do I understand this correctly? The experts tell us that human interaction is a threat to these birds’ existence on the rock, yet Claire and her team have counted every individual one. And they’ve done this so precisely that they know that four of the previous year’s 97 creatures are missing. Not off fishing, or taking a flying tour because there are humans out patrolling their nesting ground with clipboards, or just collecting at the other end of the island where the humans were counting their cousins this morning. Missing. That’s a remarkably accurate survey. I wonder how they did it?

Appreciate their good intentions but the wildlife officer has a career to think about and hence has to be monitoring, counting etc and generally interacting with the puffins, I tend to be with Froome on this matter - leave well alone, cut out any bird watching trips etc that may disturb them and accept that they will migrate if they are truly at the edge of their range.
 
An apposite image from a local artist, Simon Drew...

https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0210/4540/products/simon_drew_cards163_65bbd685-a8f2-4184-9fff-ab81264e958d_1024x1024.png?v=1478040131
imagepng
 
Appreciate their good intentions but the wildlife officer has a career to think about and hence has to be monitoring, counting etc and generally interacting with the puffins, I tend to be with Froome on this matter - leave well alone, cut out any bird watching trips etc that may disturb them and accept that they will migrate if they are truly at the edge of their range.

Indeed.

Perhaps it is a shame if giving careers to puffin enthusiasts causes the very activity that harms the birds’ population (disturbing them, even apparently coming within 100m) while feeding the public results based on poor evidence (97 birds reduced to 93) and publishing conclusions that are pure conjecture (it’s the island’s changing climate wot dunnit)?
 
Do I understand this correctly? The experts tell us that human interaction is a threat to these birds’ existence on the rock, yet Claire and her team have counted every individual one. And they’ve done this so precisely that they know that four of the previous year’s 97 creatures are missing. Not off fishing, or taking a flying tour because there are humans out patrolling their nesting ground with clipboards, or just collecting at the other end of the island where the humans were counting their cousins this morning. Missing. That’s a remarkably accurate survey. I wonder how they did it?

Shades of Neil Garrent whatsisname and the Studland seahorses.
 
Appreciate their good intentions but the wildlife officer has a career to think about and hence has to be monitoring, counting etc and generally interacting with the puffins, I tend to be with Froome on this matter - leave well alone, cut out any bird watching trips etc that may disturb them and accept that they will migrate if they are truly at the edge of their range.

Typical bull from a conservationist, how can they count so precisely? Nothing to do with "global warming" need to cull a few shitehawks! I was off Skomer near Milford a few years ago watching puffins, the evil shitehawks were waiting by the entry to the nest holes to catch the puffins as they flew in and out! Thoughts of what I would like to do to them were foremost in my mind!
 
Appreciate their good intentions but the wildlife officer has a career to think about and hence has to be monitoring, counting etc and generally interacting with the puffins, I tend to be with Froome on this matter - leave well alone, cut out any bird watching trips etc that may disturb them and accept that they will migrate if they are truly at the edge of their range.
------- i used to work for turus mara crewing on puffin watching trips to lunga on the treshnish isles off mull ----bird tourists would lie down with cameras 3 -6 feet away from the puffins who be completely unfazed and seemed to observing the tourists------and as for eating sustainable fish---who eats sandeels the main puffin diet----seems like ill informed conservationist b -llshit
 
------- i used to work for turus mara crewing on puffin watching trips to lunga on the treshnish isles off mull ----bird tourists would lie down with cameras 3 -6 feet away from the puffins who be completely unfazed and seemed to observing the tourists------and as for eating sustainable fish---who eats sandeels the main puffin diet----seems like ill informed conservationist b -llshit

who eats sand eels? We do as "margarine" A while back there was a furore, factory ships hoovering up sand eels to be processed for their oil which was then used as a cheap source of oil for hydrogenated oil products
 
who eats sand eels? We do as "margarine" A while back there was a furore, factory ships hoovering up sand eels to be processed for their oil which was then used as a cheap source of oil for hydrogenated oil products

Also minced for salmon farms. Why no sand eel farms?

rps20180406_224748_047.jpg
 
Last edited:
who eats sand eels? We do as "margarine" A while back there was a furore, factory ships hoovering up sand eels to be processed for their oil which was then used as a cheap source of oil for hydrogenated oil products
----------------- a huge amount of sandeels are caught by the danes in the north sea for fishmeal ----don t think anybody is fishing for sandeels round the channel isles
 
Top