Moan Moan Moan

The Hamble River entrance was the scene of one of my most treasured boating experiences. I had booked a couple of days of training prior to my Yachtmaster practical exam with Robert Avis (sadly now RIP) who was a well known Yachtmaster Examiner, RN Reserve Commander, some time contributor to MBM/MBY and all round good guy. We had a similar experience to the OP in that when we reached the entrance on our way out we were faced with a phalanx of yachts tacking in to the river. I was all ready to turn around and wait until the entrance cleared a bit but Robert instructed me rather sternly to carry on and stick as far to the starboard side of the entrance as was safe to do so I did. Shortly afterwards, a yacht tacked across our bow. There was no danger of a collision because I had come off the power to leave room for him to do this but all the same we got the usual volley of abuse from the crew. Robert got straight onto VHF Channel 16 and hailed the yacht. They answered and he asked to speak to the skipper. He then proceeded to explain who he was and gave the skipper a lecture on the colregs governing narrow channels at the end of which the yacht skipper couldnt apologise enough. The basis of Robert's position was that just because a vessel is a yacht under sail, that does not absolve the yacht from its obligation to keep to the starboard side of the channel. Now I suppose some might argue with that position but all the same it was a beautiful moment:D
 
The Hamble River entrance was the scene of one of my most treasured boating experiences. I had booked a couple of days of training prior to my Yachtmaster practical exam with Robert Avis (sadly now RIP) who was a well known Yachtmaster Examiner, RN Reserve Commander, some time contributor to MBM/MBY and all round good guy. We had a similar experience to the OP in that when we reached the entrance on our way out we were faced with a phalanx of yachts tacking in to the river. I was all ready to turn around and wait until the entrance cleared a bit but Robert instructed me rather sternly to carry on and stick as far to the starboard side of the entrance as was safe to do so I did. Shortly afterwards, a yacht tacked across our bow. There was no danger of a collision because I had come off the power to leave room for him to do this but all the same we got the usual volley of abuse from the crew. Robert got straight onto VHF Channel 16 and hailed the yacht. They answered and he asked to speak to the skipper. He then proceeded to explain who he was and gave the skipper a lecture on the colregs governing narrow channels at the end of which the yacht skipper couldnt apologise enough. The basis of Robert's position was that just because a vessel is a yacht under sail, that does not absolve the yacht from its obligation to keep to the starboard side of the channel. Now I suppose some might argue with that position but all the same it was a beautiful moment:D

That’s one of the best posts I’ve read on here in a long time .
Straight to the facts and truth .
 
Excellent post Deleted User - being the stand on vessel (and "correct") is one thing, being a [insert expletive] and allowing a collision to happen is quite another.
 
We had to short tack a J-80 sports boat up the Hamble in about 4 knots of wind and sail onto the lifting pontoon at the RSYC last year on the Sunday after the round the island race due to our busted outboard engine.

To be honest I felt like a bit of a dick doing this as it was a lovely day, the river was very busy and inconveniencing over water users isn't really a past time of mine.

We apologised to everyone we could pointing out are defunct engine, regardless of our 'right of way' or the endless debate about narrow channels/stand on/power vs sail/overtaking vessel etc it just didn't feel like a sensible thing to do.

Why people set race courses around navigation marks etc in busy rivers expect to have the place to themselves remains a mystery!
 
We had to short tack a J-80 sports boat up the Hamble in about 4 knots of wind and sail onto the lifting pontoon at the RSYC last year on the Sunday after the round the island race due to our busted outboard engine.

To be honest I felt like a bit of a dick doing this as it was a lovely day, the river was very busy and inconveniencing over water users isn't really a past time of mine.

We apologised to everyone we could pointing out are defunct engine, regardless of our 'right of way' or the endless debate about narrow channels/stand on/power vs sail/overtaking vessel etc it just didn't feel like a sensible thing to do.

Why people set race courses around navigation marks etc in busy rivers expect to have the place to themselves remains a mystery!

@xyachtdave - Earlier comment about X boats not giving way was not (as I suspect you know) aimed at your fine craft, but at the XOD fleet of gnarly old sea-dogs.
 
@xyachtdave - Earlier comment about X boats not giving way was not (as I suspect you know) aimed at your fine craft, but at the XOD fleet of gnarly old sea-dogs.

Yes I know...! I don't spend a lot of time in the Solent but am aware of the reputation these craft have!
 
Top