Love is blind.

andy_wilson

Well-Known Member
Joined
16 May 2001
Messages
2,716
Location
S. Yorkshire / Devon
Visit site
Soooo...

Having been a professional boat buyer for about 5 years, and having moved down the housing market to extract equity, a friend (yer a FRIEND, not me!) has bought a rather nice trawler style TSDY in Mallorca.

Survey revealed minor blistering but nothing to worry too much about, and a deal was struck after the ensuing negotiation with the former owner, a German.

Meanwhile engine works started 6 months earlier were approaching completion, under the instruction of the former owner, who assured he would be paying for this. Engineer points out to buyer that debt goes with vessel if unpaid.

Bill of sale competed, and contract stated that the boat was his (the Germans) to sell, and free of any debts or charges. Buyer is English, and broker (and transaction) Spanish.

So we are all off for a jolly between Christmas and New Year when same friend gets a FAX from (English) engineer in Spain advising that as 14,000 Euros bill for engine works has not been settled, intention is to arrest ship, and therefore she must not be moved, used or occupied!

Yes the contract said no debts, yes vendor assured cost of this work would be covered, yes he presented them with a couple of bottles of Champooh, yes he showed them over her and handed over and no he hasn't stood the debt, at least yet.

Soooo..

Anyone know any good lawyers in the UK or Spain (Malloca) with a grasp of the relevant Maritime Laws, Contract Laws, Lien and Arrest etc. so my buddy can extract himself from this situation.

As ultimately it seems the the local engineers don't need to worry too much about chasing the previous encumbent, also any advice for a Brit. in enforcing contract terms entered into by a German under a Spanish contract.

At least I can offer a good English / German interpretor!
 
There is a specialist marine lawyer based at Shamrock Quay, Southampton. I have seen some of his work on this subject and he was impressive. Can't remember his name though, but if you ring the marina manager at Shamrock Quay, I'm sure he will pass on contact details. Rgds.
 
If you can threaten legal action in Germany, that's as long as the contract is legal.
German law is very good at dealing with cases like these.


cheers
Mick

<A target="_blank" HREF=http://homepage.ntlworld.com/boats/>http://homepage.ntlworld.com/boats/</A>
 
Contract law.

We still need to identify under who's law. The contract was carried out in Spain.

We are also considering the brokers duty of care in this matter as he was aware of the works underway (as was the buyer unfortunately, but as I say love is blind!).
 
Re: Contract law.

Have you or the new owner tried contacting the previous owner? It may be a huge misunderstanding and the German chap is going to pay the bill. But if it was me, I'd be tempted to take the money and run, however because I am honest, I would only be slightly tempted!!
 
The buyer was totally stupid not to fax the engineer before paying for the boat, to confirm if bill paid. Engineer even warned him!

However, and not knowing all the facts, there are two ways out (apart from paying the E14k). One is to force German to pay, other is to avoid arrest of vessel. At a guess the second is the better way to go. Get good lawyer to find some reason why the vessel is not subject to lien for the debt, and sail it away.

I wonder if the engineer is trying it on, btw? Like, he has already been paid but would like another E14k? Seems a bit strange that he didn't push for cash from the German before, when he knew the vessel was for sale. He had lots of cards to play then, far fewer now.....
 
Top