Jabsco toilet - rotten egg smell

M

Mandarin331

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 Oct 2008
Messages
791
Location
North Norfolk
Visit site
We have a persistent problem with a rotten egg smell from the toilet when it's been left for a weeks or so. We clean it thoroughly before leaving it, using disinfectant and pump the bowl almost dry, closing both seacocks.

When we return and use it the first time the smell of rotten eggs is horrendous.

The toilet (Jabsco manual) was new last year, with all new white smooth bore sanitary grade hoses.

Can anyone help solve this?
 
This is caused by the reaction in the water left behind to create H2S - bad egg gas. A good dose of white vinegar to descale the pipes will go a long way with this, and we always refill with freshwater afterwards.
 
In my experience this kind of problem is always in the intake side of the flushing system – not in the discharge side. Probably from some rotting seaweed trapped in hose or pipework.
 
The smell is almost certainly caused by bacteria in the sea water within the inlet tube breaking down after a few days. The best way to stop the smell is to fit a system that allows fresh water to be used for flushing the inlet tube when you leave the boat. I fitted this a few years ago and have never had the rotten egg smell since. You can either make the changes yourself using a 3 way diverter valve and some extra tubing or go for something made specifically to combat this problem http://www.leesan.com/bundles/003_fresh_water_flusher.pdf Good luck and rest assured that the problem can be resolved.
 
Agree with others it is H2S decomposing in pipes. Leave only fresh water in the pipes. Most cleaners/soap/detergents are a good source of sulphur so don't be tempted to leave a few drops in the water to keep it sweet. Your nose can detect H2S in very low concentrations, so it doesn't need much.

After flushing the system through with fresh water leave the bowl well filled so in the interval until you next go to the boat fresh water seeps round the flapper valves to keep the pipes full of fresh water.
 
I'd clean the intake line. It's bound to have marine growth in it. Just close the seacock and take the hose off. Use a string down the hose to pull a wad of rag through it.

Don't be tempted to put bleach down either of the hoses ...... you'll damage the through-hulls and seacocks via galvanic action.
 
Further to what others have said, one answer is to install a freshwater flushing kit. This allows you to flush the inlet side of the system when you leave the boat. These are available from Lee Sanitation

www.leesan.co.uk

From the Homepage, go to Information and then Datasheets and look for 003 Freshater Flusher

Hope this helps.
 
I've posted many replys to this question.
(1) purchase best anti smell pipe from ASAP, expensive but solves problem and is easy to fit..
(2) When leaving the boat, pump through water, close inlet valve, pump out, put a kettle full of
fresh water in the bowl, add one tablet or one spoonful of Milton in the bowl, leave for a few minutes and then pump all water out.
I was given these tips several years ago, and have never had toilet smells in the boat since.
 
If you have a vented loop fitted then just sweat a 15mm pipe from the screw valve to a small gauzed deck vent, (similar to a fuel tank vent) worked for me for the last 3 years.

The smell is caused by small plankton type creatures dying in the inlet pipe, nothing you can do about it - it will always come back you just need to get rid of it.
 
all the answers look a bit complicated to me, the simple one (worked for us) is simply fill up with fresh water and pump some out, leaving bowl with decent amount of fresh water in it....job done.
 
We have cured the problem in our boat, fortunately it was plumbed in a way that helps.

Our heads sink drain shares the same seacock as the loo inlet. This allows us to close that seacock, fill the sink with fresh water, and then pump it through the loo, finally close the outlet seacock.

Since adopting this simple procedure when leaving the boat we have had no more smells.

Might it be possible to replumb your vessel to make a similar arrangement?
 
We used to have the smell, but it dissapeared when we installed a new toilet. At the same time we also replaced the inlet hose.

You could try just cleaning or replacing the inlet hose
 
Leighb said:
.

Our heads sink drain shares the same seacock as the loo inlet. This allows us to close that seacock, fill the sink with fresh water, and then pump it through the loo, finally close the outlet seacock.

Since adopting this simple procedure when leaving the boat we have had no more smells.

Might it be possible to replumb your vessel to make a similar arrangement?
Click to expand...

That's a spiffing idea; there are too many holes in the hull as it is. Does normal flushing really only draw in seawater, or does air gurgle in from the empty basin?
 
I can't believe that the trick with fresh water has persisted so long when it is unnecessary. I think it was our own Vyv Cox from these forums who did the experiments with various sea-waters and how much they smelled after being left for a few weeks in an enclosed space. The answe is NOT AT ALL!

The real answer is that the smell is almost certainly from detritus getting past the main pump seal and decomposing in the inlet pipe. Therefore it is not necessary to do complicated things with fresh water, but to make sure that you pump enough seawater through in the first place to get rid of every last bit of effluent. Since we started doing this on our boat, we have eliminated the smells on first flush on return to the boat every time.
 
mustntgrumble said:
Does normal flushing really only draw in seawater, or does air gurgle in from the empty basin?
Click to expand...

I think the plumbing is sufficiently far below the waterline for it not to be a problem, there is obviously some "pulldown" on the sink drain, but bear in mind that it will fill to sealevel if the seacock is open. We have to make sure that the seacocks are shut under sail, as on port tack the sink will overflow if we don't. :( The galley sink does the same on starboard tack.
 
mattnj said:
all the answers look a bit complicated to me, the simple one (worked for us) is simply fill up with fresh water and pump some out, leaving bowl with decent amount of fresh water in it....job done.
Click to expand...

Ditto!! Dont know why you would need to fit a freshwater flushing kit, to use only when you leave the boat.

I used to pump out as much seawater as possible, , close the inlet, then fill the bowl with freshwater, (I used the shower, but you could use a kettle, or anything), and flush it out, before filling it again with freshwater.

Smells were more or less non existent on return.
 
Smelly Loo?

I used to flush through with Bleech until I got fed up of, annually, replacing the seals etc, now I allways flushed through with Toilet Duck, before leaving the boat, sometimes for upto 2 months in the hot Greek summers, and NEVER had smell issues.
Regards,
 
Analysis and Design of Marine Toilet

Student graduation project on Marine Toilet

I am Jan van Dijk and currently working on my graduation project as student Industrial Design Engineering at the Delft University of Technology, the Netherlands.
My graduation project involves analyzing marine toilets. The goal is to eventually design a new marine toilet concept.

The bad smell is one of the toilet problems which could be solved in a new design!

As a part of the first phase of the project, the analysis I created a questionnaire.
in English:
http://enquete.tudelft.nl/nq.cfm?q=5d05c49e-1a4b-d1cb-5048-116f852afcaa&l=en

in Dutch:
http://enquete.tudelft.nl/nq.cfm?q=5d05c49e-1a4b-d1cb-5048-116f852afcaa

This questionnaire will take about 5 minutes of your time.
I will use the questionnaire results to continue my graduation project to eventually come to a well founded marine toilet design. The answers will be treated anonymously and confidentially.

Thank you so much!
With your help I hope to be able to design a great new marine toilet

The comments here are already useful to me! Knowing how marine toilets are used, makes a new toilet design adapted to the usage possible.

Do you have any additional comment regarding marine toilets?
What is the best quality a marine toilet should have? What currently misses on the Marine Toilet market?

Please leave your comment / remark here or at the end of the questionnaire!
Thank you so much for your time and help


With kind regards,
Jan van Dijk



Questionnaire in English:
http://enquete.tudelft.nl/nq.cfm?q=5d05c49e-1a4b-d1cb-5048-116f852afcaa&l=en
Questionnaire in Dutch:
http://enquete.tudelft.nl/nq.cfm?q=5d05c49e-1a4b-d1cb-5048-116f852afcaa
 
Still looks and smells like new!

All of what has been said obviously works, but for the UK climate I have a simple solution which has kept my Heads clean and fragrant to-date.
First as others have said, ensure that anyone using pumps enough water to completely clear the bowl and the discharge pipe, as the pipe can clog-up over time if you don’t.
Second use Toilet-Duck discs as there is no plastic to collect any undesired material.
And finally I use own brand (Morrison’s or Tesco) surface cleaner 98p ish, and use three sprays around the bowl at the end of operation. This I leave hanging by its own handle on the inlet pipe, and ensuring that people new to the boat are politely advised on the procedure to eliminate bad smells on a small boat (part of the boat safety brief).
Started this routine when I replaced my Heads and it still looks and smells like new.
 
Not much help I know if you've only recently installed a new head but having owned (& unblocked) several different types over the years, I'd now only ever fit a Lavac.
Not only super reliable & efficient, but using an enclosed, sealed system the bad egg smell from the inlet pipe is contained during that first flush.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Top