In defence of the Solent!

SNAFU

New Member
Joined
9 Jun 2003
Messages
10
Location
Solent
Visit site
On this and other forums I've read often of how awful the Solent is, and how it really is a place best avoided. In 30 years of sailing, I'd never sailed there until this year - either because I was in different parts of the world or have always sailed on the West coast, or up in Scotland (my favouraite cruising grounds without any doubt).

So, with six months in the Solent, I still can't see the basis for the criticisms. The ONLY two things I find as negatives are the cost of slips (but the rest of the country seems to be catching up) and the 100 radio checks per hour.

The water's not as crowded as I had been led to believe as the vast majority of the boats never seem to leave their slips. I've been through the Solent twice this year when not another boat was seen moving. Honest.

The ferries don't make a wash worth mentioning - have yet to see a wash which would concern anyone in a sailing boat bigger than a dinghy - and I'm including the fast cats, the Wight Link guys and the hovercrafts.

The navigation is painfully easy (does anyone get lost in the Solent?). Actually, this is a negative but will surely be spiced up when I get to sail in some fog. Plenty of opportunity to work the tide tables though. Hey, that's part of the sport!

Broad, protected patches of water, myraid of anchorages, rivers, bays, beaches, wildlife ... it seems to have all of the basics needed for a good trip.

Even in a blow, there seems to be no swell / no waves which is a nice change from, say, the Bristol Channel where a 2 metre swell is perfectly common. Continuing that comparison for a moment, the Solent water is infinitely cleaner, the tides less fierce ....

In getting to know the place, I went out for a solo day sail a few weeks back and sailed round the Isle of Wight. Found an anchorage where I was the only boat (just outside of Yarmouth) ... hey, this place has it all.

To insulate myself from the radio checks, I keep the VHF on but with the volume somewhat muted. I do miss the old fashioned chandlery with marine engineering facilities into which I could ask for the loan of some obscure tool, but I really enjoy the variety of places to go and things to do. As I prefer anchoring to marinas, even the costs of overnighters is not an issue. As to the charter boats, they've been no trouble either.

So I've come to the opinion that this area is faulted not for any real problem other than people are BORED with it. They've been sailing there all of their lives and it's lost the challenge which new cruising grounds represent.

The only question now is whether to stay another year or to move her round to the East Coast or to base Sergeant Pepper up to Scotland for 2004 and see what that's like - sort of like making a circumnavigation in stages?

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
Agree with what you say about the Solent. It's a great place (I've been sailing here for over 20 years) and some of the negative reports are just plain rubbish. Naturally, it gets a bit boring going to the same places but we do a channel hop every now and again and a longer cruise during the summer so this keeps things interesting.

Reading some of the stuff about ferry wash, over crowding and bad manners generally makes me suspect there is something adrift with the poster!

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
Me too.

Been sailing in the Solent about 20 years, love it. I think people that get bored with the solent show a lack of imagination, for example, sunday, wanted to go out for lunch, Folly? Kings Head Yarmouth? Pier View? nope, I went into Fishbourne and to the Fishbourne Inn. If you make the effort you can visit a lot of different places and not have the chance to get bored.

<hr width=100% size=1>Sod the Healey - I think I'll buy an E-Type.
 
I have been sailing Solent since all my life ...

and I am not fed up with it ...... but yes I am one of the posters that complain of some antics and incidents that spoil a good place.

In fact a lot of time I have a good laugh at some of the antics - but also realise that many of them can have serious consequences.

Yes - Solent is good, sheltered and a haven for yotties ...... but I still would like to see other places AND then return to my 'safe bolt-hole' !!!!


<hr width=100% size=1>Nigel ...
Bilge Keelers get up further ! I only came - cos they said there was FREE Guinness !
 
Yup, I agree that the chap (Mr U. Fox I believe), who described it as a playground for yachtsmen built by God, was correct. I love the west country, and am sadly unfamiliar with Celtic waters but nowhere else (in England) but the solent have I found so many safe harbours and anchorages, many with all-tide access, within an easy day's sail of each other. All passages are in sight of scenic, mostly rural, land that offers so many landmarks that eyeball pilotage is the norm. It does get busy but that's hardly surprising and there are more than a few monumental idiots around, (not all of them on pleasure craft,) but such folk have formed a fixed percentage of any human society since the dawn of time, and it is possible to avoid or ignore most of them.

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
You blithering idiot!

I might have known no good would come of Sgt Pepper relocating to Southsea marina. For years we Solent sailors have been telling everybody who would listen how awful the Solent is, to keep them from coming themselves. And now some Johnny come lately from the Brizzel Channel (of all mud infested hell-holes) has to go and sing its praises. Won't be able to get a pint anywhere between Gosport and Keyhaven without a ten-minute queue next season. Thanks!!!!

<hr width=100% size=1><A target="_blank" HREF=http://www.writeforweb.com/twister1>Let's Twist Again</A>
 
Re: You blithering idiot!

There is actually only 2 foot tidal range in the Bristol Channel ,White sand beaches and free marinas. Dont tell anyone or they will all come here.

Seriously though I have sailed in the Solent a few times and would like to spend a few weeks exploring it.Theres such a huge choice of places to visit within an easy day sail.
 
Still busier than 5 years ago

Midweek, the solent is a delight but it has definitely got busier at weekends since it was 5 years ago.It is virtually impossble to get a visitors berth in any of the popular spots on a Saturday unless you have booked in advance,are part of a yacht club rally or go in so early that it defeats the object of going sailing.

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
Tidal range ....

I seem to remember when I took coasters up to Avonmouth and Bury that there was an incredible tide rush / range ..... must be age destroying my memory !!!!


<hr width=100% size=1>Nigel ...
Bilge Keelers get up further ! I only came - cos they said there was FREE Guinness !
 
OK -- Ha Ha .....

At least someones got a sense of humour after maths on PBO Reader 2 Reader !!!!


<hr width=100% size=1>Nigel ...
Bilge Keelers get up further ! I only came - cos they said there was FREE Guinness !
 
Re: Tidal range ....

Yes your memories playing tricks on you.Once you get past Lundy its .Palm trees white sand and turquoise water.

Tide is barely noticeable,free beer in the pubs.

This of course is the WELSH side. Other side has brown water,black mud 12 meter tides etc etc....

<hr width=100% size=1>
 
Top