whipper_snapper
Well-Known Member
Isn't it all about the voltage gradients experienced by the person in the water ? 1.1 Amps passing straight through you will certainly be lethal, but to achieve that you need a big voltage gradient across your body; 12V will not do it - put one hand on a 12V battery + and the other on the -ve, you will not die because you are not a good enough conductor, if you put an ammeter in series with one hand, the current measured would be minute. If you did this underwater, the only difference is that you would make better electrical contact with the terminals so the current that you experience would go up very slightly.
If there is a positive electrode at 12V relative to a negative electrode and they are separated by 12 metres of water then the gradient will be 1V/m, and a swimmer 2m tall perfectly aligned between those terminals will feel only a 2V differential between his head and his feet and will come to no harm. The fact that he is wet will not change things much. It makes little difference if it is salt water or fresh, the current through the water would be different, but the swimmer's conductivity is about the same, so the current he feels is about the same.
Have you seen those terrifying videos of people crawling along high tension power cables They survive because they don't put their body across a voltage differential. If they crawled across a bad bit of cable with a high resistance they would fry, hence the metal underwear.
If there is a positive electrode at 12V relative to a negative electrode and they are separated by 12 metres of water then the gradient will be 1V/m, and a swimmer 2m tall perfectly aligned between those terminals will feel only a 2V differential between his head and his feet and will come to no harm. The fact that he is wet will not change things much. It makes little difference if it is salt water or fresh, the current through the water would be different, but the swimmer's conductivity is about the same, so the current he feels is about the same.
Have you seen those terrifying videos of people crawling along high tension power cables They survive because they don't put their body across a voltage differential. If they crawled across a bad bit of cable with a high resistance they would fry, hence the metal underwear.