Danforth advice

Might be worth looking at Fortress - probably the FX11.
I have the budget version of fortress in my shed, never used. It's called a Guardian. I bought it at a boat jumble (remember them) the light weight aluminium construction is very useful it can be hurled some distance but unfortunately the boat it was intended for has now been sold.
 
My local seabeds are sand and muddy sand mainly, occasionally mud. Not planning on going too far immediately, but I want to know that when I can't get a paid mooring mid summer that I can sleep fairly easily once I'm confident the anchor has set.
Not looking to swap the CQR for the Danforth, and not bothered about weight. Much more inclined to go down the low cost 'horses for courses' route than the 'one size fits all wonder anchor' at this stage. That may change with time as I venture further afield.
Cost is a problem as I've burnt through the 'boat fund' and now have to go cap in hand to the wife. My brownie points are going down like a lead mooring buoy.
Will give facehole marketplace a go, thanks.

We never slept easily with our CQR lookalike, it dragged if baked beans were on the menu. I suggest you look around for one of the new generation anchors (maybe second hand) to replace that, we replaced ours with a Manson Supreme which so far hasn't let us down. Our Fortress is only used as a kedge.
 
I have the budget version of fortress in my shed, never used. It's called a Guardian. I bought it at a boat jumble (remember them) the light weight aluminium construction is very useful it can be hurled some distance but unfortunately the boat it was intended for has now been sold.
Do you want to sell it?
 
My local seabeds are sand and muddy sand mainly, occasionally mud. Not planning on going too far immediately, but I want to know that when I can't get a paid mooring mid summer that I can sleep fairly easily once I'm confident the anchor has set.

Not looking to swap the CQR for the Danforth, and not bothered about weight. Much more inclined to go down the low cost 'horses for courses' route than the 'one size fits all wonder anchor' at this stage. That may change with time as I venture further afield.

Cost is a problem as I've burnt through the 'boat fund' and now have to go cap in hand to the wife. My brownie points are going down like a lead mooring buoy.

Will give facehole marketplace a go, thanks.

We sold our Fortress FX 16 last year, still in the sealed box we had used it that much :rolleyes:

Replaced it with a 13lb Danforth copy, all be it with a sticker saying Dutton-Lainson. They used to be really expensive at £150 for a 3Kg version. today cheap as chips on FB Market Place. I think we paid £20. We already had a spare rode so its ready to go with 50m of short chain and rope when needed.

I wouldn't get too hung up on good or bad Danforths or the copies, we just chose something that looked like it might penetrate the seabed and was light enough to be easily carried in case we need to use the dinghy to deploy it as a kedge.

I thought it was interesting watching Steve's videos, the fortress didn't do as well as I expected compared to the Danforths.

Since the budget is limited, you might search for a Kobra 2 anchor in place of the CQR copy. Might take a while to find a second hand one but the have a good reputation but without the bling and kudos price tags. You could always paint the tip yellow, fish won't notice the difference.

Pete
 
We sold our Fortress FX 16 last year, still in the sealed box we had used it that much :rolleyes:

Replaced it with a 13lb Danforth copy, all be it with a sticker saying Dutton-Lainson. They used to be really expensive at £150 for a 3Kg version. today cheap as chips on FB Market Place. I think we paid £20. We already had a spare rode so its ready to go with 50m of short chain and rope when needed.

I wouldn't get too hung up on good or bad Danforths or the copies, we just chose something that looked like it might penetrate the seabed and was light enough to be easily carried in case we need to use the dinghy to deploy it as a kedge.

I thought it was interesting watching Steve's videos, the fortress didn't do as well as I expected compared to the Danforths.

Since the budget is limited, you might search for a Kobra 2 anchor in place of the CQR copy. Might take a while to find a second hand one but the have a good reputation but without the bling and kudos price tags. You could always paint the tip yellow, fish won't notice the difference.

Pete
Thanks Pete7. Kobra was one of the front runners for the replacement and they're reasonably priced. Quite a bit of talk on the Hunter forum (she's an Horizon 272) about whether one will fit in the anchor locker and there's not much room to have it permanently on the bow roller.

Those anchor videos are interesting and very thorough, especially the later ones. The wife got so sick of hearing his voice banging on about anchors in the background though, I don't think it's helped my cause ?
 
... I thought it was interesting watching Steve's videos, the fortress didn't do as well as I expected compared to the Danforths....

They are similar on a size basis and 150% better on a weight basis, in soft mud, which is their forte'. Around here, that is all we us them for, where they out-hold other designs by 3:1 on a weight basis. Guardian is very nearly as good (I've owned and used several of each).

Knockoffs are all over the place. I've had winners and others that either didn't set or bent and were binned (I would not give them away if crap--that's like giving away crap rock climbing gear). Some are fairly good. Many break (bad welds) or fail to set reliably (slightly different fluke profile can make a big difference), which makes them... useless if not reliable. I actually took grinder to one, duplicating the Danforth fluke profile, and it was much better.

I would not pay 10c for a knockoff unless you find a possive review from someone you know.
 
US east coast sailors use Fortress a lot, but only as a soft mud storm anchor, kedge, or stern/V-tandem anchor. Very seldom as the bower, even in soft mud areas; they don't like wind or tide shifts unless rigged in a wide V.
 
Worth checking out the Kobra 2 WLane as I have fitted a 10 kg happily in a locker for which the 9kg CQR was very tight.The fact that the Kobra demounts gives sufficient wiggle to reduce the height under the cover.It also self launches happily on an extended bow roller.
 
Jonathan, we know that you, having a lightweight catamaran, worship light ground tackle, but would you not concede that being so dismissive of Danforth anchors is rather incongruous, when you admit that your only experience of such anchors, is ONE occasion, when it performed perfectly? The OP is looking for a relatively small and cheap anchor for occasional use in mud and sand, for which a Danforth would be fine.

In his OP he does not mention seabed types, so I have to assume he might want or need to anchor in weed or there may be oyster shells in the mud.

I have freely admitted that my experience of a genuine Danforth is one occasion - it is very clear. I have mentioned that I carry 2 Fortress and use one of them when we anchor in a 'V' and the other when we anchor in soupy mud.

The OP made no mention of a windlass and retrieving 30m of 8mm chain and a Danforth anchor sitting on the bow of a 27' yacht will be hard work in any breeze.

What more can I say.

It merits note the OP opened by saying he had reasons that he wanted to carry a Danforth, which he did not initially explain - but I have to assume those reasons are valid to him. The OP also said or implied he wanted a genuine Danforth. There may be good copies but I don't know - I made my position clear - I've used a genuine one once. I have not noticed a rash of posts saying that any 'copy' Danforth is good (or bad) - how precisely do you define a copy that has no name on it.....?

The OP needs a decent reliable versatile modern anchor, I gave a list to choose from, once he has that anchor on board he can then decide if he wants a Danforth, or to my mind and many here would agree, a Fortress/Guardian.. I do think he should have a second anchor - it broadens his scope of seabeds in which he can anchor and a spare is always useful (people do lose anchors).

I choose aluminium anchors because they are light and I find, contrary to many who have never used an aluminium Spade or Excel, they work as well as their steel counterparts. I choose aluminium because our catamaran is weight sensitive and in the event that my windlass stops working (which it has done - (a self inflicted fault - loose cable) they are easy to retreive by hand.

I have no problem with others using steel anchors, their yachts might not be so weight sensitive. Aluminium anchors tend to be more expensive that their steel counter parts. But I don't think many on this forum carry full sized steel Danforths most if they want that style carry an aluminium Fortress/Guardian (despite the cost) - Many carry a Fortress/Guardian simply because it is aluminium and thus light as they want a second anchor but not the weight.

Summarising I have tried to point the member in a slightly different direction to his opening post, I have made little mention of my beliefs of anchor perfroaqmcne - except get one from my very broad list and then consider the Danforth type. If nothing else a genuine Danforth, or a recommended copy - in steel is going to be a devil to stow (on a 27' yacht - with 30m of 8mm chain).

To me the OP has 2 mistakes - focussing on a genuine Danforth (without defining why the Danforth) and buying the 30m of 8mm chain prior to requesting advise. The OP can live with the 30m of 8mm chain, hopefully he is young and has a good chiropractor :). Change the focus from Danforth to a decent reliable anchor - and then consider what for a second anchor.

Stay safe, take care

Jonathan
 
In his OP he does not mention seabed types, so I have to assume he might want or need to anchor in weed or there may be oyster shells in the mud.

I have freely admitted that my experience of a genuine Danforth is one occasion - it is very clear. I have mentioned that I carry 2 Fortress and use one of them when we anchor in a 'V' and the other when we anchor in soupy mud.

The OP made no mention of a windlass and retrieving 30m of 8mm chain and a Danforth anchor sitting on the bow of a 27' yacht will be hard work in any breeze.

What more can I say.

It merits note the OP opened by saying he had reasons that he wanted to carry a Danforth, which he did not initially explain - but I have to assume those reasons are valid to him. The OP also said or implied he wanted a genuine Danforth. There may be good copies but I don't know - I made my position clear - I've used a genuine one once. I have not noticed a rash of posts saying that any 'copy' Danforth is good (or bad) - how precisely do you define a copy that has no name on it.....?

The OP needs a decent reliable versatile modern anchor, I gave a list to choose from, once he has that anchor on board he can then decide if he wants a Danforth, or to my mind and many here would agree, a Fortress/Guardian.. I do think he should have a second anchor - it broadens his scope of seabeds in which he can anchor and a spare is always useful (people do lose anchors).

I choose aluminium anchors because they are light and I find, contrary to many who have never used an aluminium Spade or Excel, they work as well as their steel counterparts. I choose aluminium because our catamaran is weight sensitive and in the event that my windlass stops working (which it has done - (a self inflicted fault - loose cable) they are easy to retreive by hand.

I have no problem with others using steel anchors, their yachts might not be so weight sensitive. Aluminium anchors tend to be more expensive that their steel counter parts. But I don't think many on this forum carry full sized steel Danforths most if they want that style carry an aluminium Fortress/Guardian (despite the cost) - Many carry a Fortress/Guardian simply because it is aluminium and thus light as they want a second anchor but not the weight.

Summarising I have tried to point the member in a slightly different direction to his opening post, I have made little mention of my beliefs of anchor perfroaqmcne - except get one from my very broad list and then consider the Danforth type. If nothing else a genuine Danforth, or a recommended copy - in steel is going to be a devil to stow (on a 27' yacht - with 30m of 8mm chain).

To me the OP has 2 mistakes - focussing on a genuine Danforth (without defining why the Danforth) and buying the 30m of 8mm chain prior to requesting advise. The OP can live with the 30m of 8mm chain, hopefully he is young and has a good chiropractor :). Change the focus from Danforth to a decent reliable anchor - and then consider what for a second anchor.

Stay safe, take care

Jonathan

I didn't want to elaborate too much in the OP as I didn't want to elicit anchor rage, apologies if it may have had the opposite effect.

What I asked in the OP was in effect; 'I can't get an original Danforth, I feel one would suit my purposes for the next couple of years, what are others' opinions on readily available alternatives?' I've had really useful replies, thanks everyone.

In response to you being so concerned about my chain Neeves, I'm in my 30s and as a builder I pick up heavy weights all day. A bit of 8mm chain is naff all in the scheme of my future chiropractor's scope of works. It won't go too waste should I feel it's excessive in practice.
 
In response to you being so concerned about my chain Neeves, I'm in my 30s and as a builder I pick up heavy weights all day. A bit of 8mm chain is naff all in the scheme of my future chiropractor's scope of works. It won't go too waste should I feel it's excessive in practice.

If you are happy, I am ecstatic. :)

Jonathan
 
Op should get down the nearest boat jumble. Plenty of choice there, and trouble with eBay anchors is their bulk/weight often means seller won’t post.
Fortress . I have had to rely on my FX 11 more than once in rough conditions to say the least. So far as I am concerned it did the job and gets my vote. By the way neither me nor the lifeboat could haul it up when taking me in tow. On a previous time had to leave it behind and come back at low tide and dig it out. Boy was it buried in sand.
 
Fortress . I have had to rely on my FX 11 more than once in rough conditions to say the least. So far as I am concerned it did the job and gets my vote. By the way neither me nor the lifeboat could haul it up when taking me in tow. On a previous time had to leave it behind and come back at low tide and dig it out. Boy was it buried in sand.

When using ours as a kedge, I attach a trip line so I can pull it up from the tender.
 
When we parked on a beach in our Snapdragon, I tended to set the kedge fairly well astern, and make sure it's well dug in - by hand after the tide's gone out, if necessary. That way I can use it to pull us off before we're fully afloat. (I don't do patient :D ) Now we've got a cat with twin diesels, I rather think I'd rely on them more, but that's one of the things I need to try out this year.
 
When we parked on a beach in our Snapdragon, I tended to set the kedge fairly well astern, and make sure it's well dug in - by hand after the tide's gone out, if necessary. That way I can use it to pull us off before we're fully afloat. (I don't do patient :D ) Now we've got a cat with twin diesels, I rather think I'd rely on them more, but that's one of the things I need to try out this year.

When we beach - we run in, gently, astern until the keels hit the sand. We leave the engine running at low revs in reverse and I set an anchor off each transom, aluminium anchors (commonly with a short length of chain and the rode predominately dyneema). If we kill the engines early or don't set the stern anchors it is easy to be blown off line if there is a breeze and bit of chop. We then winch the rodes taut (sheet winches) and kill the engines. When the tide has retreated a bit more Josephine drops an appropriate amount of chain off the windlass and I drag chain and anchor forward and. set the anchor, dug in, then hold the anchor under tension utill the tide has receded. We may stay over night, well secured, but when we leave I retreive the 2 stern anchors and as the hulls are lifted use a winch to keep the rode under tension - and we then 'pop off'. We tend to deploy 20m of rode, that's a 10:1 scope as it means we can rely on the anchor until we are well clear of shallow water and more sand.

As we come in astern we leave forward - when the props are more efficient (and sand is not sucked through the water intakes on the saildrives).

Jonathan
 
I've always gone in forwards (monohull) because I wanted the keels to ground first. My preferred tactic is to go in on a falling tide, drop the kedge on the way in and go slow ahead against the keels in the sand until they're firmly aground. I think I'd do much the same on Jazzcat, as she'd probably ground on the rudders, though if there's a significant slope, astern would have the advantage that the bed would slope the right way.
 
Hmm. We try quite hard to stay afloat. ?
Seriously, if/when we use a second anchor, we always have a tripping line and buoy on it. Not so much for retrieval, but to give us and others an indication of its position, and crucially, in case we have to leave in a hurry, when we can just let it go and pick it up later.
 
Top